Benefitting from Schooling in Education Landscapes (in Western Norway)
Author(s):
Tobias Werler (presenting / submitting) Aina Saetre (presenting)
Conference:
ECER 2012
Format:
Paper

Session Information

27 SES 03 C, Parallel Paper Session

Parallel Paper Session

Time:
2012-09-18
17:15-18:45
Room:
ESI 3 - Aula 6
Chair:
Tobias Werler

Contribution

The main purpose of our research is to understand the meaning of schools and their anchorage in a regional environment. We are in search of different stakeholder’s views on what they consider as an important benefit of schooling. This is done in order to contest prevailing criteria for success in education (like national standards) and to test the hypothesis that there are alternative regionally induced Verstehenshorizonte (Gadamer) of “holding school”.

 Current education policy is mainly characterized by the idea of the provision of academic school knowledge which is rendered by national standards of education. The policy of school and teacher accountability is hereby used as a tool to ensure that school programs and teachers’ didactical choices are designed to provide (to the students) testable knowledge and skills. But if research is just examining what students have learned, in terms of competence or qualifications, one has not described all effects of education. A fundamentally heterogeneous student population will probably benefit quite differently of the public good schooling.

 The research project applies the concept of the education landscape (Werler 2011b). This is done so since life-, work-, and professional opportunities as well as historic regional disparities are challenged by globalization effects and result in the regionalization of education (Popkewitz 2000). Since the co-production of public services is the focus of regional development, one can conclude that a regional education landscape is mainly determined by the coordination and cooperation between different actors (schools & teachers, students, parents). This means that a regional education landscape assembles heterogeneous rationales into a network-like structure, which determines benefitting from education and the educational experience of the individual (e.g. teachers, students, parents).

 That means that a school’s regional placement, its architecture, students (parents) economy, socio-geographic conditions, the local school management/ organization and the curriculum are to be seen in the light of heterogeneity. Since these factors will vary from place to place, the composition of any school class is unique. These factors will have an influence on the process of schooling but they are only partially “designable” by a school.

 This means that heterogeneity is present as culturally developed content and represented by the curriculum and by the curriculum as it is practiced by the school/ teacher. Beyond that, teachers will also respond to pupils’ heterogeneity as they start teaching in order to establish a powerful learning environment. Heterogeneity is present in teacher’s didactical choices and students’ diverse responses to them. Initial indicators of whether pupils experience offers to learn as meaningful will be found in the pupils’ experience of the clarity and structure of the offer to learn.

In order to find and answer on the proposed question our research design focuses on what has to be learned(a school’s culture, program, content), where has it to be taught and learned(socio-geographic placement, local environment, management) and who is teaching and learning(principal’s, teachers’ and students’ views on schooling) and the relation between these factors (Werler 2011a).

 

Method

The regional education landscape construes an offer to learn where educational success occurs as a multi-causally produced public good. To map the different views on the effects and benefits of schooling the research team carried triangulated research design. By a standardized survey we collected quantitative data from teachers, students and their parents on their views of schooling (who). This is combined with socio-demographic statistics (where). A document analysis will provide information on a school’s culture, program and content (what). In order to be able to identify impact of a schools “placement” (geographically, demographically, socially, and culturally) on the different views a strategic sample of schools (quasi-experimental comparative design) was set up. It stretches from schools placed in urban municipalities which are challenged by industry based migration effects (globalization) to rural agricultural focused municipalities on the West coast of Norway. The sample consists of 12 schools (students in grade 9/10, 48 teachers, 334 students, 120 parents).

Expected Outcomes

Answering the questions regarding a school’s “where”, “what” and “who” will cast light upon the existing relationship between those three vertexes of an education landscape. Empirically-based research analysis will help us to understand: - in which ways a school’s and student’s economy, socio-geographic placement or management influence the teachers didactical choices and the students’ responses to it. - how a school’s placement, its culture, its leadership and classroom management influence processes and the possibilities of teaching to provide an offer to learn. - what impact a school’s/teacher’s choices have on the development of teaching as an offer to learn. - in how far a school should be judged by its regional placement and functioning.

References

Popkewitz, T. S. 2000. Globalization/Regionalization, Knowledge, and the Educational Practices: Some Notes on Comparative Strategies for Educational Research, in Popkewitz, T. (ed.), Educational Knowledge: changing relationships between the state, civil society, and the educational community, pp. 3-27. Albany: State University of New York Press. Werler, Tobias 2011a. Et didaktisk rammeverk for skolen i Skandinavia. (A Didaktik Framework for Schooling in Scandinavia), in Midtsundstad, J; Werler, T. (eds.), Didaktikk i Norden. (Didactics in the North), pp. 185-209 Kristiansand: Portal forlag. Werler, Tobias 2011b. Benefitting from the public good in a heterogeneous landscape. in: Werler, T. (ed.), Heterogeneity. General Didactics Meets the Stranger, pp. 155 – 172. Münster: Waxmann.

Author Information

Tobias Werler (presenting / submitting)
Volda University College, Norway
Aina Saetre (presenting)
Volda University College
Volda

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.