Session Information
32 SES 11 B, Organizational Learning in Higher Education Institutions
Paper Session
Contribution
Educational discourse commonly has a future-oriented disposition, but these notions of future ideals are not formed in a vacuum. They are shaped and informed by past educational struggles, development, and scholarly inquiry, which have led to questioning what education is for and what kinds of changes are possible for educational improvement. In contemporary higher education (HE) research, social justice in education and socially just education embed notions and conceptualisations of reimagined future possibilities, yet these futures are rarely explicitly discussed or theorised, even though they play a central role in shaping the discourse. This paper argues that a historically informed ‘utopia as method’ application to the existing and future discourse can offer a theoretical and methodological lens through which past educational imaginings can shape present practices and facilitate future reimagining of socially just HE.
Utilising utopia as a method to guide education towards its idealised future form comprises three modes: archaeology, ontology, and architecture (Levitas, 2013). When applied to an education context, the archaeology mode requires reflexive practice to examine what constitutes a ‘good education’. Absences and deficiencies can be identified by examining the historical and present foundations of educational systems, institutions, and policies. Critiquing the usefulness of these elements in the envisioned future of education will clarify which policies and practices facilitate socially just education and which do not (Levitas, 2013, pp. 153-174). In ontology mode, there is a reorientation of perspective: we are required to look forward to the future to specify how we want to restructure society based on the archaeological mode’s discoveries. In this mode, ‘what is understood as human flourishing, what capabilities are valued, encouraged and genuinely enabled, or blocked and suppressed, by specific existing or potential social arrangements’ (Levitas, 2013, p. 153) are explored and critiqued. Lastly, the architectural mode involves the (re)imagining of potential futures and possibilities, guided by the critiques of the previous modes. However, once the imagined future is visualised, the actual implementation of creating utopias can take different forms. Wright’s (2010) transformation types can help scholars realise pathways to actualise socially just HE.
Wright (2010) suggests three transformation types: ruptural, interstitial, and symbiotic. Ruptural transformations require a ‘direct confrontation and political struggles…[to] create a radical disjuncture in institutional structures in which existing institutions are destroyed and new ones built in a fairly rapid way’ (Wright, 2007, p. 6). In contrast, interstitial transformations are based on ‘incremental modifications of the underlying structures of a social system’ (Wright, 2010, p. 321), while symbiotic transformations require collaboration with the institutions in power to solve identified problems while expanding ‘the scope of social empowerment’ (Wright, 2007, p. 6). Complete ruptures of educational systems and institutions may not be possible. However, interstitial and symbiotic transformations may be more accessible to scholars in their everyday practice, for example, through the pedagogies they employ in their classes, student/staff co-creation of curriculum, creation and/or adoption of artificial intelligence (AI) for classroom use, or other experimental interventions.
Integrating utopian methodology with educational reimagining of future socially just possibilities, this paper demonstrates how educational futures are shaped by historical developments and present practices. The paper argues for the explicit use of archaeology, ontology, and architectural modes in social justice in education and in socially just educational discourse to contextualise the work already done and to chart the way forward in HE research. This will enable scholars to move toward more reflective, reflexive, imaginative, and socially just educational futures.
Method
This paper employs ‘utopia as method’ (Levitas, 2013) to study social justice in education and socially just educational discourse as an object of inquiry, with the aim of reimaging socially just educational futures in HE. It has been likened ‘to a thought experiment that encourages thinkers to transcend that which currently is by engaging in the imagined reconstruction of society’ (Baker, 2020, p. 24). While employing ‘utopia as method’, scholars are not restricted to a single methodology, but can employ varied methodologies in their examinations and critiques. The first mode of ‘utopia as method’ is archaeology. By this, Levitas (2013) means ‘piecing together the images of the good society that are embedded in political programmes and social and economic policies’ (p. 153). This involves examining our current and past societal ‘worlds’, understanding their historical significance and development, critiquing them, and problematising our institutions and societies. ‘We live in an era dominated by the present tense, which vastly undervalues the accumulated experience of the past as a guide for where we go next’ (Krznaric, 2025, p. 1). The archaeology mode is not a historical description but rather an examination of the futures embedded within past discourse. The second mode is ontology, ‘which addresses the question of what kind of people particular societies develop and encourage’ (emphasis in the original) (Levitas, 2013, p. 153). Levitas highlights that this mode is necessary because ‘any discussion of the good society must contain, at least implicitly, a claim for a way of being that is posited as better than our current experience’ (p. 177). She frames this as a process of ‘becoming’ (Levitas, 2013, pp. 180-181), because the person should be considered in a continuous state of change and transformation that is shaped by social, institutional, and educational contexts. The third mode is architecture, ‘the imagination of potential alternative scenarios for the future’ (Levitas, 2013, p. 153). This mode is focused on ‘world-building’, including explorations of what human flourishing means and how we can achieve it and ‘describing its social institutions’ (Levitas, 2013, p. 197). Architecture mode is a laborious project because a balance must be struck between what society should look like and the pathways for achieving such visions. The idea here is not to create a whole new world from the first day. Architecture can begin small with one contained alternative (e.g., classroom practice) and expand over time (e.g., creating new educational structures).
Expected Outcomes
Many contemporary scholars in the field of social justice in education and socially just education implicitly incorporate utopian ideals in their work. Reimagined futures for socially just HE are incorporated into critiques and research focused on equity, inclusion, participation, student voice, etc., without explicitly linking the philosophical basis to the future reimaging present in their work. As a result, the philosophical foundations of social justice in education and of socially just education remain implicit rather than systematically explored, even as they continue to shape what is considered possible and desirable in HE. Linking Levitas’ (2013) conceptual framework of ‘utopia as method’ seeks to strengthen and extend current social justice research work. The archaeological, ontological, and architectural modes can provide scholars with a structure to make future reimaginings explicit in their work. Through the archaeology mode, scholars can situate their work within historical educational developments and struggles, while the ontology mode can outline clearly the type of person that socially just education seeks to cultivate. Finally, the architecture mode allows scholars to engage with the future possibilities of socially just HE, taking into account the variety of transformation options that may facilitate the utopian ideal’s realisation (Wright, 2010). Linking social justice work in HE to a utopian framework facilitates reflexive practices for change and transformation by clarifying the futures toward which current socially just scholarship is oriented. Making these aspects of social justice in education and socially just education explicit strengthens the theoretical and philosophical foundations of social justice research and enhances its capacity to reimagine socially just educational futures.
References
Baker, M. (2020). Utopias and reimagining the reimagining of higher education. Cambridge Educational Research e-Journal, 7, 18–34. https://doi.org/10.17863/CAM.58325 Krznaric, R. (2025). History for tomorrow: How the past can inspire our future. Penguin. Levitas, R. (2013). Utopia as method: The imaginary reconstitution of society. Palgrave Macmillan. Wright, E. O. (2007). Guidelines for envisioning real utopias. Surroundings. https://doi.org/10.3898/136266207820465778 Wright, E. O. (2010). Envisioning real utopias. Verso.
Update Modus of this Database
The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER.
Search the ECER Programme
- Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
- Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
- Search for authors and in the respective field.
- For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
- If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.