Critical Race Theory: A Critique
Author(s):
Conference:
ECER 2008
Format:
Paper

Session Information

07 SES 05A, Interacting Inequalities

Paper Session

Time:
2008-09-11
08:30-10:00
Room:
BE 016
Chair:
Chris Gaine

Contribution

Critical Race Theory (CRT) has for a numbers of years been a popular theory embraced by ‘race’ theorists in the USA. CRT is now rapidly gaining world-wide prominence. CRT theorists claim to present an explanatory theory of racism in contemporary global society. I argue that the popularity of CRT has not been subjected to sufficient critique, it is therefore my intention to offer such a critique in order to raise important questions with respect to the underlying premises of CRT, and posit an alternative framework using the concept of racialisation vis-à-vis these challenges. Part 1 of this paper begins by suggesting that CRT’s prioritising of “white supremacy” is misplaced and confused because it is essentialist. I argue that the CRT assertion that education policy is designed on the back of white supremacist thinking is inherently misconstrued, furthermore, I reject the idea that white people are a homogenous group in positions of power and privilege; as their account of ‘whiteness’ is as argued by CRT theorists. Moreover, I believe that CRT confuses far-right Nazi-inspired and eugenics movements with everyday capitalist imperialist practices, a discourse facilitated by racialisation. In Part 2 of the paper I go on to argue that CRT’s valorising of ‘race’ over social class (and other identities such as gender and forms of structural oppression) makes it unable to connect to modes of production, and thus renders it limited in explaining various manifestations of racism, which are related to moments and developments in the capital accumulation process. This critique will propose an analysis that acknowledges class-based racialised (and gendered) social relations of production in a neo-liberal global capitalist society. In Part 3, I argue the case for the Marxist concept of racialisation. I believe that racialisation has more purchase in explaining and understanding contemporary racism because it links racism to modes of production. Furthermore, I develop this concept to incorporate aspects xenophobia to recognise non-colour coded racism. The dynamics of racism are captured through the theory of xeno-racialisation to offer a more comprehensive and critical account of racially charged forms of oppression, especially pertinent in the light of the expansion of the European Union and global movements of people. Even in countries that enjoy relatively harmonious social relations and exponential increases in immigration, the emergence of CRT has significant implications, especially in relation to Teaching and Learning practice. CRT potentially offers far-reaching changes in the way in which teachers and lecturers approach issues of, inter alia: immigration, racism, and social cohesion, terrorism; in the class room. In part 3 of my paper I suggest those involved with teaching need be critical when adopting CRT in their practice. For example, I argue that the usage of ‘race’ needs to be explored as a socially constructed identity, and the challenges that follow from this need to tackled rather than essentialised and thereby glossed over. In CRT the notion of ‘race’ is not deconstructed and therefore remains unproblematised. I also argue that students need to appreciate the importance of imperialism, what can be called ‘new imperialism’ as seen in Iraq; also, the remnants of old empire. Without knowledge of historical trajectories within modes of production, it is easy for students and teachers to buy into CRT and provide an incomprehensive and critically blunted analysis of racism. My paper is designed for two purposes: to provoke critique of CRT; and to promote an analysis that locates racism within modes of production.

Expected Outcomes

Although Critical Race Theory has been popular in the USA for a number of years, it is only now beginning to be discussed in Europe and Australia. This paper is designed to contribute to those discussions about racism and develop a critique that will advance the theory by incorporating a social class dimension, and to be relevant to analyses of racism outside of the US context.

References

Cole, M. and Maisuria, A. (2008) Critical Race Theory and Education. Journal for Critical Education Policy Studies. The Institute for Education Policy Studies, Vol 5, No1 Cole, M. (2007a) Marxism in Education Theory: origins and issues, London: Routledge Darder, A. and Torres, R. D. (2004) After Race: Racism after Multiculturalism, New York and London: New York University Press Delgado, R. (1995) The Rodrigo Chronicles: Conversations about America and Race, New York: New York University Press. Gillborn, D. (2005) “Education Policy as an Act of White Supremacy: Whiteness, Critical Race Theory and Education Reform”, Journal of Education Policy, 20 (4) July, pp. 485-505 Gillborn, D. (2006) “Critical Race Theory and Education: Racism and antiracism in educational theory and praxis”, Discourse: studies in the cultural politics of education, 27 (1), pp. 11-32. Leonardo, Z (2004) “The Unhappy Marriage between Marxism and Race Critique: Political Economy and the Production of Racialized Knowledge”, Policy Futures in Education, 2 (3 & 4), pp. 483-493. Online. Available HTTP: http://www.wwwords.co.uk/pfie/content/pdfs/2/issue2_3.asp#4 (accessed 19 July 2007) Miles, R. (1989) Racism, London: Routledge. “Rac-ing Forward” Northampton University: Maisuria, A. and Martin, C. (2008) “Those Polish, they’re coming here and taking all our jobs”: A Critical Analysis of Critical Race Theory in Britain. Centre for Sociology, Anthropology and Politics (C-SAPs). The Higher Education Academy A full reference list can be provided upon request

Author Information

University of Wolverhampton
Education Studies
London

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.