A Real Girl – Thin-skinned and Chicken-hearted: Gender Stereotypes in the Novels that are Part of Primary School Readings in Serbia
Author(s):
Jelena Stefanovic (submitting) Dragica PavlovicBabic (presenting)
Conference:
ECER 2017
Format:
Paper

Session Information

07 SES 10 B, Gender Stereotypes, Sexual Harassment and Discrimination

Paper Session

Time:
2017-08-24
15:30-17:00
Room:
W3.17
Chair:
Sandra Girbés-Peco

Contribution

The main research questions explored in this paper are the following: Which gender stereotypes are present in the novels that are on the required reading list for the second cycle of primary education? What socialization role do they have considering the age and educational experience of students? Implications and recommendations derived from the findings examine the possibility of introducing gender perspective into the mother tongue school program, answering the question of how to teach students to interpret the school readings outside the strict framework imposed by an androcentric interpretative community.

Therefore, the main objective is to document the presence and frequency of gender stereotypes in the required readings for the second cycle of primary education (for students aged 11 to 14, fifth to eighth grade) and to identify, classify, describe and analyze these stereotypes. The additional goal is to develop models for integrating gender perspective into the analysis of these readings in classes, in order to put an end to the reproduction of patriarchal gender ideology through school readings and encourage students to develop a critical attitude towards gender stereotypes, as well as to enrich primary school literature programs with new interpretations. Given that the school readings can also be considered as a canon, the aim of this paper would be to challenge the values, ideas and beliefs related to gender-sensitive issues and promoted in the school readings. This paper, in fact, is a critique of the canon/school reading from the gender equality perspective.

The starting point of this paper is the fact that gender stereotypes have a significant influence on creating the concepts of femininity and masculinity and establishing the social category of gender. Even when someone’s beliefs about the gender differ from reality, these can still have an important role in their behavior and the way in which they view themselves and the others (Brannon, 2000). The same behavior is often interpreted in different ways in women and men. Stereotypical portrayal of gender roles influences child’s attitudes and understanding of gender acceptable behaviors in society, and teaches them not to challenge the existing social relations. For that reason, examining stereotypes is crucial for understanding how the category of gender shapes our daily life.

The theoretical framework of this paper is the feminist literary criticism developed within the second wave of feminism, in the 1970s in the United States, with the main representatives being Milett, Ellmann, Rich, Fetterley, Gilbert&Gubar, and Showalter, although the works of their forerunners Woolf, Wollstonecraft and Beauvoir are also taken into account. The feminist literary criticism seeks to discover stereotypical portrayals of women in books written by men. It represents a new reading of old literature works based on the category of gender. The feminist reading focuses on the relation between gender and power and attempts to answer several questions: what is the number of female and male characters in a book? How are they depicted? What are the relations between female and male characters? What are their attitudes towards the predefined gender roles? (Gordić Petković, 2007). In Serbia, however, the feminist literary criticism did not start as a critical reading of predominantly male literature, since it established itself as gynocriticism from the very beginning (Slapšak, 1997).

