Education as the Practice of Love: Treading Lightly in the Footsteps of Badiou, Schatzki and St Paul.
Author(s):
Michael Victory (presenting / submitting)
Conference:
ECER 2014
Format:
Paper

Session Information

ERG SES C 14, Theories of Education

Paper Session

Time:
2014-09-01
11:00-12:30
Room:
FPCEUP - 254
Chair:
Tiago Neves

Contribution

The letters of Paul of Tarsus, (St Paul), first century apostle and missionary to Europe and Asia Minor have been re-examined by European philosophers Badiou (2003), Žižek (2003), and Agamben (2005) as historical documents with contemporary application for secular philosophers. This paper asks. ‘What lessons might there be in those same letters for contemporary educators?’

Paul’s letters, hitherto the preserve of theologians, New Testament scholars and believers in Christianity, have been used to shape belief, establish a moral code and guide believers in a faith journey. What Badiou, and his contemporaries have done is to show that the letters also deal with universality, identity, separateness and the ontology of event, being and subject, making them accessible to all, not just those who profess a Christian faith.

Whether from a believer’s perspective or otherwise, it is manifest that Christianity has shaped European and Western civilisation and, arguably, the ‘event’ on the road to Damascus has shaped the Europe that we experience. Certainly as a result of the preservation of his letters, Paul’s influence has extended from circa 50AD to the present. With his colleagues Paul transformed the communities of Europe and Asia Minor with whom he interacted. Badiou argues and this paper agrees that his letters continue to shape the world in which we live. In this paper it is argued that Paul’s letters deal with the Platonic quest to live a ‘good life’, the challenge to love at a personal and a societal level for both believers and non-believers. As educators seeking to be transformative in our impact we may be able to learn about ‘practice’ from Paul’s interactions with these early European communities.

Using a narrative inquiry methodology, following the work of Clandinin and Connelly (2000) and their three dimensional narrative model (Temporal, Personal and Social, and Place), and in this paper drawing only on Paul’s letters to the community of Thessalonica, a narrative of Paul as educator is established. The paper then turns to Schatzki’s site ontologies (Schatzki 1997, 2003) as the lens for understanding the personal and societal transformations that took place in Thessalonica (and also Philippi, Corinth, Ephesus, Rome, Galatia and the communities where Paul’s teaching succeeded).

Emerging from the narrative of Paul as educator are ‘clashing cymbals’ of education as partnership, education as dialogue, education as community, education with an ontological dimension, education as love, echoes of which can be found in the work of Dewey (1938), Freire (1970) and the Communities of Practice of (Lave & Wenger 1991) and (Wenger 1998). These education philosophies, somewhat lost in the current transcendence of neo-liberalism, need a rejuvenated voice to challenge the present and to shape a better future for education in Europe and the West. What this paper suggests is that these progressive education philosophies have antecedents that reach back through 2,000 years of European history. We may have in Paul’s letters the evidence we need to argue for education as ‘the practice of love’.

Method

Paul’s letters to the community at Thessalonica are the field texts for this Narrative Inquiry. Initially the field texts were analysed using Clandinin and Connelly’s model for Narrative Inquiry (Clandinin & Connelly 2000). That framework has three dimensions: a) The Temporal Dimension (looking backward and forward) b) The Personal and Social Dimension (looking inwards and outwards) c) The Dimension of Place (the location of the participants) This framework enabled the researcher to look at events prior to and following the writing of the letters by Paul, his emotions at the time of writing and to analyse the practice and social arrangements in the specific spatial-temporal site of the audience. Paul wrote his letters to specific communities based on a unique relationship between writer and audience, generated through lived experience together. For this reason Schatzki’s site ontology is helpful. Schatzki provides an approach that enables a more focused investigation into the social events and phenomena of Paul’s experience. For Schatzki the tasks are to: 1) Delimit whatever activity episodes compose an event or phenomenon of interest This is an investigation of how Paul changed the religious practice of the inhabitants of Thessalonica. What was the impact on individuals and on the society? 2) Uncover the practice-arrangement mesh of which the activity or phenomenon or interest is a component and uncover the further meshes and confederations to which this mesh is connected intentionally or unintentionally What practices did the religion of the Gentiles require of adherents and what societistic arrangements supported those practices in Thessalonica? How did Pauline practice change that practice-arrangement mesh and for whom did it change? How did Pauline practice differ from Judaic Christianity centred on Jerusalem? 3) Trace the chains of human and non-human action that link all of these meshes and lead to or spiral away from the social event of interest or create harmony, conflict or competitiveness between the confederations. How did this change in practice bring the new adherents to Pauline Christianity in Thessalonica into conflict with existing societistic structures, at the state or family level or individual level? What was the practice that characterised the relationship between the Thessalonian community and the wider Christian movement? What was Paul’s role in this practice? The results achieved from applying this methodology using Paul’s Letters to the Thessalonians as a case study, have enabled the researcher to draw some conclusions about Paul as educator.

Expected Outcomes

Paul succeeds in converting gentiles in Thessalonica. He enters into a dialogic relationship with them, lives with them and works with them. He is in dialogue with them about their individual beliefs and their relationship with society. He communicates the truth of love experienced in the ‘event’. He uses his letters to remind the people that he modelled as well as taught the new life that they are to live. As an educator Paul is reflexive. He shares with them his suffering and doubt. He continues to learn from the relationship with them. It is evident in his intimate longing for them and the open expression of love that is shared. Agape is the Greek word that best describes this form of love. As educator, Paul seeks nothing for himself, not financial gain, not status, not power. He does not create a church, nor put himself in charge. He asks people to choose weakness over strength – the humility of a crucified Galilean over the state of Rome - and they so choose. Paul’s pedagogy is based on community, to live with, to learn with, to bring a new understanding of life, to support them through the change in practice. Paul’s narrative shows that to educate is the practice of love. The challenge for contemporary educators in Paul’s letters is twofold. Firstly to learn how to educate in love in our current institutions, in our schools, universities and vocational colleges. Secondly to learn how to educate for love in the temporal-spatial world in which we live. If I might refer here to a contemporary problem in Australia, but also of significance across Europe, how do we educate for love for those who seek refuge from persecution? Perhaps the voice of Paul with the gravity of centuries may have answers.

References

Reference List Agamben, G 2005, The time that remains: a commentary on the Letter to the Romans, Stanford University Press, Stanford. Badiou, A 2003, Saint Paul: the foundation of universalism, Stanford University Press, Stanford. Clandinin, JD & Connelly, FM 2000, Narrative inquiry: experience and story in qualitative research, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco. Dewey, J 1938, Experience and education, Collier Books Edition edn, Collier Books, New York. Freire, P 1970, Pedagogy of the oppresssed, Revised edn, Penguin Books, London. Lave, J & Wenger, E 1991, Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation, Cambridge University Press, New York. Schatzki, TR 1997, 'Practices and Actions A Wittgensteinian Critique of Bordieu and Giddens', Philosophy of the Social Sciences, vol. 27, no. 3, pp. 283-308. —— 2003, 'A New Societist Social Ontology', Philosophy of the Social Sciences, vol. 33, no. 2, pp. 174-202. Wenger, E 1998, Communities of Practice: learning meaning and identity, Cambridge University Press, New York. Žižek, S 2003, The puppet and the dwarf: the perverse core of Christianity, The MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.

Author Information

Michael Victory (presenting / submitting)
Victoria University, Australia
Education
West Footscray

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.