Institutionalization of Service-Learning in Spanish universities: a study in search of evidence

Session Information

22 SES 05 B, Interactive Poster Session

Poster Session

Time:
2016-08-24
13:30-15:00
Room:
NM-Theatre O
Chair:
Christine Teelken

Contribution

Various international organizations have claimed that the 21st-century university should create the conditions to promote a more student-centered learning environment and make use of innovative teaching methods. An example in this regard is stated by the Ministers responsible for Higher Education from those countries involved in shaping the European Higher Education Area (EHEA), which is known as the Bucharest Communiqué (2012).

One of the most common methods focused on students' learning is Service-Learning, which is consistent, educationally speaking, with the concept that students learn while acting on the real needs of the environment in order to improve it. A Service-Learning (SL) proposal comprises a combination of learning of academic content and providing training (skills) in order to mobilize them in real contexts (Puig, 2009; Santos Rego, Sotelino, & Lorenzo, 2015).

However, the benefits of Learning-Service may go beyond students and the potential cognitive and social effects instilled in them, since they may also affect professors, the community and the university as a whole, especially if it succeeds in linking three of its unequivocal missions: teaching, research and social responsibility.

However, there are quite a few studies that have been published and which, strictly speaking, have no empirical evidence consistent with this methodology, basing much of their claims, and even conclusions on the experiences (valuable in most cases), of teachers willing to make use of the above-mentioned methodology. And this is how their students' good results are justified, without resorting to a rigorous research design or anything close to it.

Therefore, this study is aimed at simply presenting the design of an experimental research focused on the application of Service-Learning in the context of Higher Education. The objective, first, is to study the relevance of Service-Learning as a framework for innovation and development of the processes of learning in Spanish universities; and second, to evaluate the effectiveness of Service-Learning when it comes to improving social competences and civic skills, along with knowledge, and with all of them related to students' disciplinary content. With both goals in mind, it is proposed to validate a model of institutionalization of the Service-Learning methodology at university level.

The institutionalizing attempts of the SL methodology in the Spanish university system should be based on four pillars:

1. The findings of social research, especially in the international context, which associate SL to students' improved academic performance and higher social capital.

2. The legal and institutional framework which endorses SL in the Spanish university system (Status of University Student, University Strategy 2015, Spanish Qualification Framework for Higher Education) and obviously in the EHEA.

3. There are increasingly more teachers working with this methodology, often on their own and as a personal initiative, but without any institutional and educational support which would allow us to affirm the sustainability of such initiatives.

4. The benefits derived from the institutionalization of any practice vs. those which do not have such recognition (see Furco, 2007).

In short, if our intention is to affirm the opportunities of Service-Learning in the Spanish university context, the first thing to bear in mind is that an implementation dynamics, as needed, requires a sufficient degree of knowledge regarding the elements and factors to be taken into account.

Note:

This work is supported by a research project funded through a competitive call by Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad, en el marco del Programa Estatal de I+D+i Retos de la Sociedad: “Aprendizaje-Servicio e Innovación en la Universidad. Un programa para la mejora del rendimiento académico y el capital social de los estudiantes" (EDU2013-41687-R)

Method

To achieve the objectives of this research study, a Sequential Exploratory Design and a sample of academic centers from six (6) Spanish universities are used. This study is, therefore, a complex evaluation research, consisting of three distinct, but interdependent steps: In the first phase, an exploratory study with a predominantly descriptive approach is conducted. Various quantitative and qualitative instruments are used in order to analyze the teaching structure at university level and identify practices that can be conceptualized as SL. To carry out the exploratory study, the following is considered: a sample of 1916 university professors (questionnaire), 44 deans or vice-deans (semi-structured interview), 6 institutional training programs for university professors and 174 degree subject programs (content analysis). The second phase is focused on the design of the SL university program, which includes teacher training, along with the instruments and protocols to be developed for evaluating the projects. The result of the training has to be translated into a maximum of 25 projects designed by teaching assistants. Each project to be developed will be submitted to a design evaluation, involving experts in SL (interrater criterion). Finally, the third phase consists of implementing and evaluating, according to the established design, each of the SL projects (quasi-experimental design of two nonequivalent groups, using Pretest and Posttest and an independent variable) in one of the universities within the sample as a pilot study. Besides the evaluation of the design, each project will be evaluated from the moment of its implementation, during monitoring and through to the end results. For the implementation evaluation, these components are essentially used: self-assessment reports from the subjects involved in the program (professors, students, partners); students and professors' portfolio; and group interviews with students participating in each project. For the evaluation results, the following will be employed: scales for students (Pretest and Posttest) regarding civic-social competences, attitudes towards the course and university studies, etc.; satisfaction questionnaire for students and professors; semantic differential of the program as a whole for students, professors and partners; grading protocols for courses; structured interview with the people who would receive the service; final evaluation report of the program carried out by the professor; and focus group with the professors involved. A follow-up evaluation will also be performed, and indicators such as project continuity, demand for teacher training or evaluation of the professor involved will be used in this regard.

Expected Outcomes

The paper presents an experimental research aimed at helping, if necessary, to lay basic foundations for sustainable institutionalization of Service-Learning in Spanish universities. In this regard, it cannot be denied there is a limited number of existing solid research studies in our country on Service-Learning and university, a fact which has been demonstrated in recent congresses and conferences in the field. Therefore, the purpose of this research is to show the level of implementation of the Service-Learning methodology in the Spanish university system. To this end, knowing the institution concerns relating to the examination, implementation, expansion and sustainability of Service-Learning in programmatic terms is of great importance (Santos Rego & Lorenzo, 2007; Lambright & Alden, 2012). In many cases, claims a well-known expert in the Latin American context (Tapia, 2010, p. 36), Service-Learning takes place through transition processes, not always intentional, which are based on other types of activities, but which eventually become defined as Service-Learning. In short, it is obvious that one of the fundamental elements linked to the relevance of Service-Learning as a framework for innovation and development of the learning processes in Spanish universities is provided by the empirical demonstration that the implementation of such programs in Higher Education optimizes academic performance and improves students' social competences and civic skills, about which there is considerable consensus as well as substantive issues with regard to the dynamics of employment.

References

Furco, A. (2007). Institutionalising service-learning in higher education. En L. McIlrath, & I.M. Labhrainn (eds.) Higher education and civic engagement: international perspectives (pp. 65-82). Aldershot (England): Ashgate. Lambright, K. & Alden, A.F. (2012). Voices from the trenches: faculty perspectives on support for sustaining service learning. Journal of Higher Education Outreach and Engagement, 16(2), 9-45. Puig, J. M. (coord.) (2009). Aprendizaje Servicio (ApS). Educación y compromiso cívico. Barcelona: Graó. Santos Rego, M.A. & Lorenzo, M. (2007). Universidad y sociedad civil en Galicia. Vigo: Xerais. Santos Rego, M.A., Sotelino, A., & Lorenzo, M. (2015). Aprendizaje-Servicio y misión cívica de la Universidad. Una propuesta de desarrollo. Barcelona: Octaedro.Service-Learning, university, research,institutionalization Tapia, M. (2010). La propuesta pedagógica del aprendizaje-servicio: una perspectiva latinoamericana. Tzhoecoen. Revista Científica, 3(5), 23-43.

Author Information

Mar Lorenzo Moledo (presenting / submitting)
University of Santiago de Compostela, Spain
Complutense University of Madrid, Spain
University of Cordoba, Spain
University of A Coruña, Spain
University of Navarra, Spain
University of Valencia, Spain

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.