Empirical Study of Social Mal-Adaptation of Returning Female Labor Migrants into their Sending Country: Facing Dilemmas in Ukrainian Context
Author(s):
Olena Koshmanova (presenting / submitting) Maxymilian Dubniak (presenting)
Conference:
ECER 2012
Format:
Paper

Session Information

ERG SES H 04, Intercultural education

Parallel Paper Session

Time:
2012-09-18
13:15-14:45
Room:
FCEE - Aula 2.4
Chair:
Patrícia Fidalgo

Contribution

Labor migration is an important component of globalization which promotes the economic development of many countries with transitional economies and emerging civil societies. The influence of international labor migration from the perspective of its home country has become the focus of many studies throughout the recent decade (Tolstokorova, 2009; Hughes, 2000; and others). While it may be true that wage migrant-sending households rely on remittances to increase consumption, international migration also produces benefits because families can also use this money to sustain schooling of younger family members. Research by Taylor, Mora, & Adam (2006) provides evidence to this assumption, showing that remittances help loosen up credit constraints among receiving family members, enabling them to invest more substantially in their children’s education. Others working in this tradition have taken a definitely more negative approach, concentrating their attention on the negative aspects of cross-border migration (Hapon, 2004). Emigration is especially strong in the post-socialist countries of Eastern Europe. According to Christina Montefusco (2008), who studied worldwide emigration of women, there are 7 million women migrant laborers from Ukraine (out of 48 million of the Ukraine’s population). Mass cross-border migration of Ukrainian female population (Lavrynenko, 2009) resulted in the development of complex social, psychological and educational problems, caused by the disconnection of traditional family ties, rapid growth of dysfunctional families, increase of social orphans and homeless children.

 Using a case study approach, the study explores the current dynamics of social life in Ukraine influenced by the processes of female labor migration promoting existential frustrations of returning migrants, their social and personal mal-adaptation (Hapon, & Koshmanova, 2010). This social phenomenon is strengthened by the returning migrants’ professional marginalization caused by social depreciation of professional knowledge and skills (Golovashenko, 2006).  This paper, then, closely examining personal, social and psychological factors of cross-border labor migration, will define indicators of mal-adaptation of women who returned from labor migration as compared to women who did not emigrate and stayed in the country as temporary unemployed.  It will show that there is a connection between their levels of mal-adaptation and personal self-effectiveness, their communication control. The paper is based on two suppositions: (1) Women who returned to their sending country from labor migration are characterized by specific features of mal-adaptation according to the parameters of absence of professional occupation; instability of financial status; presence of inner discomfort; perception of own health, family, home setting, their future and attitude toward society. (2) There is a connection between females’ level of mal-adaptation and their levels of personal self-effectiveness and communicative self-control. The study is based on a combination of qualitative and quantitative methods of research, as well as general psychological, historical and systematic principles of human development and objectivity. It employed a document analysis and methods of mathematical statistics. The authors suggest practical recommendations on the perspectives of educational work with temporary unemployed females, especially with those who returned to their sending country from labor migration.

 

Method

The methodology of this paper is based on qualitative (literature review) and quantitative (statistical) analysis. More specifically, it employed the following research tools: survey on the basis of the questionnaire of personal and social mal-adaptation elaborated by O. Urbanovich (Malkin-Pykh, 2005), test of communicative control elaborated by Marion Snyder test (Tarabrina, 2001) and the Russian variant of a general self-effectiveness scale (Romek, 1966).The research was conducted in June—July 2011. All the participants were women (N=105) of 28—40 years of age, with a medium of 34 years. The first subgroup of the participants (N=52) were female labor migrants who came back to their sending country from labor migration (which lasted from 1 to 3 years); at the moment of study, these women were looking for a job. The second subgroup of the participants (N=53) did not participate in labor migration and stayed in their home country; these women were temporary unemployed (from 1 to 3 years).

Expected Outcomes

The study confirmed the validity of both suppositions. The analysis of survey results showed that females from the first subgroup developed: (a) a medium level of mal- adaptation; (b) a low level of estimation of their material conditions; (c) an increased level of sensitivity and anxiety; (c) a positive view on their future. Women from the second subgroup showed: (a) non-perception of low professional wages; (b) negative perception of personal health; (c) higher anxiety regarding relationships with their family and friends; (d) worse attitudes toward the society they live in. Women who returned from labor migration were characterized by mal-adaptation according to the social and personal blocs of scales. More specifically, the dominant factors of mal-adaptation of the females from the first subgroup were not so much of inner-personal conflicts, worries about poor financial status and vague future, but rather about their problematic relationships with the family, friends, non-perception of social changes, and general social order of their home country. Females from the first subgroup demonstrated a more active professional position to achieve professional success; they had a higher level of self-esteem and were two times more likely to control their communication and self-effectiveness than subjects from the second subgroup.

References

Golovashenko,I., Ed. (2006) Gender Approach to Education: Coordinating National Experience with International Standards. International Conference Proceedings (11-13 June, pp. 34-38). Vynnytsa, Ukraine. Hapon N. (2004). Gender and Education: Psychological Research of Students’ Imaginations. R. Kucha, Ed. European Integration through Education: Traditions the Present and the Future, pp. 523-529. Lublin: Maria Curie-Sklodowska Uniwersytety Press. Hapon, N., & Koshmanova, O. (2010). Ukrainian students’ views on family values: Gender analysis. Paper presented at the ECER –EERA 2010, Education. Culture. Change. 23-27 August. Helsinki: Univerity of Helsinki, Finland Hughes, D. (2000). “The ‘Natasha trade’: The Transnational shadow market of trafficking in women“, Journal of International Affairs 53(2), 625-651. Lavrynenko, S. (2009). Trends of Labor Migration from Ukraine to the Union of Independent States, Strategic Priorities, 2 (11), pp. 185-194. Malkin-Pykh, 2005 Малкина-Пых И. Г. Экстремальные ситуации. – М.: Изд-во Эксмо, 2005. – 960 с Montefusko, C. (2008).”Ukrainian migration to Italy,” Journal of Immigrant and Refugee Studies, Special Issue: Migrant Strategies and Migration Policies: Comparing European and North American Experiences, 6 (3), pp. 344-355. Romek, V. (2005). Psychological Help in Crisis Situations. St. Petersburg: Rech.. Tarabrina, N. (2001) Psychological Practicum on Post-Traumatic Stress. St Petersburg: Peter. Taylor, J., Mora, J. & Adams, R. (2005). “Remittances, Inequality and Poverty: Evidence from Rural Mexico.” University of California, Davis, Working paper. Tolstokorova, A. (2009). Costs and benefits of labour migration for Ukrainian transnational families: connection or consumption? Cahier de l'URMIS (Unité de recherche migrations et société), Accessed 10 June 2009.

Author Information

Olena Koshmanova (presenting / submitting)
Loyola University Chicago
Political Science
Kalamazoo
Maxymilian Dubniak (presenting)
Lviv State University of Internal Affairs

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.