Disability+Migration. Teachers' Perception On Migrant Students With Disabilities. An Explorative Research in Italy.
Author(s):
Donatella Camedda (presenting / submitting)
Conference:
ECER 2014
Format:
Paper

Session Information

ERG SES D 10, Mobility and Education

Paper Session

Time:
2014-09-01
13:30-15:00
Room:
FPCEUP - 249
Chair:
Christine Winter

Contribution

The new European social configurations, caused by migration, reveal aspects of complexity that could be identified  as new educational and social challenges. The  "dilemma of difference" (Terzi, 2008) that concerns people with disabilities hailing  from foreign countries is an emergent element in European nations, in particular regarding the immigrant children in each scholastic orders, so this widespread issue needs to be more  examined within the field of educational research  . In order to explore this topic in Italian educational background it’s been realized an empirical research, titled “Like butterfly wings. Study and research about children with disability, offspring of migrants”, between 2012 and 2013 involving 8 state schools (primary and preschool) of Vignola, a city in northern Italy. The sample of research, here presented, was composed by 22 teachers (class teachers and support teachers), 13 working at preschool and 9 at primary school;  A part of research, not here presented, included into sample 10 scholastic educators, 4 families, the school head and a child neuropsychiatric, all of them belonging to the research background. 

Starting from the results of a statistic inquiry on disabled students, promoted by Italian Ministry of Education and realized in 2009-2010, it came to light that  the 7% of over 200.000 students with disabilities attending Italian schools, respectively 15.000, hails from foreign countries. Is critical to underline that this several increasing presence doesn’t consider the children with learning difficulties or social and economic disadvantage but only whom have a medical or neuropsychiatric  diagnosis of disability; if  both them could be included into the inquiry the number will surely increase.

The main research questions were related to the topic’s exploration, in particular relatively  to teachers’ perception about the dual dilemma of difference (disability and cultural diversity). At the same time this research would contribute to expand the knowledge on this matter, since the lack of empirical or theoretical study that are increasing only of late in Italy.

The aims of this part of research were:  to define how many children with disabilities (3-11 age), having both parents hailing from a foreign country, were attending state primary school and preschool  in the background chosen; explore if  the cultural dimension affects someway the disability factor into teachers’ perception; identify which elements of resource or disadvantage were relevant to the teachers; to discover which critical factors/strategies are influent to the inclusion.

Since there are few literature references about this specific topic the main theoretical mention was influenced by M. R. Moro (Moro 1994-2002-2008-2012), an ethno-psychiatrist  that has studied this issue in French background through an complementary and transcultural approach. In regard to define the conceptual framing have been  relevant most recent Italian researches (Caldin 2012; Goussot 2011; Martinazzoli 2013) that have examined the subject within the educational framework.  The pedagogical approach that have guided this research, combines two typical educational field: Special Pedagogy and Intercultural Pedagogy. This crossed approach tries  to give a complementary view on the subject, considering both the disability factors and the cultural elements that are strictly connected and couldn’t be evaluate separately in this case.The theoretical framework hold  specific descriptive categories  outlined taking account of the principal  complexity elements: cultural dimension, migration, social inclusion, linguistic and comunicative dimension, functioning and disability, dual diversity.

Method

The research was based on a mixed method and structured in two phases: quantitative and qualitative . The first step of quantitative phase was a primary inquiry, composed by questionnaire, to obtain general data about the number of migrant children with disabilities, which both parents hailing from foreign countries, attending the primary and nurse state schools in the city of Vignola* , and other information about which order of schools they were attending, which classes, if there were specific inclusive projects. The participants were 2 teachers in charge of coordinators for integration (like SENCO), one for primary schools and the other for preschools. The schools involved into the research were 8, all under the same board of education, which includes 11 schools in total. The second step of quantitative phase consisted of questionnaires to teachers which were working in the class (n=16) attended by migrant children with disabilities. This step of research was dedicated to collect more specific information about each student and the class’ structure e.g. type of diagnosis, age, place of birth (Italy or else), parents’ country of birth, presence of support teacher or educator in the class, different curriculum or main program and more else. After this first mapping, the qualitative phase of research was realized by interviews articulated in 4 steps: step 1- (n=22) teachers involved; step 2-(n=10) educator’s involved; step 3- n=4 families involved; step 4- (n=1) head of school and (n=1) child-neuropsychiatric. The interviews to teachers were mainly focused on their perception of double dilemma of difference but there were also questions about school organization, some question about relationship with families and others to outline which elements are relevant, for these teachers, to improve inclusion of migrant children with disabilities and their families. The quantitative data has been analysed simply using Excel program, instead the qualitative data analysis has been analysed with Atlas.ti program. *[Vignola is a small city situated in Modena district (northern Italy); the population in 2012 was 24.344 of which 15,9 % were migrants (3.938 people)]

