Session Information
33 SES 08 A, Exploring and Theorising Higher Educational (In)Justices in Diverse Contexts
Paper Session
Contribution
The persistent underrepresentation of racialised women in European academia raises fundamental questions about how gender intersects with colonial legacies, race, and power structures in higher education. This study challenges traditional approaches to gender research by exploring how racialised women early career researchers (ECRs) from former colonies navigate and reconstruct their gender identities within academic institutions in England, France, Portugal, and Spain.
We want to address the same questions in four different postcolonial contexts with different historical and cultural backgrounds, complex relationships in which the former colonies and the former empires have an influence on each other (Fradera, 2018). Thanks to this diversity, we hope to uncover different facets of the complex arrangements of the "colonial" relationship between the former colonial power and the former colonised countries. These arrangements will be translated through participants' reflections on their own relationship to 'imperial' culture.
The timing of this research is critical given the current political landscape across Europe, where right-wing populist movements have gained momentum. These movements combine anti-gender rhetoric with nativist ideologies, fostering a particularly challenging environment for racialised women in academia. Their discourse depicts gender equality as a threat to traditional values while promoting xenophobic narratives that target individuals from former colonies, creating multiple layers of hostility that directly impact racialised women ECRs.
- How do racialised women ECRs experience gender within the context of European academia's colonial heritage, and how does it shape their well-being and career progression?
- How can their lived experiences inform a more nuanced understanding of gender that transcends Eurocentric binary frameworks?
While intersectionality is our primary analytical framework, we draw on Black feminist literature and postcolonial theory to capture the complex interplay between gender, race, and colonial legacies in academia. We also consider the same questions from a French perspective, taking as a starting point the universalism inherited from the Enlightenment and the French Revolution (Balibar 1997, Diagne 2013), and the debate between this perspective and critical race theory and intersectionality (Fassa, Lepinard & Roca, 2016).
- How do racialised women ECRs experience gender within the context of European academia's colonial heritage, and how does it shape their well-being and career progression?
- How can their lived experiences inform a more nuanced understanding of gender that transcends Eurocentric binary frameworks?
While intersectionality is our primary analytical framework, we draw on Black feminist literature and postcolonial theory to capture the complex interplay between gender, race, and colonial legacies in academia. We also consider the same questions from a French perspective, taking as a starting point the universalism inherited from the Enlightenment and the French Revolution (Balibar 1997, Diagne 2013), and the debate between this perspective and critical race theory and intersectionality (Fassa, Lepinard & Roca, 2016).
Our study moves beyond adding race as an afterthought to gender analysis, instead examining how gender itself is constructed and experienced differently through the lens of colonial histories and racial hierarchies in European academia. It responds directly to the need to reconceptualize gender in ways that center previously marginalized voices and experiences.
Method
Our study employs focus groups as the primary data collection tool, designed to create safe spaces for dialogue and collective reflection among racialised women ECRs. This method aligns with our theoretical framework by acknowledging the power of collective voice and shared experiences in understanding intersectional identities in academia. The focus groups are conducted face-to-face across four European countries (England, France, Portugal, and Spain), each hosting 8-10 participants. This size allows for meaningful dialogue while ensuring all voices can be heard. Each 2-hour focus group are structured around key themes as personal narratives of navigating academic spaces; institutional structures and barriers; strategies for resilience and career progression; intellectual and personal relationship with the culture of the country in which they are studying and why they have chosen to study in that country. The focus groups will be recorded, transcribed, and analyzed using thematic analysis informed by our theoretical framework. The carousel approach involves the lead researchers from the four countries moving between locations, thus allowing for identification of common patterns across different national contexts, understanding of how colonial histories uniquely shape experiences in each country and building transnational networks of support.
Expected Outcomes
Theoretically, the study develops a more nuanced framework that integrates postcolonial perspectives with intersectional approaches to gender in academia, generating new insights into how colonial legacies continue to shape gender experiences in European higher education. This will enhance our understanding of how race, gender, and academic identity intersect within national contexts. Methodologically, it demonstrates how participatory research approaches can effectively capture intersectional experiences while empowering participants. By developing a model for cross-national comparative research, it creates new tools for documenting and analyzing experiences of marginalization in academic settings. The practical impact will be substantial, producing evidence-based recommendations for institutional change in European universities and developing concrete strategies to support racialised women ECRs' career progression. A key strength of the project lies in its capacity-building potential. By creating platforms for dialogue and experience sharing, it will potentially empower racialised women ECRs through knowledge sharing and collective support. Thanks to the comparison between four different national settings, we hope that the study will also open up new questions for the study of post-coloniality. Inspired by Bhabha's theory of cultural hybridity (Bhabha, 2004), we aim to rethink issues of identity, social agency and national belonging, combined with gender, in their ambivalence, with the ambition of contributing to political change.
References
Balibar, É. (1997). Racisme et universalisme. Raison présente, 122, 63-77. Bhabha, H. K. (2004). The location of culture. Routledge. Diagne, S. B. (2013). On the postcolonial and the universal? Rue Descartes, 78(2), 7-18. Fassa, F., Lepinard, E., & Roca Escoda, M. (Eds.). (2016). L'intersectionnalité : enjeux théoriques et politiques. La Dispute. Fradera, J. (2018). The imperial nation: Citizens and subjects in the British, French, Spanish, and American empires. Princeton University Press. Showunmi, V., & Tomlin, C. (2022). Understanding and managing sophisticated and everyday racism: Implications for education and work. Rowman & Littlefield. Showunmi, V., Younas, F., & Gutman, L. M. (2024). Inclusive Supervision: Bridging the Cultural Divide. Encyclopedia, 4(1), 186-200.
Update Modus of this Database
The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER.
Search the ECER Programme
- Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
- Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
- Search for authors and in the respective field.
- For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
- If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.