On-the-Job Trainers:Key-Persons in the Socialization and Transition Processes
Author(s):
Conference:
ECER 2015
Format:
Paper

Session Information

02 SES 09 B, The Contribution of on the Job Trainers

Paper Session

Time:
2015-09-10
11:00-12:30
Room:
324. [Main]
Chair:
Leif Christian Lahn
Discussant:
Ludger Deitmer

Contribution

In Switzerland, VET is the pathway most followed by young people after compulsory education (SEFRI, 2013). The majority engages in the dual VET system, which combines periods of learning and work in school and work settings in companies. A direct consequence of the system is the strong tie relying it to the labour market (Hanhart, 2006). This tie takes several forms: a practice-oriented VET system (Hoeckel, Field, & Grubb, 2009); a central position of the companies within the system (SEFRI, 2013); a close confrontation of the apprentices to the production needs and an education oriented towards immediate “employability” (Masdonati, Lamamra, Gay-des-Combes, & De Puy, 2007). Although host companies play a decisive role in dual VET, not much research has been done on them and in particular little is known about those who play a key role in the learning process: on-the-job trainers (Mulder, 2013; Baumeler, Lamamra & Schweri, 2014).

This contribution will be focused on the role played by the on-the-job trainers in the professional socialization of learners. This process takes place at various levels: when learners enter the working environment, when they learn standards and codes applying to the occupation, and more generally when they become more accustomed to working life and employment. Through the analysis of VET-trainers’ everyday activity, their direct or indirect influence on the school-to-work transition process will also be questioned. The following questions will also be addressed: what kind of transitions does the dual system support (a smooth and guided one or a harsh and rough one)? What kind of socialization takes place during the VET experience (to an occupation, to work, to the labor market’s logics)? Which role does the on-the-job trainer play in these processes (socialization and transition)?

On the theoretical level, it must be first  underlined that very few studies have been interested in on-the-job trainers function, in their everyday activity or in their pathways (Bahl, 2008, 2012; Barras, 2011; Capdevielle, 2013). This contribution is based on current studies on transition that point out the lengthening and complexification of the transition process (Bergman et al., 2011; Häfeli & Schellenberg, 2009; Masdonati, Lamamra, & Jordan, 2010). Based on this literature, it adopts two different definitions of transition. On the one hand, transition is considered as a process, which begins at the end of compulsory school and comes to an end when entering the labor market. On the other hand, it is seen as two thresholds: Transition 1, located between the end of compulsory school and vocational or general upper secondary education; Transition 2, between the end of upper secondary education and employment. Both definitions will be useful in the current contribution, on-the-job trainers having an influence on the whole process, but also more specifically on the two thresholds (selection and first socialization of the apprentices or socialization to the labour market logics, employability).

This contribution also refers to the issue of occupational socialization that is often related to VET programs and particularly its dual-track, considered as a site of occupational socialization and occupational identity construction (Dubar, 1996). This socialization integrates different aspects: socialization to an occupation, to work, to the labor market’s logics, etc. (Heinz et al., 1998; Kergoat, 2003; Moreau, 2003). In this perspective, VET system does not only prepare to a specific occupation (skills, language, tricks), but also familiarizes to the world of work (constraints, hierarchy, organization and division of work) and to the labor market’s logics (flexibility, profitability, production-oriented, etc.). The on-the-job trainer will also be the key person for this socialization process and in this way he or she represents a central resource for the transition process.

Method

On the methodological level, these issues will be addressed through a qualitative study, based primarily on analysis of semi-structured interviews with VET trainers (50) as well as on observations within the host company (30). Interviews and observations are conducted in large, medium and small companies. Two types of analysis will be carried out: 1) descriptive analysis (state of affairs) based on interviews and observations as well as on examination of legislative texts concerning VET trainers; 2) analysis of thematic content based on transcripts of interviews. Quantitative data (cantonal statistics about VET trainers) will allow us to have further information on who the trainers are. These very heterogeneous data will first underline the need of such research projects and second give a descriptive analysis of who these persons are (sex, age, professional sectors, previous occupation, etc).