Expected Outcomes

The first data analysis confirm the presence of several immigrant students with disabilities within the schools of research’s background: 21 children, with migrant parents , were attending 8 schools and they were the 40,38% of the disabled students (52) under the board of education (11 schools) of Vignola. Migrant students with disabilities attending primary school were 10 whereas other 11 students were attending the preschool. From a comparison with the percentage of immigration in the city of Vignola a straight correspondence results between the census scale of foreign countries and the parents’ fatherland of migrant students attending preschool. The analysis of quantitative data matched with the results of other Italian research on this topic, confirming a common presence of migrant students with disabilities in northern Italian primary and preschool. Interesting elements are emerged from teachers’ interviews analysis, in relation to cultural dimension and about significant elements that influence teachers's perceptions. Through interviews’ analysis is already possible to discover the teachers’ stereotypes and prejudice towards immigrant people or a false belief of integration that hides a concept of immigrant’s adjustment to Italian cultural model. The results of this research, compared to the theoretical framework, reveals points of corrispondence. In order to extend careful reflections about the concept of inclusion the outcomes of this research will be used as a starting point for another research, during next two years, aiming to explore teachers’ inclusive attitudes in relation to values and practice.

References

REFERENCES – Associazione Treelle, Caritas Italiana, Fondazione Giovanni Agnelli, Gli alunni con disabilità nella scuola italiana: bilancio e proposte, Erickson, 2011 Booth T., Ainscow M., Index for Inclusion, developing learning and participation in school, CSIE, UK, 2011 Caldin R. (a cura di), Alunni con disabilità, figli di migranti, approcci culturali, questioni educative, prospettive inclusive, Liguori Editore, Napoli, 2012 Callari Galli M., Cerutti M., Pievani T., Pensare la diversità, Meltemi, Roma, 2000 Canevaro A., Le logiche del confine e del sentiero, una pedagogia dell’inclusione (per tutti, disabili inclusi), Erickson, Trento, 2006 Devereux G., Basic problems of ethno-psychiatry, University of Chicago Press, 1980 European Agency For Special Needs and Inclusive Education, Multiculural diversity and special needs education, Odense, Denmark, 2009 Eurostat, Population and social condition, Citizens of European countries account for the majority of the foreign population in EU-27 in 2008 Eurostat, Foreign citizens made up 6.5% of the EU-27 population in 2010, New relase, July 2011. Eurydice, Integrating immigrant children into schools in Europe, Bruxelles, 2004 Goussot A., Bambini stranieri con bisogni speciali. Saggio di antropologia pedagogica, Aracne editrice, Roma, 2011 Martinazzoli C., Due volte speciali, quando gli alunni con disabilità provengono da contesti migratori, Franco Angeli, Milano, 2012 Ministero dell’Istruzione, dell’Università e della Ricerca, L’integrazione scolastica degli alunni con disabilità nel sistema nazionale di istruzione, dati statistici A.S. 2009-2010. Morin E., Le sept savoirs necessaires à l’éducation du futur, Seuil, 2000 Moro M.R., Parents en exil. Psychopathologie et migrations. Paris: P.U.F.; 1994 Moro M.R. Enfants d’ici venus d’ailleurs. Naître et grandir en France. Paris : La Découverte ; 2002 Moro M.R., Maternità e amore. Quello di cui hanno bisogno i bambini per crescere bene qui e altrove, saggi Frassinelli, Milano, 2008 Moro M.R, Enfants de l’immigration, une chance pour l’ecole, Editions Baiard, 2012 Sayad A., La double absence. Des illusions de l'émigré aux souffrances de l'immigré. Paris, Seuil, 1999 Santi, M. & Ghedin, E. (2012) Evaluating the commitment toward inclusion: a multidimensional Repertoire. Giornale Italiano della Ricerca, anno V, , 99-111

Author Information

Donatella Camedda (presenting / submitting)
University of Padua
Philosophy, Pedagogy, Sociology and Applied Psychology
Padua

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.