Session Information
32 SES 07 B, Whose Knowledge Counts - Agency, Counter-Practices and Organizational Learning
Paper Session
Contribution
This paper examines how school participation settings organise whose knowledge counts in interactions between schools and parents. Rather than explaining unequal participation mainly through parents’ individual resources, the paper reconstructs how participation is shaped through role-making, credibility judgements, and discursive boundaries in everyday school–family encounters. The guiding question is: How do parental roles become epistemic categories that structure credibility and ‘actionability’ of parents’ knowledge—and how are these roles co-produced by schools and parents?
Analytically, the study follows Situational Analysis (Clarke, 2018) and works the situation through situational, relational, and positional maps. This mapping sequence is essential for reconstructing parental roles not as personal attributes, but as discursive positions that emerge from patterned relations and include sites of discursive silence. It draws on a theory-driven qualitative subsample from the project SODETE (“Social and Democratic Participation through Parent Participation”), based on 12 semi-structured interviews with parents, school leaders, school social workers and municipal actors, and three participant observations of formal participation settings (two parent council meetings and one parents’ evening). Following Clarke’s mapping practices, the analysis develops situational maps and positional maps to identify role positions and their relations, including sites of discursive silence—positions that are not openly voiced or represented, yet still shape the situation through what others anticipate, avoid, or mark as ‘not us’.
The paper’s central argument is that participation settings generate and stabilise parental roles that function as epistemic categories: they define what ‘good’ participation looks like and, at the same time, determine which kinds of parental knowing are treated as credible and relevant. Using the lens of epistemic injustice, the analysis traces two linked processes: unequal credibility (some parents are treated as more trustworthy or competent knowers than others) and uneven interpretive uptake (some experience-based accounts do not become meaningful within institutional frames and therefore fail to travel into organisational action).
Empirically, two role-making mechanisms are foregrounded. First, participation is moralised through responsibilising role constructions (“parents must also…”). This frames cooperation and educational success as parental duties, while organisational conditions that would support recognition (e.g., translation, low-threshold formats, reliable feedback loops) remain weakly secured. Second, the role of the “passive”, “uninterested”, or “hard-to-reach” parent is produced as a negative reference point. Importantly, this role is not only constructed by the organisation through familiar categories (e.g., ‘hard to reach’). It is also actively reconstructed within parent communities: ‘good’ or highly engaged parents draw boundaries by distancing themselves from imagined others (“those parents who do not care“, „those who never show up”), thereby making this role socially real even when it is not represented by an identifiable persona. In Clarke’s terms, these negative reference roles operate as sites of discursive silence: powerful in organising participation, yet rarely available as legitimate, speakable positions.
A Key finding is therefore relational: role positions are co-produced across school and parent worlds. Parents do not merely ‘adapt’; they participate in the ongoing construction of legitimacy by aligning with expected codes of ‘proper’ participation, by translating their concerns into institutionally acceptable frames, or by withholding issues that would risk being read as ‘demanding’ or ‘difficult’. This helps explain why epistemic inequalities can persist without overt exclusion: voice may be formally invited, yet resonance and uptake depend on role-based legitimacy regimes and the discursive boundaries they create.
The paper contributes to research on school–family participation by showing how epistemic (in)justice is organised through parental role-making and discursive silence. For debates on knowing and acting, it specifies how participation becomes effective (or ineffective) depending on the recognition and translation of parents’ knowledge within these role regimes.
Method
This paper uses Situational Analysis as a mapping-based methodology to reconstruct how parent participation is organised through role positions, legitimacy, and discursive silence (Clarke et al., 2018). Empirically, it draws on a theory-driven qualitative subsample from the project SODETE (“Social and Democratic Participation through Parent Participation”), comprising 12 semi-structured interviews (parents, school leaders, school social workers, and municipal actors) and three participant observations (two parent council meetings and one parents’ evening). Transcripts and fieldnotes were pseudonymised. The aim is analytic generalisation through mechanism reconstruction rather than estimating prevalence. Analytically, the study “works the situation” through an iterative sequence of mapping and memoing. The analysis begins with messy situational maps for central data units to lay out the situation in its breadth: key human and non-human elements, organisational arrangements, discursive constructions, and absences. These messy maps were then refined into ordered situational maps to clarify which elements were most consequential for the emerging focus on how parents are positioned as more or less credible knowers in participation settings. From these situational inventories, the analysis moves into relational analysis. Relational maps were developed to ask how the identified elements are linked and co-constituted—specifically, how role labels, access practices (e.g., translation, invitation routines, feedback channels), communicative expectations, and moral framings hang together in organising participation. This step is crucial because the role positions at stake are not simply ‘in the data’ as fixed categories; they emerge through patterned connections and filtering points that can only be made visible by explicitly mapping relations. On this basis, positional maps were produced to reconstruct the discursive possibility spaces within which participation becomes meaningful and actionable. Positional mapping allowed the analysis to distinguish discursive positions from persons, and to identify sites of discursive silence: positions that are not claimed as legitimate standpoints in the setting, yet still organise participation because others orient to them through anticipatory distancing and boundary work. In the empirical material, negatively marked roles such as the ‘passive’ or ‘hard-to-reach’ parent operate as such silent reference positions, shaping credibility and speakability even when no identifiable actor ‘occupies’ them. To situate these role dynamics beyond single encounters, social worlds/arenas mapping was used to locate collective actors and arenas through which participation is organised. Finally, selected scenes/vignettes were developed as worked exemplars to connect the mapping results back to concrete moments of interaction and to show how roles, relations, and silences are enacted in practice.
