Session Information
33 SES 15 A, Representations of Genders, Sexualities and Violence in and through Formal and Informal Educational Spaces
Paper Session
Contribution
In this paper, youth discourse surrounding Gender-Based Violence (GBV) and the gender binary is used as a way to critically examine the understanding of GBV constructed in the Icelandic education system. A critical-discursive approach is used to analyze how educational materials portray GBV and how Icelandic youth perceive its manifestations in their culture, as well as the impact of gendered discourse and the gender binary on their perceptions. This analysis compares the construct of GBV and its discursive context in youth culture and in the educational system in Iceland.
Iceland consistently ranks among the top countries for gender equality and is often viewed as progressive regarding sexual minority issues. Despite progressive laws and national curricula, scholars suggest that Iceland may never have been the paradise it has been portayed as, in regards to GBV and its prevention. All across Europe and other western countries, there has been a resurgence of traditional and binary gender roles. This paper therefore adresses an issue that is relevant to international research on GBV, as well as contributing to the growing body of literature examining how imported discourses affect youths perspective, discourse and subsequently their culture.
A critical-discursive approach is adopted to analyze how GBV is portrayed in educational materials. From a Foucauldian perspective, the emphasis on specific epistemologies creates distinct understandings, and social power is transferred through discourse by controlling the narrative of what knowledge is valuable to the epistemology of any given field. The analyzed material forms a framework for how an understanding of GBV is constructed within the Icelandic educational system, indicating what knowledge is deemed valuable for GBV prevention.
I will discuss youth perceptions of GBV from the persepctive of Liz Kelly’s conceptualization of a continuum of violence. Youth discourse on gender identity, roles, harassment, and GBV is analyzed, establishing a continuum from everyday discourse to GBV. Kelly’s work higlighted various manifestations of violence and harassment that were prevalent in women’s lives and were considered typical, socially sanctioned behaviour of men, making it difficult for women to classify them as violent. The continuum concept has later been applied to GBV in a wider context, including behaviours such as homophobic or transphobic comments and online expressions that are sexist or normalize sexual objectification. The continuum framework emphasizes that events and behaviours do not exist in isolated categories but tend to intersect. Suggesting that addressing only one end of the continuum of GBV, such as rape and domestic homicide, without challenging everyday manifestations and attitudes of sexism and gender hierarchies is insufficient for prevention purpose
Given the complexity of GBV, I will draw on the concept of intersectionality, which seeks to understand society from multiple perspectives that are multiplicative rather than additive. Intersectionality is grounded in Critical Race Theory, which problematises the way we view racism and its societal manifestations. Similarly, Queer Theory critisises how everyday life marginalises queer individuals, while disability studies expose how marginalisation is created in an ableist society. All three theories offer a critical lens for examining the educational system.
In order to use the results of the discourse analysis of youths' perceptions of GBV to critically analyse how the Icelandic education system covers the manifestations faced by youth, the paper will answer the following questions:
Q1: What gaps exist between the manifestations of GBV in youth culture and the education provided in Iceland's education system?
Q2: How do educational materials contextualise and address a continuum of GBV?
Q3: How are the voices of marginalised youth represented in the educational material?
Method
The analysis presented in this paper is built on two research phases using two different data-gathering methods: Focus group interviews with youth; and gathering teaching material used for GBV prevention in Iceland. In both, research methods are qualitative and all material was analysed using a critical discursive analysis method. The focus group interviews with youth allowed the researcher to gain insight into the experiences and realities of participants and what meaning they place into them. Each of the interviews was conducted with a small groups of friends or acquaintances, 3-7 youth at a time. Gatekeepers would therefore make contact with a group of friends or a young person that then discusses the idea of participation with peers. The group would then jointly make the decision to participate or not. The friend group method was chosen to allow for a free discourse of youth culture, not only between youth and researcher but also among the youth themselves. The analysis of the construct of GBV in the educational system included educational material for youth intended to educate on and/or prevent GBV in Iceland. The construction of GBV in the materials is layered, ranging from the language used or the tone of the text to the broader patterns of the texts’ structures. The data consists of educational works in or related to the field of GBV available on the website stoppofbeldi.is (e. stop violence), created as a part of a parliamentary resolution on prevention. The web page is intended as an educational hub where educators can find all materials about and/or to prevent GBV. The selection was narrowed further by the researcher. All of the data is analysed using Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA). CDA helps the researcher to better understand micro levels of the texts through „the detail of linguistic interaction in a particular context“ (Coyle, 2021, p. 278) as well as macro levels and hegemonic discourses in the texts analysed and how they serve to create and maintain power and reinforce social structures.
Expected Outcomes
The results of the educational material analysis reveal an incomplete image of GBV, reinforcing normative understandings and marginalizing minority youth. Apart from one text, written from a gender studies point of view, the discourse does not contextualize GBV; rather, the focus is individualised, without problematising sociocultural or economic aspects of GBV. The preliminary results from focus group interviews with youth show a much more complex picture of GBV, with very clear continuums from everyday discourse to violence that make it difficult to draw a clear line between acceptable, harmful, or violent discourse or behavior. In addition, a rigid policing of gender roles through discourse and binary ideas of gender supports a culture that fosters violence rather than combating it. Discourse and ideas seem to normalise certain manifestations of gendered harassment and violence and further marginalise minority youth. The author concludes that the implications of generalised descriptions in educational material, as well as the construction of commonality, create a hegemonic discourse that marginalises minority youth. The findings show that youth receive minimal education on the context in which GBV takes place and little, if any, on their own cultures. It is doubtful that education on generalised, non-contextual manifestations of GBV can effectively contribute to the prevention of GBV when youth's understanding of manifestations contradicts what is taught. This highlights the need for a more intersectional approach that does not seek to overly simplify the complex issue of GBV.
References
Alcoff, L. M. (2018). Rape and Resistance. Polity Press. Anitha, S., & Lewis, R. (2018). Introduction: Some reflections in these promising and challenging times. In S. Anitha & R. Lewis (Eds.), Gender based violence in university communities: Policy, prevention and educational initiatives in Britain. Policy Press. Bates, L. (2014). Everyday Sexism. Simon & Schuster UK. Brah, A., & Phoenix, A. (2013). Ain’t IA Woman? Revisiting Intersectionality. Journal of International Women’s Studies, 5(3), 75–86. Butler, J. (1990). Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity. Routledge. Campbell, F. K. (2009). Contours of Ableism: The production of disability and abledness. Palgrave Macmillan. Crenshaw, K. (1991). Mapping the margins: Intersectionality, identity politics, and violence against women of color. Stanford Law Review, 43(6). Foucault, M. (1978). The History of Sexuality. Volume I: An introduction. Random House. Gill, A. (2018). Survivor-Centered Research: Towards an Intersectional Gender-Based Violence Movement. Journal of Family Violence, 33(8), 559–562. Kelly, L. (1988). Surviving Sexual Violence. Polity Press. Sundaram, V. (2018). A continuum of acceptability: Understanding young people’s views on gender based violence. In S. Anitha & R. Lewis (Eds.), Gender based violence in university communities: Policy, prevention and educational initiatives.
Update Modus of this Database
The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER.
Search the ECER Programme
- Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
- Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
- Search for authors and in the respective field.
- For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
- If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.