Writing for Wikipedia in the Classroom: Challenging Official Knowledge (a Case Study in 12th Grade)
Author(s):
Lia Oliveira (presenting / submitting) Lauro Martins
Conference:
ECER 2016
Format:
Paper

Session Information

06 SES 02, Smart Media Use in Classrooms

Paper Session

Time:
2016-08-23
15:15-16:45
Room:
NM-Theatre M
Chair:
Mart Laanpere

Contribution

The paper describes an exploratory case study, carried out in an environment of critical action-research, at a urban K12 School in Portugal, which incorporates the use of Wikipedia in the 12th grade Portuguese curriculum (Writing Workshop, 73 students, 3 classes).

The question was: Does the activity of writing articles for Wikipedia, by students changes the way these students a) relate to knowledge (awareness of it’s constructed, dynamic nature and b) use the information available on the Internet?

Through questionnaires, observation and document analysis, we found many positive outcomes, e.g. skills relating to Wikipedia system; critical awareness of the information available; awareness that a text is an unfinished product and that can be collective; awareness of ethical and legal requirements.

The online collaborative encyclopedia Wikipedia is a source of knowledge and a space of possibility for knowledge production, since it is edited anonymously and in a self-regulated way. Also, it provides a context for work within the framework of multiliteracies skills. According to Szesnat (2006), research on the educational use of Wikipedia can be divided into two categories: use of Wikipedia as a database of knowledge and use of Wikipedia as a tool for teaching. We found a third category in the work of Jandric (2010) whose approach analyses Wikipedia from the point of view of the philosophy that underlies it (anarchism).

Analysis of Wikipedia praxis in the light of basic concepts of anarchist philosophy of

education shows the following:

- Engagement in Wikipedia is based on essentially anarchist beliefs about human nature.

- Engagement in Wikipedia is very close to anarchist concept of work.

- Wikipedia creates a virtual anarchist society (Jandric, p.65).

And the author concludes (p. 66): “No-one has ever created a fully egalitarian education system of neraly similar size and stability as Wikipedia.” It seems that we are close of the idea  formulated by Ivan Illich (1971) when he imagined the possible "knowledge networks"…

So this study is based on two integrated dimensions: epistemological and philosophical; and the pragmatic pretext for teaching and learning in a different way. Thus, the study explores the relationship of students with knowledge in the active situation of writing for Wikipedia, trying to raise awareness of the socially constructed nature of knowledge either the official/social or individual one (Oliveira et al, 2013).

These particular paper describes a pioneering teaching experience undertaken at a urban/rural Secondary School in the north of Portugal, which aimed to incorporate the use of Wikipedia in the 12th grade Portuguese curriculum.

The object of study sets up the problem of student’s management of information available on the Internet. Specifically, it focuses on the writing of articles, by students, for Wikipedia. We try to answer the following question: — The activity of writing articles for Wikipedia, by students (conducted, monitored and checked by the teacher), changes the way these students a) relate to knowledge (awareness of it’s produced nature produced, constructed, dynamic) and b) use the information available on the Internet?

The objectives are:

1) to provide students with knowledge and skills related to the functioning of Wikipedia (organizing and editing) that enable them to critically read articles and participate in their writing;

2) to promote oriented reading and writing (synthesis and argumentation);

3) to promote a critical and reflective look over facts and events;

4) to encourage students to use Wikipedia as a starting point for thematic research, applying the required validation filters;

5) to contribute to citizenship development through the communication possibilities offered by the Internet for the transmission and sharing of ideas.

Method

This is an exploratory case study (Yin, 1994; Bogdan and Biklen, 1994), carried out in an environment of critical action-research (Kincheloe, 2006), during the academic year 2012/2013. We used inquiey by questionnaires, participant observation and document analysis (the entries/articles produced by the students). The sample included 73 students in three classes of the 12th grade, in the context of an activity entitled Writing Workshop, which is included in the official curriculum for that grade, in Portuguese Language.

Expected Outcomes

It was found that students incorporate technology in their everyday life, have free access to the internet without any limitations; and when searching for specific information, students report to check sources and compare them; and show in general a critical attitude towards the treatment of information collected online. Wikipedia is not recognised as a source of credible information. Most young people revealed difficulties in writing an encyclopaedic article and in editing an entry in Wikipedia. The presenting work had several positive outcomes, given that students acquired: knowledge and skills relating to the operation of Wikipedia, which they may improve later; critical awareness of the information available, in which checking its source and comparing the relevant contents provide a way to confirm its seriousness and credibility; the requirement of citations and references to confer informative reliability; the perception that the textualisation of an encyclopaedic article has specific characteristics; the awareness that a text is an unfinished product and that the copyright holder can be collective; and awareness of the existing ethical and legal requirements, such as respect for the author’s rights and the fact that plagiarism translates a reality which is easily censured. This is not about using technology for technology. It is about using a technology that allows to introduce in the classroom activities that would not be possible without it! The Wikipedia is already and will be increasingly, the reference to the knowledge accumulated by human kind. We do believe that it will evolve in its collaborative and anonymous nature of fulfilling the promise of knowledge accessible to all ... Also, we believe that teachers, inside their classrooms and ‘respecting’ the imposed curriculum, can make a difference.

References

Oliveira, L. R.; Martins, L.; Capitão, M.; Costa, M.; Barbosa, H.; Cardoso, E. & Santos, B. (2013). Data is a Built Thing: (de)constructing the curriculum through Wikipedia writing. Procedings of EduLearn 2013, Barcelona. Pp. 120-125. Szesnat, H. (2006). Who knows? Wikipedia, Teaching and Research. SBL Forum. Disponível em http://sbl-site.org/Article.aspx?ArticleID=603. Acedido 27 de agosto de 2013). Jandric, P. (2010). Wikipedia and education: anarchist perspectives and virtual practices. Journal for Critical Education Policy Studies, vol.8. no.2. Pp. 48-73. Illich, I. (1971) Une société sans école. 4ième Edition. Paris: Seuil.

Author Information

Lia Oliveira (presenting / submitting)
University of Minho, Portugal
High School of Santa Maria Maior, Portugal

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.