Session Information
33 SES 06 A, Embedding and Embodying Intersectional Gendered Lenses in Educational Research
Paper Session
Contribution
Physical education is a school discipline that contributes to citizenship through the mobilization of the body. (Evans, 2017) This school discipline is often noted for the societal issues it tackles. There is no shortage of challenges, as is the case with gender issues. In this discipline, the body is at the centre of attention, to which questions are now being added. The complexity of body-related issues has the power to destabilize sporting certainties. We can see the difficulty sports federations have in integrating trans bodies into their thinking, particularly female trans bodies. It therefore seems useful to deconstruct what the body represents as a social object.
A major vision of the body is that of a biological mechanism, thought to be founded in nature by its organization in space, the intrinsic quality of its tissues, its vital and developmental constants, and opposed to the social in a dualist approach (Durkheim, 1930). Biologist Ann Fausto-Sterling (2000) has shown how scientific descriptions are biased by socially and historically rooted beliefs from which simplified, fixed and differentiated images of the two sexes are derived. These categories, which seem to be based in nature on the external examination of genitalia, have been constructed by culture, from which no science or scientist can exclude itself. For the author, bodily states are the result of complex interactions between nature and culture. This deconstruction of the immutable biological makes the malleability of bodies conceivable. Henceforth, bodies are subject to the tool-rich intervention of biotechnologies, with multiple objectives that have no limits other than those of ethics and politics. In so doing, this critique confers on bodies an infinitude, as the character of that which is infinite, boundless, in motion, evolving. Humanity experiences this through the aging process that tests them, the monstrosity that dehumanizes them, in turn making them a spectacle or invisibilizing them, and the disability that weakens and stigmatizes them. Any excess or shortcoming is sifted as pathological according to the standards in force, which are themselves evolving. The myth of the natural, healthy body is still powerful, even though we can't ignore bodies assisted by cutting-edge technologies. An emblematic case is that of 400-meter Olympic athlete Oscar Pistorius, running in 2012 with the able-bodied on artificial legs, carbon blades. The diversity of bodies is infinite, and bodies themselves are in perpetual transformation as a result of the different processes that run through and modify them. So, to think of sex as univocal and unchanging is to believe in the power of an obsolete image. It is on this belief, suggested by the omnipresence of the materiality of bodies, that the binary categorization of reference that subdivides sporting practices has been forged. This binarity remains impervious to questioning, despite the blows of athletes who put it to the test, forcing us to confront the limits of these social, moral and political constructions. It's worth remembering that the configurations of gendered bodies form a continuum that challenges the historically elaborated bicategorical construction.
Method
The expectations of this part are tricky to meet, given the nature of the proposal, which is intended to be rather theoretically oriented. Nevertheless, it is possible to provide some pragmatic details, drawn from narrative accounts and field observations of various scientific investigations and also formative visits to trainee teachers as part of my work as a teacher. They allow us to interrogate gender issues that fall within the scope of physical education, with reference to sports practices too. In the first place, I propose to examine the way in which pupils are labelled by the binary opposition "girls" and "boys", which activates mutual exclusion in order to avoid any suspicion or transgression of sex and gender norms. The activation of these categories produces effects on students' performance and behaviour in learning and assessment (Cogerino, 2004; Coltice et al., 2013). Secondly, this leads us to the integration of trans students into physical education learning. Trans bodies disrupt reference points and mental schemas. They brutally question categorical attributions and their exclusive character, claiming to be transiting from one sex to another or in an unfinished, fluid state. They force the boundaries that enclose categories and any possibility of measurement within a homogeneous group. Thirdly, I'd like to raise the question of the relationship between sexuality and sport. Sporting sexuality systematically refers to the sexual act between heterosexuals, when the link between sexuality and performance is questioned. Could we extend the questioning to sexual orientation? Would homosexuality jeopardize sporting performance? While sexuality has no decisive impact on sporting performance, it does serve as a behavioural referent: girls with masculine behaviour are subject to the lesbian label, while boys with less virile attitudes arouse homophobic suspicion. However, no correlation has been demonstrated between sexual orientation and the choice of a preferred sporting discipline. Finally, I’d like to confront the image of the healthy body as the primary referent of the sporting body. Historically, sport has been built on medical representations of the healthy body as a guarantee of performance. This deserves to be questioned in relation to the natural, healthy body, when we can't ignore the bodies assisted by cutting-edge technologies that intrude into, come into contact with or pass through sporting bodies.
Expected Outcomes
-By calling out "girls" and "boys" as soon as they enter the gym, the mental reference to binary activates differentiation. -Trans bodies force us to question binary sporting references. -School climate surveys reveal that young homosexuals, have a difficult experience of PE. -Diversity of bodies is infinite. Bodies are in perpetual transformation as a result of the different processes that run through and modify them. Physical education took a long look at the implementation and effects of gender diversity in the 20th century (Kirk, 1990). Our ambition is to outline some current and ambitious perspectives that it could take up in the 21st century. Could this discipline equip itself with the means to amplify its inclusive implementations, to become the terrain of a civic experience lived through bodies (one's own), in relation to bodies (of others), for the fulfilment of the individual within a collective? The preliminary constraint is to accept multiple bodies, whatever the forms of their production. We need to move towards an understanding of the social transformations whose ongoing processes impact on bodies as social objects. These mutations carry with them political forces (Butler, 2019), needs for recognition moral (Honneth, 2000), a democratic requirement to rights and resources to satisfy principles of social justice (Fraser, 2011). An indispensable deconstruction of the immutable biological would enable us to consider the malleability of bodies. Bodies are yet subject to the intervention of biotechnologies that have no limits but those of ethics and politics. In so doing, this critique confers on bodies an infinitude, as the character of that which is infinite, boundless, in motion, evolving. Humanity experiences this evolution at every moment, through the aging process that tests bodies, the monstrosity that dehumanizes them, in turn making them visible or invisible, and the disability that weakens and stigmatizes them.
References
Butler, Judith (2019). Those bodies that still matter. Political Reasons, 76(4), 15-26. Coltice, Michelle; Couchot-Schiex, Sigolène and Sallet, Bruno (2013). La leçon en Volley-Ball : l'accompagnement des expériences corporelles de tous les élèves, Les cahiers du CEDRE/CEDREPS, 13, 115-125. Durkheim, Émile (1897). On suicide. Penguin Classics. Evans, J. (2017). Equality, education, and physical education. Tylor & Francis. Fausto-Sterling, Anne (2000). Sexing the Body: Gender Politics and the Construction of Sexuality. Basic Books. Fraser, Nancy (2011). What is social justice? La Découverte (French translation). Honneth, Axel (1995). The struggle for recognition. The Moral Grammar of Social Conflicts. Polity. Kirk, D. (1990). ‘Defining the Subject: Gymnastics and Gender in British Physical Education’, in Kirk, D. and Tinning, R. (Eds) Physical Education, Curriculum and Culture (43-67). London: Falmer Press.
Update Modus of this Database
The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER.
Search the ECER Programme
- Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
- Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
- Search for authors and in the respective field.
- For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
- If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.