Session Information
32 SES 03 B, Vulnerability, Management & Reform
Paper Session
Contribution
Although it is assumed that the organisational social capital of interorganisational networks can impact their effectiveness, there is little empirical evidence to support this claim. The purpose of this paper is to discuss how organisational social capital at network level affects the effectiveness of Dutch regional networks in education.
Social capital theory posits that social relationships provide access to resources, such as advice, support and information, which can be exchanged, borrowed and leveraged to achieve individual and collective goals (Bourdieu, 1986; Putnam,1993). Building on the notion that well connected social relationships within and between organisations are vital to the exchange of knowledge, learning, improvement and innovation in organisations (Cross and Parker, 2004), organisationalsocialcapital has been coined as an important source for organisational advantage. Research has shown that organisational problems of coordination can be overcome by facilitating the flow of valuable resources between individuals (i.e., Adler and Kwon, 2002; Leana and Pil, 2009; Tantardini and Kroll, 2015).
Also in educational settings, organisational social capital has proven a useful concept to understand how a collaborating community could stimulate effective governance and policy implementation (Fredette and Bradshaw, 2012; Hooge, et al, 2019; Saatcioglu et al., 2011), not only within individual organisations, but also in interorganisational networks (Adler and Kwon, 2002). Based on the concept of organisational social capital, interorganisational networks are viewed as a set of social relationships, interactions, and resources, which offers a fruitful perspective for research into the transfer and sharing of valuable resources affecting the functioning and performance of the network (Inkpen and Tsang, 2005; Tsai and Ghoshal, 1998).
The interorganisational networks our research focuses on are regional networks in the field of education in the Netherlands, composed of school districts and other organisations in and around education. Various types of these networks were involved in our research project, divided across three themes: professionalisation, educational innovation and advanced care issues, and across three education sub-sectors: primary education, secondary education and intermediate vocational education. Furthermore, these interorganisational networks differ in the way they were established (a) through incentives via subsidies from the national government; (b) on the initiative of school districts, or (c) on a mandatory legal basis.
Our research question was:
(How) Does the organisational social capital of Dutch regional networks in education affects their effectiveness?
Nahapiet and Ghoshal (1998) conceptualize social capital in three dimensions: 1) a structural dimension, involving the configuration of the network in terms of patterns of relationships between individuals; 2) a relational dimension, referring to socio-emotional characteristics of mutual relationships, e.g. trust or care for, and 3) a cognitive dimension referring to the mental connectivity between network members e.g. shared vision or knowledge exchange. Here, we have limited the operationalisation of organisation social capital to the relational and cognitive dimensions, investigating these in survey research. The structural dimension is not included because that would require a methodologically different approach, involving social network analysis and measures such as density, centrality and hierarchy (Hooge et al., 2019; Saatcioglu et al., 2011).
Drawing on literature on governance effectiveness and decision-making processes, effectiveness of interorganisational networks has been operationalized as the extent to which these networks succeed in jointly 1) deliberating and weighing up interests, 2) taking decisions, and 3) monitoring compliance with decisions (Dholakia & Bagozzi, 2022; Jackson & Holland, 1998; Van Popering-Verkerk & Van Buuren, 2016).
Method
Our mixed-methods research design involved empirical enquiry using quantitative and qualitative research. Data were collected through a survey among 208 members of 29 regional networks and through interviews with 34 network coordinators (i.e., some networks have multiple coordinators). A semi-structured interview protocol was developed, using the critical incident method (Allen, 2017). With consent of the interviewees, the interviews were recorded and transcribed. The interview data were coded and analysed. The following research instruments used in the survey were developed based on literature review and (translation) of existing instruments: I Organisation Social Capital / Cronbach’s alpha: .93, 13 items: I.1 Relational dimension / Cronbach’s alpha: .89, 6 items I.1.1 Mutual Trust / Cronbach’s alpha: .85, 3 items I.1.2 Mutual Affection / Cronbach’s alpha: .87, 3 items I.2 Cognitive dimension / Cronbach’s alpha: .89, 7 items I.2.1Shared Vision / Cronbach’s alpha: .90, 4 items I.2.2 Exchange Knowledge and Information / Cronbach’s alpha: .87, 3 items II Interorganisational Network Effectiveness Cronbach’s alpha: .89,9 items: II.1 Making Decisions Cronbach’s alpha: .78 , 5 items II.1.1 Deliberation of Decisions Cronbach’s alpha: .86, 3 items II.1.2 Taking joint Decisions Cronbach’s alpha: .70, 2 items II.2 Monitoring Compliance of Decisions Cronbach’s alpha: .91, 4 items The survey has been tested on responses of 81 school district administrators. Item reduction and optimalisation of instruments was carried out with factor analyses, reliability analyses, inter-item correlations, and face validity checks. The survey was distributed across all members of the 29 regional networks. Since not all network members participated in the survey (response rate 53%), Inter-Class Coefficients (ICC) as Estimates of Interrater Reliability have been calculated, following Shrout and Fleiss (1979). The average absolute agreement of all networks was .94 with a 95% conference level between .91% and .96%, which indicates a high degree of reliability (Koo & Li, 2016). The survey data are of multi-level character: 208 individual respondents (network members) are nested in 29 groups (networks), consisting of individual perceptions (level-1-variables) and aggregated perceptions (level-2-variables). Both levels have been combined in multi-level analyses, including the network-id as a latent variable to account for possible network-by-network effects. The model of the three variables representing interorganisational network effectiveness as dependent variables and the four variables measuring organisational social capital as independent variables, was analysed in Stata using Generalized Structural Equation Modeling.
