Session Information
33 SES 04 A, Dance, Play and Romance in Gendered Educational Experiences
Paper Session
Contribution
School is a strategic place in the social life of individuals (Lahire, 2019). Physical education (PE), one of its school disciplines, is recognized for its involvement in societal issues and citizenship. In France, as elsewhere (Földesi et al., 1994), PE has long been committed to gender equality, with a focus on co-education. Since the early 2000s, the effects of co-education in PE have been disseminated in teacher training. However, conceptual resistance still marks teaching practices today, renewing the opportunity to pursue and accentuate reflections in teacher training. More recently, PE has taken up the theme of psychosocial skills, with a renewed emphasis on health in schools. Although psychosocial skills have been defined by the World Health Organization (WHO) since 1990, there are few scientific studies documenting this dimension in the school environment, even though they are said to have positive effects on health, well-being and academic success (Lenzen, 2022). These potentialities are the subject of debate in PE research. However, we note that while danced physical activity refers to many modalities of cultural practice (Thorel-Hallez, 2015), it is recognized as conducive to encounters with others (Necker and Thorel-Hallez, 2015), to the benefit of coeducation in mixed classes and to students' psychosocial skills. Social skills, which involve behaviors between individuals and the emotional skills involved in affective processes, are among the factors that underpin the school experience, like any other living space.
During 2024, we carried out research to identify the effects of an experimental ballroom dance program that pupils in several classes in the city of Paris (France) followed. The commissioned study aimed to identify the benefits in terms of psychosocial skills that could have an impact on school climate. The dance program was seen as likely to have positive effects on relations between girls and boys in the classes concerned, and to ease any pre-existing tensions. The results presented in our paper will be related to this objective.
Another part of the program was designed to facilitate the transfer of ballroom dance skills to teachers, enabling them to integrate the program into their annual planning. This part of the program will not be covered in our communication.
Method
Three methodological tools were designed to document the effects of the ballroom dance program on students in mixed-gender classes. Using a mixed quantitative and qualitative methodology, we sought to consolidate the results with both factual data (records of objective facts) and subjective data based on students' narratives. First tool: a questionnaire was administered to all pupils in the classes taking part in the experiment. The purpose of the questionnaire was to question the pupils' individual representations of various aspects of school climate, juvenile sociability, inbodied sociability. It also focused to gather factual information on their experience since the start of the school year in their school and class, to identify any microviolence they may have experienced. Second tool: in half-class interviews with students, we discussed the themes of school and gendered socialization, and the experience of the experimental dance-sport project. Third tool: in situ observations of dance-sport sessions were carried out in four classes in three establishments: two schools and one middle-school. The reference dance was Cha-cha, a Latin dance chosen because it is little known to the pupils, so it has the potential to be unexpected. It is also very dynamic with rhythmic steps mostly easy to learn. The study population comprised 8 schools and 4 middle schools. The sample for the questionnaire survey was as follows: Total sample: N=463 Girls: n=234 (50.5%) Boys: n=229 (49.5%) Schools: CE2, CM1, CM2 n=375 (81%) Middle schools: 6th, 4th, 3th n=88 (19%) Students aged 9-11 represent 82.3% of the total sample. We carried out descriptive statistical analyses on the questionnaire data concerning their assessments of the quality of living together, relations between students and victimization, and we questioned their representations and learning of sports, in PE and dance. Referring to the context of this activity, we collected interesting data on physical contact (holding hands, looking into each other's eyes) with the dance partner. We checked whether cha-cha could be a dance that ease tensions and create a more positive classroom climate.
Expected Outcomes
A sample of the results will be developed in this communication. The results focus in particular on gender issues, including boys' adherence to the proposed dance activity, in this case cha-cha dance. While students have a very positive opinion of their school, which they largely appreciate and in which they feel comfortable (95% positive and very positive assessment), mockery and insults are markers of deterioration in relations between students, with marked effects on younger students in particular. Micro-violence such as insults and mockery can target pupils on the basis of skin color or origin, religion, or gender (dress, behavior, conformity to gender norms). As expected, sports participation is high (93.7%). Dance practice is mainly part of PE programs, and few students are enrolled in a structure offering dance outside school, especially middle-school girls. Not surprisingly, boys also dance outside school, at home. In fact, 51.5% of students dance at home. While the gendered dimension is marked, the family practitioners represented in the quotations open up a fairly broad spectrum. Dance is not a marginal activity, either outside or inside school. Moreover, students agree with the statement that dancing in pairs is for both girls and boys (86.8%), showing balanced representations. The physical contact required to dance with a partner is a major obstacle to learning in the classroom. They are perceived as difficult by 56% of students. Discussions on the subject in the interviews were extensive and illustrative. Other limitations were also identified. Students point out that the question of the dance partner's gender is not the most important one. The important question is "Is this person a friend?". Indeed, it's more difficult to agree to dance (and therefore enjoy a physical activity together) with a partner who has mocked or insulted a few minutes earlier.
References
Benbenishty, R. and Astor, R. A. (2005). School violence in context: Culture, neighborhood, family, school, and gender. New York: Oxford University Press. Földesi, Gyongyi S ; Irlinger, Paul, Louveau, Catherine and Michèle Metoudi (1994). East-West: the practise of sports as revealing aspects of french and hungarian societies. International Review for the Sociology of Sport, 29(2), 149-170. Lenzen, B. (2022). Editorial. L'éducation physique en mouvement, 8. [available at: https://ressources-eps-vd.ch/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/Numero-8-Competences-psychosociales.pdf ] Necker, S. and Thorel-Allez, S. (2015). Artistic practices to meet and co-educate. Theater and dance, towards "better living" in educational settings? International Journal of Violence and School, Hors-série, 16, 123-146. Thorel-Hallez, S. (2015). Les gestes professionnels de l'enseignant-e d'éducation physique en danse: entre intentions, croyances et interventions. Recherches et éducation, 129-140.
Update Modus of this Database
The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER.
Search the ECER Programme
- Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
- Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
- Search for authors and in the respective field.
- For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
- If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.