A Historical Perspective on the Conditions for Accumulating Symbolic Capital in Vocational Education and Training, an Example from Sweden
Author(s):
Åsa Broberg (presenting / submitting)
Conference:
ECER 2015
Format:
Paper

Session Information

02 SES 08 A, Transitions: Individual and Systemic Perspectives on VET

Paper session

Time:
2015-09-10
09:00-10:30
Room:
322. [Main]
Chair:
Johanna Lahja Lasonen
Discussant:
Magdolna Benke

Contribution

The research on vocational education and training from a historical perspective traditionally has a strong emphasis on institutional change. The theoretical approaches are mainly drawn from economics and institutional theory. However, there has been an increasing interest in the cultural aspects of vocational education and training (VET) which seek to deepen the understanding of the VET.  The contextual dependence of concepts like “labor” and “skill” are examples of important factors conditioning the VET. (Clarke & Winch ed. 2007) I´d like to describe this as a movement in historical research on VET from focus on the system – the outside of the schools – to a focus on social structures, the inside of the schools. This is needed in order to examine the inner life of VET and its conditions -  an important piece in the puzzle of VET history. This paper aim to contribute to this research field by examining some empirical indications of symbolic capital development in the 20th century Swedish vocational education and training. The aim of this paper is to explore or “try out” the concept of symbolic capital on the earlier Swedish VET system in order to shed light on the efforts to gain recognition for the vocational education and training on its own merits. The historical perspective allows for important questions to be asked and explored. The Swedish case of changing path, i.e. replace a market related VET model constructed in the reform of 1918 with a centralized state governed model in 1971 provides an interesting opportunity to investigate if and how conditions for the recognition of VET and its status in society is related to the model it self as well as the historical context in which it develops. A look into the rear mirror on the symbols, narratives and ceremonies of the early VET structure in Sweden reveals differences from the modern VET in regard of social and cultural conditions for the recognition of VET and the symbolic values possible to attain through education.

The change from one model to another meant that the Swedish VET, in 1971, became integrated in the same national education system as the academic educations (Nilsson 2010). The concept of field in this paper provides the background structure for the analysis of the process of generating symbolic capital. In the sociological tradition of Bourdieu, field has been defined or used as a system of relations and positions occupied by people and institutions that combat over something in common to them (Broady 1998). In this case the struggle to define quality vocational knowledge, to create hierarchies based on education related to vocations and professions in the trades and industries. Academic educations investigated from this theoretical perspective has generated some interesting results on the function of education and how it produces and reproduces class structures in society. As interesting as this may be the VET, if at all included in the studies,  is rarely considered in its own right and the unique conditions of this kind of education is overlooked (Berner 1989).

Method

The method of this paper is related to two aspects in particular. The theoretical point of departure is motivated by the circumstance that VET is generally overlooked in research where symbolic capital can explain relations and structures important to societal recognition of VET. The second aspect is the historical change from one VET model to another in Sweden. The shift from being a parallel educational system to be a part of the same educational system as the academic educations (which has a long tradition as a provider of symbolic capital) implies an important change of conditions for the VET as field where symbolic capital could both be generated (by the use of symbols, narratives, ceremonials and quality regulations) within the institution and accumulated by individuals. This is an important process and function for the recognition of VET in society and it can be investigated by analyzing historical artifacts as objects with symbolic value. The isolation in time of the previous VET model makes this an exemplary case study. The main questions asked to the empirical material is what an object or an act created within the educational system of VET could signal in terms of knowledge, quality or virtues related to the participants of the education. For this research I´ve selected some various expressions of creating values attainable in VET. I examine narratives like “the good VET student”, the virtues of “the long hard way to success”. I also consider the symbolic value materialized in graduation rings, award ceremonials and end of term ceremonials. The empirical approach in this research is inspired by the perspective of materiality of schooling (Burke & Grosvenor 2008, Lawn & Grosvenor 2005) which can be described as school archeology. The material used in this research is a journal of vocational education and findings from some school archives in Stockholm. The journal Tidskrift för praktiska ungdomsskolor [Journal of vocational education and training schools] was published by Svenska yrkesskolföreningen [the Swedish association of vocational education and training]. The school archives contain interesting materials such as minutes, brochures (for the purpose of information and PR), and photographs. For the narratives I focus mainly on the journal and the archives provides information on symbols and ceremonials but information on the different aspects can be found in all the materials.

Expected Outcomes

The result suggests that the conditions for recognition of VET and thereby the possibilities to make VET an attractive educational option are imbedded in the specific models and the historical contexts of VET. I argue that in the middle of the 20th century, while the Swedish VET was still an educational system apart from the national education program (and new as an educational institution) it functioned as a social field in its own right and the actors were engaged in a process of generating symbolic capital. This is evident in the inventions and uses of artifacts and ceremonials. Following this point of departure the hypothesis is that the old VET model provided other conditions to accumulate cultural and symbolic capital than the modern model and that the aspect of being parallel to another system was important for the development of its own symbolic capital.

References

Berner, Boel (1989). Kunskapens vägar: teknik och lärande i skola och arbetsliv. Lund: Arkiv. Broady, D. 1998 Kulturens fält en antologi [The field of culture an anthology] Göteborg: Daidalos Burke, Catherine & Grosvenor, Ian (2008). School. London: Reaktion. Clarke, Linda & Winch, Christopher (red.) (2007). Vocational education: international approaches, developments and systems. New York: Routledge. Lawn, Martin & Grosvenor, Ian (red.) (2005). Materialities of schooling: design, technology, objects, routines. Oxford: Symposium Books. Nilsson, Anders (2010). “From one model to the other: Swedish vocational education and training in the twentieth century.” i Utbildningens sociala och kulturella historia: meddelanden från den fjärde nordiska utbildningshistoriska konferensen. Uppsala.

Author Information

Åsa Broberg (presenting / submitting)
Stockholm University
Department of education
Stenhamra

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.