Beyond Competence, Thinking Through the Changes: Economy, Work and Neo-Liberalism
Author(s):
James Avis (presenting / submitting)
Conference:
ECER 2015
Format:
Paper

Session Information

02 SES 05 B, Competence in VET: Transitions in Perspectives

Paper Session

Time:
2015-09-09
11:00-12:30
Room:
324. [Main]
Chair:
Margaret Eleanor Malloch
Discussant:
Trine Deichman-Sørensen

Contribution

The paper considers workplace learning, cognitive capitalism and conceptualisations of competence. This discussion needs to be set within the wider socio-economic context characterised by an increasingly turbulent environment in which the old certainties surrounding industrial Fordism of jobs for life have been found wanting. This is particularly the case in societies closely wedded to neo-liberalism such as the US and UK. These societies are marked by significant inequalities of wealth and income, polarised labour markets, as well as substantial levels of underemployment, unemployment and over-qualification. Economic turbulence allied to underemployment, unemployment and over-qualification has been a longstanding characteristic of waged labour in the emerging economies and is increasingly found in continental Europe, even though here the hegemony of neo-liberalism is somewhat softened. For some writers the logic of capitalist development anticipates forms of social production which carry progressive possibilities whereas for others the prognostication is much bleaker. The paper explores these debates as they serve to frame the manner in which we make sense of and engage with notions of competence and knowledge. The paper draws on discussions of vocationalism, vocational pedagogy as well as what constitutes vocational knowledge, debates which are set within particular historic, socio-economic and national contexts. It points towards the limitations of analyses of workplace learning and in so doing draws upon conceptualisations of 'really useful knowledge' and subject based disciplinary knowledge. Workplace learning can easily fold over into an instrumentalism concerned with enhancing variable labour power. The paper argues for a recognition of the articulation between practice-based and employer interests in VET which are set against wider disciplinary understandings and access to powerful and transformative knowledge. It is suggested that disciplinary knowledge, when allied to workplace experience, can be appropriated by oppressed and marginalised groups thereby becoming 'really useful knowledge' that can be marshalled in the struggle for social justice. This then is the pedagogic challenge - to open up possibilities that themselves presage not only the transformation of practice but also social relations. The notion of competence, as Sawchuk (2009) suggests, is a floating signifier with its meaning varying over time, from society to society, as well as in relation to the particular occupational task addressed. Not only do we encounter this fluidity, but the term will be embedded in vocational education and training policy discourses in distinctive ways. In the paper I have set myself the task of bring together and relating literature that has addressed workplace learning, competency as well as changes in the capitalist mode of production.

Method

There is a particular difficulty in the analysis of competence and its relationship to capitalism. This arises in part as a consequence of the level of the analysis with the notion being derived from and related to specific social formations, and in part because of this specificity and the fluidity of the term. Not only do we encounter this fluidity, but the notion of competence is embedded in vocational education and training policy discourse in distinctive ways. Thus the notion of competence will carry varying meanings in different VET systems and can straddle narrow job specific definitions, as found in Anglo-Saxon models, to more holistic ones as seen in Germany. Alongside these differences shaped by national VET systems, the European Qualification Framework seeks to create a structure based on learning outcomes that aims to facilitate labour mobility across the EU (for discussion see Méhaut & Winch 2012). This is not discounting national variations in the way in which competence is conceived and enacted in VET training systems. Brockmann, Clarke & Winch (2011) have usefully explored the different linguistic meanings attached to the term across the EU and in particular those found in English, French, Dutch and German.

Expected Outcomes

We should rethink and move beyond the notion of competence, resuscitating its progressive elements. Competence has always been concerned with more than waged labour, being a site of struggle. Importantly the notions of competence and education are multifaceted, carrying a range of contradictory meanings. Following Workerist analyses the focus on competence could be viewed as a strategy to pacify the working class, being capital’s response to worker resistance to Fordism. These discussions raise important questions. For some social production, co-configuration, mass customisation and the development of open source software, carry progressive and democratic possibilities (Benkler, 2006; Guile, 2010; Engeström, 2010). Theories of cognitive capitalism provide a corrective, illustrating the way in which capital seeks to appropriate and valorise such practices. Despite the difficulties surrounding the notion of the 'refusal' of work, it nevertheless raises questions about the nature of work in capitalist societies, pointing towards different ways of organising social and political life. Whilst these analyses may be limited they pose questions that problematise approaches to WPL that seek to align this with a progressive politics and social justice commitment. Workerism makes an important contribution to discussions of WPL, and VET, forcing us to think beyond productivist conceptualisations of competence.

References

Avis, J. (2010) Workplace learning, knowledge, practice and transformation, Journal for Critical Education Policy Studies 8(2) December 2010, p165 -193, URL: http://www.jceps.com/?pageID=article&articleID=197 Benkler, Y (2006) The Wealth of Networks: How Social Production Transforms Markets and Freedom, New Haven, Yale University Press Boutang, Y. M., (2011) Cognitive Capitalism, Cambridge, Polity Brockmann, M., Clarke, L., Winch, C., Hanf, G., Méhaut, P., Westerhuis, A. (2011) Interpretive dictionary: competence, qualification, education, knowledge, Brockmann, M., in Clarke, L., Winch, C., with Hanf, G., Méhaut, P., Westerhuis, A. (Eds) Knowledge, Skills and competence in the European Labour market, London, Routledge Engeström, Y. (2010) From teams to knots: activity-theoretical studies of collaboration and learning at work, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, paperback edition Guile, D. (2010) Learning Challenge of the knowledge Economy, Rotterdam, Sense Publishers Méhaut, P., Winch, C. (2012) The European Qualification Framework: skills, competences or Knowledge, European Education Research Journal, 11(3) p369-381 Mulder, M. (2014) Conceptions of professional competence, Billett, S., Harteis, C., Gruber, H. (Eds) International Handbook of Research in Professional and practice-based learning, Dordrecht, Springer p107-137 Sawchuk, P. Labour perspectives on the new politics of skill and competence formation: International reflections, Illeris, K. (Ed) International Perspectives on Competence Development, London, Routledge, p124-138

Author Information

James Avis (presenting / submitting)
University of Huddersfield
Education
Huddersfield

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.