Method

The corpus of this research on gender stereotypes consists of all fourteen novels that are part of the required, recommended or additional contents of the Serbian Language syllabus, supposed to be read at home and analyzed in literature classes during the second cycle of primary education. In Serbia, where the syllabus is designed by the Ministry of Education, the teachers have a limited autonomy in selecting the contents; they can choose three to five books from or outside the list of additional books to analyze in class. The research focuses on the novels, since these, although apparently simple, offer abundant material for the analysis of gender stereotypes, owing to the variety of topics, diversified plots, a myriad of characters, and tendentious didacticism. Moreover, because of their volume, the novels had been left out of the previous gender analysis of school readings, which included all other texts planned by the syllabus. In addition, there is a consensus in the methodological literature that analyzing novels in class is a complex task, very important for student’s development (Rosandić, 1979; Nikolić, 1988; Andrić, 1996; Bajić, 2004; Ilić, 2006; Kalezić Đuričković, 2008; Radulović, 2009). In analyzing gender stereotypes in the novels included in the primary school readings we used a literary analysis encompassing the following aspects of the novel: construction of characters, narrative perspectives, contents and the manner in which the storyline is built. Categories for each aspect were predefined and based on the review of bibliography and previous researches. The central analysis referred to the analysis of characters. This analysis relied on the Macionis’ model of stereotypical female and male personal traits, as well as on the analysis of elements of gender stereotypes made by Brannon (physical appearance, traits, behavior, occupation), supplemented with the category of characters’ value (this category was identified within the project titled Gender Sensitive Textbooks and Classroom Practice in the Balkans). According to Macionis, stereotypical male traits are: active, ambitious, analytical, assertive, attractiveness derived from achievement, brave, competitive, dominant, independent, insensitive, intelligent and competent, rational, sexually aggressive, strong. Stereotypical female characteristics are opposite to the male ones: passive, content, intuitive, receptive, attractiveness derived from physical appearance, timid, cooperative, submissive, dependent, sensitive, unintelligent and incapable, emotional, sex object, weak. The analysis aimed at determining the frequency of the predefined categories in the selected novels.

Expected Outcomes

The authors of all the novels, except one, are men. Nine out of fourteen novels tell the story about the growing up of boys. The majority of the novels focusеs on the growing up of boy, while none of them is about the growing up of girls. The characters are predominantly male and, in all novels but one, men are the main characters. The description of the appearance of male and female characters boils down to a gender stereotype of men being stronger and women being weaker, more fragile or fairer. Almost all male characters are active, intelligent, independent and brave, while the real girl is: passive, emotional, ignorant and easily scared. Positive female characters accept their submissive position. Conflicts are portrayed as an integral part of man’s life, from childhood war games and fights, to participating in wars for freedom or saving the world, resulting in the understanding of life as a constant battle in which the strongest person wins and in which the focus is on competition. The novels mention a wide range of male occupations (more than 100), and only sixteen women’s. In addition, male characters’ values are diverse, while the greatest female characters’ value is love. The male characters have the freedom of movement, while the female ones do not. All the narrators are men, and the androcentric perspective is presented as universal. Deviations from gender stereotypes are rare and mainly due to genre requirements. The selection of school readings as it is cannot contribute to achieving the set educational goals. For this reason, it is important to offer teachers teaching models that take into account a gender perspective, in order to teach students to recognize gender stereotypes in the novels, understand their function and develop a critical attitude towards them.

References

Brannon, Linda. (2000). Gender Stereotypes: Masculinity and Femininity. www.feminish.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/Brannon_ch07.pdf [8. 4.2016] Gordić Petković, V. (2007). Na ženskom kontinentu. Novi Sad: Dnevnik. Kalezić Đuričković, S. (2008). Nastavno proučavanje romana u osnovnoj školi. Podgorica: Zavod za udžbenike i nastavna sredstva. Milett, K. (2000). Sexual Politics. Urbana and Chicago: University of Illinois Press. Rosandić, D. (1979). Metodički pristup romanu. Sarajevo: IGKRO Svjetlost. Slapšak, S. (1997). Kradljivice jezika. Beograd: ProFemina. Andrić, М. (1996). Metodički prilozi književnoumetničkom delu. Beograd: Društvo za srpski jezik i književnost. Bajić, Lj. (2004). Odabrane nastavne interpretacije. Beograd: Društvo za srpski jezik i književnost. Ilić, P. (2006). Srpski jezik i književnost u nastavnoj teoriji i praksi. Novi Sad: Zmaj. Nikolić, М. (1988). Metodika nastave srpskohrvatskog jezika. Beograd: Zavod za udžbenike i nastavna sredstva.

Author Information

Jelena Stefanovic (submitting)
Secondary School "Kreativno pero"
Belgrade
Dragica PavlovicBabic (presenting)
University of Belgrade

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.