Session Information
33 SES 13 A, Challenge and Discomfort through Education: Sexualities, Genders and Feminist Research and Actions.
Paper Session
Contribution
This qualitative study examines Aluba—a ritualized adolescent practice of mock-thrusting peers against poles—as a contested site of deviant play intersecting institutional discipline, gender performativity, and peer hierarchies. Through semi-structured interviews with 10 intersectionally diverse participants across Mainland China and thematic analysis, we challenge binary interpretations of Aluba as solely homosocial bonding or bullying. Findings reveal its dual function as a liminal space that simultaneously subverts institutional control while reinforcing micro-hierarchies: academically privileged students dominate active "lifter" roles, while marginalized peers face disproportionate targeting. Gendered participation exposes biological essentialism, with male collaborators performatively constructing hegemonic masculinity through fluid agentive/receptive roles, while female and queer engagement remains constrained by covert male primacy norms. Institutional responses oscillate between prohibition and tacit tolerance, hindered by sexual stigma and pedagogical discomfort. Introducing a spectral model of Deviant play, we position Aluba along axes of coercion intensity and role rotation frequency, challenging rigid school violence categorizations. The study urges educators to critically engage adolescent transgressive play beyond disciplinary frameworks, recognizing its dual role in identity negotiation and systemic harm.
Method
Participants and Recruitment This study employed a purposive sampling strategy to recruit 10 participants for in-depth interviews, with each session averaging 40 minutes. The participant pool encompassed diverse perspectives on the phenomenon under investigation—referred to here as Aluba (a form of ritualized physical activity among students)—including complete bystanders, occasional participants, and deeply involved individuals. The cohort demonstrated intersectional diversity: gender identities included female, male, individuals who formerly identified as transgender men, and nonbinary individuals; sexual orientations represented were heterosexual, lesbian, and pansexual. To ensure nuanced insights, recruitment utilized a dual approach: snowball sampling initiated through personal networks and targeted outreach within queer communities to amplify underrepresented voices. Data Collection Interviews were conducted using a semi-structured format, combining three modes to accommodate participants’ privacy needs and the sensitive nature of the topic: telephone calls, video conferences, and asynchronous text-based platforms. Prior to each session, participants reviewed and signed informed consent documents, followed by a detailed explanation of their rights, including anonymity, voluntary withdrawal, and data confidentiality. The interview protocol centered on four thematic clusters: Terminology and Cultural Memory: Questions probed participants’ awareness of Aluba (e.g., “How did you recognize this activity as Aluba?”; “Were alternative terms used in your school?”). Temporal and Contextual Dynamics: Participants described when and how Aluba occurred (e.g., “Was it tied to specific events or daily routines?”; “What was its typical duration?”). Social Dynamics and Roles: Questions explored power hierarchies (e.g., “Who initiated or received Aluba?”; “How did roles affect interpersonal relationships?”) and institutional responses (e.g., “Did teachers intervene?”). Embodied and Affective Experiences: Follow-up questions tailored to participants’ gender identities delved into subjective emotions (e.g., “What role did you play, and how did it feel?”). To circumvent linguistic ambiguities—given regional variations in terminology—participants were invited to supplement verbal accounts with hand-drawn sketches or diagrams reconstructing Aluba’s physical choreography. This visual methodology aimed to anchor cultural memory in embodied practices. Data Analysis Thematic analysis was conducted iteratively across three phases: (1) open coding of transcripts and visual materials to identify emergent patterns; (2) axial coding to cluster codes into themes (e.g., “ritualized violence,” “gender performance”); and (3) selective coding to refine thematic boundaries and interrogate contradictions. Reflexivity was maintained through researcher memos documenting positional biases, particularly regarding gender and power dynamics inherent in Aluba. This methodology prioritized ethical rigor, intersectional inclusivity, and multimodal data triangulation to capture the complexity of Aluba as a culturally situated practice.
