Transnational Knowledge: Emergence and Use of Common and Professional Knowledge in Transnational Spaces - Case Studies of Transmigrants in Germany
Author(s):
Caroline Schmitt (presenting / submitting) Tina Hollstein (presenting)
Conference:
ECER 2012
Format:
Poster

Session Information

06 SES 05.5 PS, General Poster Exhibition

General Poster Session during Lunch

Time:
2012-09-19
12:30-14:00
Room:
FCEE - Poster Exhibition Area
Chair:

Contribution

The concept of transnationalism is an analytical paradigm to analyze cross-border practices of individuals, groups, organizations and policies. Using this approach, actors become visible in their mobilities and are not reduced to national spheres of action by a methodological nationalism (WIMMER/GLICK SCHILLER 2002). The importance of the nation state is not negated here, but gets complemented by a wider perspective, which allows capturing local, regional, national and transnational spaces in their interactions (GLICK SCHILLER/LEVITT 2006).
This paper focus on the interactions between actor’s transnational knowledge emergence and transformation in different local, regional, national and transnational spaces and the new forms of knowledge that are constituted here. Our paper can be seen as an attempt to overcome the traditional understanding of knowledge as a closed 'box', because it is involved in many different ways of cross-border processes in which it is generated, transformed and used.
An approach which systematically combines questions of transnationalism with questions of knowledge has not been developed so far.

We would like to highlight on the basis of two empirical case studies how certain forms of transnational knowledge get generated by transmigrants and how they are used as cross-border socio-economic resource. The concept of knowledge is thereby defined in an action-theoretical perspective as a source that enables people to act and to create their lifeworlds (KOCH 2006).

The cases of two transmigrants in Germany show that actors cross national borders to design professional and/or common knowledge as coping strategies in the context of their transnational lifeworlds: Mrs. Assogba acquires knowledge to professional uses with the aim to establish an Afro Hair Salon in Germany and to fulfill a long cherished career aspiration. While it is not possible to learn the specific Afrohairstyles in Germany because of the lack of Afro Hair schools on site, she travels in her African home country and to London and Paris, where the Afro Hair Business is more established, to learn the techniques and to adapt the knowledge she needs to open a salon in Germany. Mr. Savinov is generating a specific knowledge through his migratory labour between Germany and the republic of Moldova. He acquires a certain theoretical and technical knowledge about house building in Germany which he transforms to his home village in order to build a new house with a higher standard of living. In adoption to the circumstances in his village, he develops new ways of for example establishing a water supply system. In this context, he creates new strategies of income which also base on generated transnational knowledge for financing his project.

Till today, the acquirement and use of knowledge of actors who are not categorized as „highly-skilled“ and not involved in any knowledge networks or scientific communities does get overlooked in research about cross-border knowledge processes. This is problematic as it is exactly this kind of knowledge, which is particularly relevant to the agency of actors at different spatial and social, economic and political contexts and of course for the discipline of Educational Sciences.

Method

The analysis is based on examples from two different ongoing dissertation projects which are both dealing with questions of transmigration. Caroline Schmitt is using an ethnographic design to analyze social and economic facets of space along Afro Hair Salons in Germany. The salons can be seen as transnational places which get analyzed in their specific meaning for owners and visitors, whose lifeworlds span across several nation-states. Tina Hollstein is examining processes of illegal migration from a transnational perspective. She is focusing on the topics of social support and on different coping practices of several actors. She has conducted qualitative interviews. In both projects, the analysis of the conducted material is done in orientation on the methodology of Grounded Theory (STRAUSS 1994). The authors use specific elements of different 'line-by-line' analysis methods (STRAUSS 2004; WERNET 2009) and methods of CLARKE´s Situational Analysis (2003). Concerning methodology, a multi-sited approach (MARCUS 1995) is suitable to research in transnational knowledge processes as the approach refers to the movements of actors, things and ideas in different spaces analogous to the criticism of methodological nationalism. Because of that, the authors follow people and things across different spaces and/or reconstruct their movements.

Expected Outcomes

The results show that the actor´s life strategies span across national borders and go ‘hand-in-hand’ with a partly-planned acquisition of knowledge, which precedes the emergence of transnational knowledge and plays a central role for their agency. The acquired knowledge is used to develop professional perspectives in Germany as well as to increase the economic benefits of migrant labor and living standards in the country of origin. The actors do an innovative act of knowledge emergence, from which arises a knowledge that is characterized by a combination and connection of the various local knowledge facets anchored in different nation states. It cannot be described only as an addition of different knowledge aspects. Transnational knowledge represents knowledge that arises from the combination of specific local, regional and national knowledge aspects in their transformation into something new. For Educational Sciences, it is important to recognize actor´s transnational knowledge and encourage it as a resource in their lifeworlds. This also includes the identification of social structures, which undermine people´s (transnational) agency. Educational Sciences in this sense is understood as an actor-oriented discipline, which should be involved simultaneously in the identification of actor´s resources and the creation of supportive frameworks.

References

CLARKE, A. E. (2003): Situational Analysis: Grounded Theory Mapping After the Postmodern Turn. In: Symbolic Interaction 26 (4), S. 553-576. GLICK SCHILLER, N./LEVITT, P. (2006): Haven´t we heard this somewhere before? A Substantive View of Transnational Migration Studies by Way of a Reply to Waldinger and Fitzgerald. Working Paper Series. Princeton University. In: http://cmd.princeton.edu/papers/wp0601.pdf (26.11.2011) KOCH, G. (2006): Internationalisierung von Wissen. In: KOCH, G. (Hrsg.): Internationalisierung von Wissen. Multidisziplinäre Beiträge zu neuen Praxen des Wissenstransfers. St. Ingbert, S. 11-23. MARCUS, G. E. (1995): Ethnography in/of the World System: The Emergence of Multi-Sited Ethnography. In: Annual Review of Anthropology 24, S. 95-117. STRAUSS, A. L. (2004): Analysis through Microscopic Examination. In: sozialersinn (2), S. 169-176. STRAUSS, A. L. (1994): Grundlagen qualitativer Sozialforschung. München. WERNET, A. (2009): Einführung in die Interpretationstechnik der Objektiven Hermeneutik. 3. Auflage. Wiesbaden. WIMMER, A./GLICK SCHILLER, N. (2002): Methodological Nationalism and Beyond: Nation-State Building, Migration, and the Social Sciences. In: Global Networks 2 (4), S. 301-334.

Author Information

Caroline Schmitt (presenting / submitting)
Research Center of Social and Cultural Studies/University of Mainz
Institute of Educational Sciences
Mainz
Tina Hollstein (presenting)
University of Mainz
Institute of Educational Science
Mainz

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.