Expected Outcomes
This paper shows that epistemic (in)justice is not an add-on to parent participation but a constitutive feature of how participation is organised in school–family settings. Using Situational Analysis, the study reconstructs parental roles as discursive positions that shape credibility, speakability, and the likelihood that parents’ knowledge will be translated into organisational action. Inequalities in participation are therefore not primarily explained by parents’ individual “barriers”, but by role-based legitimacy codes that define what counts as reasonable, cooperative, and decision-relevant knowing. Two mechanisms are central. First, responsibilising role constructions frame participation as moral duty of parents, while organisational conditions that would support access and recognition remain weakly institutionalised. Second, negatively marked roles such as the “passive”, “uninterested”, or “hard-to-reach” parent operate as powerful reference points. These roles often function as sites of discursive silence: they are rarely claimed as legitimate standpoints, yet they organise participation because other actors orient to them through anticipatory distancing and boundary work. In the material, “good” or highly engaged parents co-produce this order by drawing boundaries against imagined others, thereby making the negative role socially real even when it is not represented by identifiable personas. A key contribution of the paper is to show how these role regimes become durable. Parents do not only respond to institutional expectations; they actively reproduce legitimacy codes by aligning their talk and conduct with what they expect to be recognised, withholding concerns that risk delegitimation, or withdrawing from formal settings. In this way, participation can be formally invited while resonance and organisational uptake remain unevenly distributed—captured here as “voice without resonance”. For research on school–family participation, the findings underline that improving participation cannot be reduced to expanding formats or invitations. It requires transforming the role positions and discursive boundaries through which parents’ knowledge is recognised, ignored, or silenced.
References
1.Arnstein, S. R. (1969). A ladder of citizen participation. Journal of the American Institute of Planners, 35(4), 216–224. https://doi.org/10.1080/01944366908977225 2.Betz, T., Bischoff, S., Eunicke, N., Kayser, L. B., & Zink, K. (2017). Partner auf Augenhöhe? Forschungsbefunde zur Zusammenarbeit von Familien, Kitas und Schulen mit Blick auf Bildungschancen. Kurzfassung. Gütersloh: Bertelsmann Stiftung. ISBN: 978-3-86793-815-0 3.Chamakalayil, L.; Ivanova-Chessex, O.; Leutwyler, B.; Scharathow, W. (Hrsg.) (2022): Eltern und pädagogische Institutionen. Macht- und ungleichheitskritische Perspektiven. Weinheim, Basel: Beltz Juventa. 4.Clarke, A. E., Friese, C., & Washburn, R. S. (2018). Situational analysis: Grounded theory after the interpretive turn (2nd ed.). SAGE. 5.Crozier, G., & Davies, J. (2007). Hard to reach parents or hard to reach schools? A discussion of home–school relations, with particular reference to Bangladeshi and Pakistani parents. British Educational Research Journal, 33(3), 295–313. https://doi.org/10.1080/01411920701243578 6.Fricker, M. (2007). Epistemic injustice: Power and the ethics of knowing. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 7.Fürstenau, S., & Gomolla, M. (Hrsg.). (2009). Migration und schulischer Wandel: Elternbeteiligung. VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-531-91457-2 8.Giddens, A. (1984). The Constitution of Society: Outline of the Theory of Structuration. Cambridge: Polity Press. 9.Gomolla, M. & Radtke, F.-O. (2009). Institutionelle Diskriminierung. Die Herstellung ethnischer Differenz in der Schule (3. Aufl.). Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.
Update Modus of this Database
The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER.
Search the ECER Programme
- Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
- Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
- Search for authors and in the respective field.
- For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
- If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.