Secondary Student Movement: Present, Continuities and Ruptures since the return to democracy. Argentina 1983-2012
Author(s):
Marina Leonor Larrondo (submitting) Pablo Del Monte (presenting)
Conference:
ECER 2012
Format:
Paper

Session Information

ERG SES B 15, Secondary schools

Parallel Paper Session

Time:
2012-09-17
11:00-12:30
Room:
FCEE - S. 3
Chair:
Daniel Fischer

Contribution

 

In Latin America, secondary students movement conformed by the mobilization of students and their organizations (students’ unions or “centro de estudiantes”)  has always been a social movement which acted as public spokesman of the defense of the public, secular and gratuitous education. The students in general, and particulary high school´s students, have been, in repeated opportunities along history, a key factor causing changes to happen in educative policies and educative institutions. Their bonds with State and educative policies have gone through different stages. Conflict, cooperation,  and different  regulations that has been established and had been changed, by the state  has  marked this history,  in each one of the countries. In the last few years, some authors have spoken about the “young people´s lack of interest in politics” in Latin America. However, the students protest in the conflict in Chile during 2006 and 2011 and the conflicts led by the students of Buenos Aires and Córdoba (Argentina) in 2010, showed that the secondary student movement is a political actor with strong presence in political and educational life.  Its scope of action is permeable and it is developed in diverse instances: within schools, in political parties, social movements; as well as in independent organizations, streets, and negotiation tables. The students' secondary movement is a social movement which study allows us to know the diverse and complex links between youth, politics, citizenship and school.

  • Questions

 

What characteristics do young people who participate in politics in their schools have? In what ways have their identities, demands and forms of organization changed since the return of democracy? What forms of political and “non-political” participation do there exist in high schools? What traditions do they follow? In what ways do they intervene in the public sphere? What kind of relationship do they hold with political parties, social movements and the State? What actions they perform in their schools?

 

Thus, the overall objective of the research is: To investigate the relationship between young people, middle school and politics through the participation in secondary student movement both nowadays and in its recent history (1983-2012), on the grounds of a study in Province of Buenos Aires.

 

  • Guidelines of the conceptual approach

 

Secondary Student Movement is considered as: field of political participation of the young people, conformed and historically situated and inserted in secondary school as an institution. In this sense, we will display the main issues involved in building the object of study, present in four lines of work: 1- Studies that relate to political participation of youth at secondary school today 2 - The history of student movement 3 – The research on youth cultures and subjectivities and political participation of young people and 4 – The issues related to secondary education as an institution .  Also, some brief reference will be made of the theoretical framework used, which takes the following problematizations: Distinctions between "politics" and "the political" ; the student movement as a social movement ; demands, frames of identity and organization.

Method

• The general methodological strategy seeks to explain both the historical journey of the student movement and its characteristics in the present. Thus: 1- In order to reconstruct the development of the performance of the student movement during the period, and delve into the most relevant aspects, certain critical junctures of national policy and the development of educational problems during the period have been selected. From there, there are two complementary strategies: 1.1-Analysis of primary sources: - Interviews with former militants with a focus on oral history (Carnevale, 2007) and with current militant students at “centros de estudiantes” (student unions) and coordinators of unions of students in both cities. 1.2-Secondary sources: -Analysis of publications, pamphlets and leaflets in files available. -Analysis of newspapers available. 2 - For the analysis of the organization at school today, we posed the following strategies: 2.1-Thorough interviews with militant students, school officials and teachers and observations of the activities of the union of students belonging to a group of schools in both cities (Buenos Aires and La Plata). -Interviews with federation leaders and student coordinators. 2.2 It is complemented by the analysis of secondary sources: -Analysis of online publications (blogs, online magazines, social networks) of the main groups, student and student "coordinators".

Expected Outcomes

1. In the analyzed period, we expect to find that the student movement has been affected by changing processes similar to those suffered by other social movements and political organizations. 2. Simultaneously, it is expected that as social specific movement, has been crossed by processes of change of their identities and demands. These changes would be strongly related to economic, political, cultural changes and - strongly - to the vicissitudes of the educational politics, specially in the context of educational neoliberal reforms 3. It is possible to consider the existence of a process of "pedagogization" of political participation in middle school, based on the creation of structures and mechanisms for “citizen participation” though "non political", since: 3.a The “politicization of the teenagers" is a phenomenon that generates resistance in the educational system, despite his efforts to generate devices of “talk”, participation and opening 4. There are strong biases in the presence of organized participation according to socioeconomic level prevailing in the different schools. 5. The path of the militancy of the parents is a strong determinant factor of the path of the young militants. In Argentina, political and student activism has been strongly linked to the middle class. In this sense, it is possible to find some reproduction of inequalities of cultural capital.

References

Alvarado, S. & Vommaro, P. (2010) “Presentación” en Alvarado, S. y Vommaro, P (comps) Jóvenes, Cultura y política en América Latina: Algunos trayectos de sus relaciones, experiencias y lecturas (1960-2000). CLACSO-Homo Sapiens Batallán, G.; Campanini, S.; Prudant E. ; Enrique, I. & Castro, S. (2009) “La participación política de jóvenes adolescentes en el contexto urbano argentino: Puntos para el debate” en Última década (Valparaíso: CIDPA). Vol. 17, Nº 30, Julio. Berguier, R.; Hecker, E. & Schiffrin, A. (1986). Estudiantes secundarios: sociedad y política. Buenos Aires, Centro Editor de América Latina Manzano, V. (2011) “Cultura, política y movimiento estudiantil secundario en la Argentina de la segunda mitad del siglo XX” en Propuesta Educativa (Buenos Aires: Flacso) Nº 35 Mc Adam, D.; Mc Carthy, J. & Zald, M. (1999), “Oportunidades, estructuras de movilización y procesos enmarcadores: hacia una perspectiva sintética y comparada de los movimientos sociales”, en McAdam, McCarthy y Zald (comp.), Movimientos Sociales: perspectivas comparadas, Madrid, Istmo Melucci, A. (1994), "Asumir un compromiso: identidad y movilización en los movimientos sociales", en Zona -Abierta 69, Madrid Mouffe, Ch. (1999). El retorno de lo político. Comunidad, ciudadanía, pluralismo, democracia radical. Barcelona, Paidós Nuñez, P. (2010) Política y poder en la escuela media La socialización política juvenil en el espacio escolar. Tesis de Doctorado. Universidad Nacional de General Sarmiento-IDES. Buenos Aires. Reguillo Cruz, R. (2003) “Ciudadanías juveniles en América Latina” En Revista Última década nº19, CIDPA Viña del mar, Noviembre 2003 Schuster, F; Naishtat, F; Nardacchione, G; Pereyra, S (2005) Tomar la palabra. Estudios sobre protesta social y acción colectiva en la Argentina contemporánea. Buenos Aires, Prometeo. Tarrow, S (2004) Poder en Movimiento. Madrid, Alianza. Tyack, D. & Cuban, L (2001) En busca de la utopía. Un siglo de reformas en las escuelas públicas. México, Fondo de cultura económica.

Author Information

universidad de san andres
escuela de educacion
Victoria
Pablo Del Monte (presenting)
Institute of Education, University of London
Department of Sociology
Buenos Aires

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.