Expected Outcomes
The Duality of Deviant Play: Subversion and Carnivalesque Construction The contradictory narratives of "not quite appropriate" versus "just playing" in the findings reveal the essential characteristics of Aluba as deviant play. Participants construct temporary "liminal spaces" (Turner, 1969) by evading teacher supervision and selecting specific spatiotemporal contexts (e.g., breaks/P.E. classes), where the disciplinary power of academic-centered order is temporarily suspended. The phenomenon of academically successful students dominating the lifting roles while "problem students" assume the lifted position echoes Willis' (Willis,1977) observation of "counter-school culture" complexity—surface-level norm subversion actually reproduces micro-hierarchies based on academic performance. This duality culminates when teachers become targets: while students deconstruct pedagogical authority through play, their actions remain embedded within the "resistance-compliance" power framework. The centrality of vertigo experiences (e.g., weightlessness intertwined with pain) corroborates Caillois' "ilinx" theory, yet requires particular attention to its peculiarities: the lifted individual's bodily loss of control constitutes both imposed violence and collectively constructed "voluntary complicity." Embodied Performances on Gender Tracks Aluba's gendered practices demonstrate remarkable "biological sex anchoring effects." Male participants collaboratively construct masculinity through alternating agentive/receptive roles within a "brotherhood" framework—the endurance of the lifted and physical prowess of the lifters jointly reinforce "toughness" as bodily discipline. The marginal participation of females (as lookouts or transgressors) substantiates Butler's (1990) gender performativity theory: transgender males and lesbian T's attempt to transcend biological boundaries through neutralized clothing/behavior strategies remains constrained by the latent "male primacy" rule. Notably, the cognitive chasm between female bystanders' empathetic pain perception and male participants' "play consensus" exposes the covert operation of violence legitimization mechanisms: when physical violence is encoded as "male-exclusive play," its potential harm becomes incorporated into the "exemption zone" of gender norms.
References
Becker, H. S. (1963). Outsiders: Studies in the sociology of deviance. Free Press. Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77–101. https://doi.org/10.1191/1478088706qp063oa Caillois, R. (1958). Les jeux et les hommes [Man, play and games]. Gallimard. Chen, Y. (2010). Ritualized violence and peer hierarchies in Taiwanese schools: The social dynamics of Aluba. Asian Journal of Social Science, 38(4), 532–549. https://doi.org/10.1163/156853110X511465 Ho, S. K. (2008). Doing masculinity in the playground: Aluba and the performance of male dominance in Hong Kong schools. Gender Press. Huang, J. J. (2004, November 20). University orientation deviant games involving genital contact. Wen Wei Po. https://exampleurl.com [Archived]. (Original work in Chinese) Liberty Times. (2006, September 28). Millennium Kill, Grass Flight, Aluba... 50% of elementary students experienced school sexual bullying. Liberty Times. https://exampleurl.com [Archived]. (Original work in Chinese) Oriental Daily. (2009, February 8). University of Hong Kong orientation repeatedly features lewd games. Oriental Daily. https://exampleurl.com [Archived]. (Original work in Chinese) United Daily News. (2007, December 4). Four minors prosecuted for "Aluba" ritual. United Daily News. https://exampleurl.com [Archived]. (Original work in Chinese) TVBS News. (2007, December 4). Four students sued for Aluba game causing genital bruising. TVBS News Network. https://exampleurl.com [Archived]. (Original work in Chinese) Wang, F. M. (2006, September 28). Aluba, Millennium Kill, and school sexual bullying: A hidden crisis. Liberty Times. https://exampleurl.com [Archived]. (Original work in Chinese) West, C., & Zimmerman, D. H. (1987). Doing gender. Gender & Society, 1(2), 125–151. https://doi.org/10.1177/0891243287001002002 Wu, L. (2015). Aluba as transgressive play: Power, shame, and the boundaries of consent in East Asian school rituals. Journal of Deviant Behavior, 36(7), 523–540. https://doi.org/10.1080/01639625.2014.935653
Update Modus of this Database
The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER.
Search the ECER Programme
- Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
- Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
- Search for authors and in the respective field.
- For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
- If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.