Expected Outcomes

This research project is an invitation to study the dual VET system from the angle of transition and socialization processes in taking into account VET actors who have rarely been studied, but also into socialization and transition processes from the point of view of socializing actors rather that socialized ones as it is usually the case. The first results will show several differences between big companies which have “education centers” with full-time trainers supervising several apprentices and SMB, where the trainer is first of all an employee (or the boss) with strong pressure towards profitability and no time for supervising the apprentice. Another difference can be pointed out between different kinds of socialization: related to an occupation, including the transmission of the interest and the pride for one specific occupation, of its skills and know-how, etc.; socialization to work, including the transmission of its rules, hierarchy, social skills, etc.; socialization to the labour’s market logics, involving the transmission of a production-oriented logic, profitability, etc. The first analyses show a shaded picture. Indeed, we cannot assert that big companies are more production-oriented while SMB would be more interested in transmitting know-how and professional identity. This variability is due to the on-the-job trainer. Some of them are motivated to pass on trade skills, others to accompany young people during their transition process, others to prepare them for the labour market, by making apprentices employable. What appears as a first result is that the socialization process is the consequence of the confrontation of two logics: that of the company and that of the trainer.

References

Bahl, A. (2008). Die Situation des ausbildenden Personals in der betrieblichen Bildung (SIAP). Bonn: Bundesinstitut für Berufsbildung. Bahl, A. (2012).Ausbildendes Personal in der betriebliechen Bildung : empirische Befunde und strukturelle Fragen zur Kompetenzentwicklung. Bonn: Bundesinstitut für Berufsbildung. Barras, M. (2011). Transition école-monde professionnel: Etude des paramètres en lien avec la formation en entreprise facilitant l'insertion professionnelle des adolescents. Analyse du point de vue de six formateurs actifs en entreprise. Mémoire de master. IFFP. Lausanne. Baumeler, C., Schweri, J., & Lamamra, N. (2014). Les formateurs et formatrices en entreprise, personnes-clefs de la socialisation professionnelle. FNS100017_153323. Bergman, M. M., Hupka-Brunner, S., Keller, A., Meyer, T., & Stalder, B. E. (Eds.). (2011). Youth transitions in Switzerland. Results from the TREE Panel Study. Berne: Seismo. Capdevielle-Mougnibas, V., Cohen-Scali, V., Courtinat-Camps, A., de Léonardis, M., Favreau, C., Garric, N., Fourchard, F., & Huet-Gueye, M. (2013). Quelle place pour les apprentis dans les petites entreprise? Représentations de l'apprenti et rapport à la fonction de tuteur des maîtres d'apprentissage dans l'apprentissage de niveau V. Toulouse: Université de Toulouse. Dubar, C. (1996). La socialisation: Construction des identités sociales et professionnelles (2nd ed.). Paris: Armand Colin. Häfeli, K., & Schellenberg, C. (2009). Facteurs de réussite dans la formation professionnelle des jeunes à risque Berne: CDIP. Hanhart, S. (2006). Marché de l'apprentissage et pouvoirs publics. Bulletin de la CIIP, 19 , 8‐ 9. Heinz, W. R., Kelle, U., Witzel, A., & Zinn, J. (1998). Vocational training and career development in Germany: Results from a longitudinal study. International Journal of Behavioral Development, 22, 77‐101. Hoeckel, K., Field, S., & Grubb, N. W. (2009). Learning for Jobs. Evaluation par l'OCDE du système de formation professionnelle suisse. Paris: OCDE. Kergoat, P. (2003). Le désenchantement des apprentis facteurs‐trieurs. Travailler, 2(10), 107‐128. Masdonati, J., Lamamra, N., Gay‐ des‐ Combes, B., & De Puy, J. (2007). Enjeux identitaires du système de formation professionnelle duale. Formation Emploi, 100 , 15‐ 29. Masdonati, J., Lamamra, N., & Jordan, M. (2010). Vocational Education and Training Attrition and the School-to-Work Transition. Education + Training, 52(5), 404-414. Moreau, G. (2003). Le monde apprenti. Paris: La Dispute. Mulder, M. (2013). Review on Vocational Education and Training Research Revisited: Key Findings and Research Agenda . Paper presented at the ECER‐ Conference, Istanbul. SEFRI (2013). La formation professionnelle en Suisse. Faits et données. Berne: Secrétariat fédéral à la formation, la recherche et l'innovation.

Author Information

Nadia Lamamra (presenting / submitting)
EHB IFFP IUFFP, Switzerland
EHB IFFP IUFFP, Switzerland
EHB IFFP IUFFP, Switzerland
EHB IFFP IUFFP, Switzerland

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.