Journeys We Make is an educational project which uses fictional and mythic storytelling to develop intercultural communication and understanding in secondary schools. Its conceptual framework departs from an understanding of intercultural education as the development of “an attitude of mind, an orientation that pervades thinking and permeates the curriculum” (Short, 2009, p. 2). It also embraces an understanding of culture as “collective programming of the mind which distinguishes the members of one group or category of people from another" (Hofstede, 1991, p.5), and assets of particular (collective) “ways of living and being in the world that are designs for acting, believing, and valuing” (Short, ibid). Therefore, sharing of culture is an essential element of identity, the expression of belonging and of collectively differing from a (common) Other (Wetherell, 2007).
Acknowledging that individuals experience such collective differing and identification with several groups, we understand intercultural communication not only as the communication between representatives of cultures, but also as the negotiation of cultures as these are experienced by the same individuals. Interculturalism, therefore, is a creative act, involving the synthesis of something new at the crossover zone between individuals’ multiple narratives. As such it is both an internal and external experience, tangled closely with identity. It is the process that supports individuals to critically, consciously and safely engage with such communication, in a process that allows individuals to take ownership of and become writers of their own story (Jesson and Newman, 2004).
Within formal education, intercultural education can include dialogue between pupils and teachers whose disparate cultures of origin negotiate to create the culture of a single, multicultural school, as well as the internalisation of this dialogue by the members of the school community as they become consciously multicultural citizens.
Our way of doing so was by engaging students with stories. Heinemeyer’s practice research across a variety of contexts (2018) has explored the potential of stories to act as a framework for indirect dialogue across social divides. As Reason and Hawkins (1988) demonstrate, enquiry and negotiation through story may be fruitful even in situations where overt propositional dialogue is problematic or controversial, because of narrative’s ability to encompass complexities of context and the coexistence of contradictory truths.
Initially our target group was vulnerable groups who have had significant, often traumatic experiences of migration or conflict between home cultures and cultural context, which we could reasonably assume to have had a significant impact on their identity development (Lilgendahl, 2015: 493). We aimed to support students in taking ownership of the identities and narratives that relate to them, firstly by helping them to acknowledge the existing narratives and then empowering them to change and exercise agency on their vulnerability.
Yet Kakos’ previous (Kakos & Ploner, 2016) and ongoing research suggests that a key impact of these migration experiences on recently arrived students has been in defining how they are perceived by others, e.g. as refugees or migrants. Many of these young people expressed the wish to be identified in relation to their current interests, assets and experiences of adolescence, rather than a traumatic but brief episode in their past. As Freire (1972:93) reminds us, any educational or political action programme which fails to respect the particular worldview held by the participants involved constitutes cultural invasion. Moreover, our understanding of intercultural learning as a negotiation between cultures and individuals called for a creative dialogue between the knowledge, experience and values of young people of different backgrounds. Our focus therefore moved from the ‘problems’ experienced by particular young people, to the ‘journeys’ travelled by all the young people present – however they wished to interpret that term.