Expected Outcomes
The presence of organisation social capital within interorganisational networks promotes their effectiveness: our results indicate that the more social capital the regional networks dispose of, the more effective they are. The cognitive dimension of organisational social capital matters more than the relational dimension. Regarding the relational dimension: mutual affection between network members has no influence whatsoever. Only mutual trust between network members partly positively influences decision-making (both deliberation and decision-taking), but it has no influence on monitoring compliance of decisions. This is remarkable, given that in the literature mutual trust is considered a critical factor of organisational social capital (Hooge, et al, 2019; Inkpen & Tsang, 2005), solving coordination problems and strongly influencing people's behavior (Nahapiet & Goshal, 1998; Saatcioglu et al., 2011). With regard to the cognitive dimension, the existence of shared vision in particular, and also the exchange of knowledge and information, turn out to have a major influence on decision-making and monitoring compliance. That shared vision is a crucial factor for organisational social capital is confirmed by the literature: it embodies the collective goals and ambitions of network members (Tsai and Ghoshal, 1998), promotes the exchange of resources, and leads to joint action and collective responsibility (Hooge, et al., 2019; Saatcioglu et al., 2011). Our interview data provide an interesting insight into what shared vision entails in practice: it is often ‘rather vague’ and usually formulated in such general terms that ‘no one can disagree with it’. This raises the question of how a vague or broadly formulated shared vision can align the members of the network and lead them toward common goals. We will study theory and research literature on ‘boundary objects’ (Star, 2010) and ‘empty signifiers’ (e.g., Sørensen & Torfing, 2005) to explain this in more detail theoretically.
References
Adler, P. S., & Kwon, S. W. (2002). Social capital: Prospects for a new concept. Academy of Management Review, 27(1), 17–40. Bourdieu, P. (1986). The forms of capital, in Richards, J.C. (Ed.), Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education, Greenwood Press, New York, NY, pp. 241-258. Cross, R. and Parker, A. (2004). The Hidden Power of Social Networks. Understanding How Work Really Gets Done in Organisations, Harvard Business School Press, Boston, MA. Dholakia, U.M. & Bagozzi, R.P. (2002). Mustering motivation to enhance decisions: how decision process characteristics influence goal realisation. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 15: 167-188. Fredette, C. and Bradshaw, P. (2012). Social capital and nonprofit governance effectiveness, Nonprofit Management and Leadership, 22(4), 391-409. Hooge, E. H., Moolenaar, N. M., van Look, K. C. J., Janssen, S. K., & Sleegers, P. J. C. (2019). The role of district leaders for organization social capital. Journal of Educational Administration, 57(3), 296–316. Inkpen, A.C. and Tsang, E.W.K. (2005). Social capital, networks and knowledge transfer, Academy of Management Review, 30(1), 146-165. Jackson, D.K. & Holland, T.P. (1998). Measuring the effectiveness of nonprofit boards. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 27(2): 159-182. Leana, C.R. and Pil, F.K. (2006). Social capital and organisational performance: evidence from urban public schools, Organisation Science, 17(3),353-366. Nahapiet, J., & Ghoshal, S. (1998). Social capital, intellectual capital, and the organizational advantage. Academy of Management Review, 23(2), 242–266. Popering-Verkerk, J. van & Buuren, A. Van (2016). Decision-making patterns in multilevel governance: the contribution of informal and procedural interactions to significant multilevel decisions. Public Management Review, 18(7),951 - 971. Putnam, R.D. (1993). The prosperous community: social capital and public life, American Prospect, 13(3), 35-42. Saatcioglu, A., Moore, S., Sargut, G. and Bajaj, A. (2011). The role of school district social capital in district governance: effects on financial and academic outcomes. Leadership and Policy in School, 10(1),1-42. Sørensen, E., & Torfing, J. (2005). The democratic anchorage of governance networks. Scandinavian Political Studies, 28(3), 195–218. Star, S. L. (2010). This is not a boundary object: Reflections on the origin of a concept. Science, Technology, & Human Values, 35(5), 601–617. Tantardini, M., & Kroll, A. (2015). The role of organisational social capital in performance management. Public Performance & Management Review, 39(1), 83-99. Tsai, W., & Ghoshal, S. (1998). Social capital and value creation: the role of intra-firm network. The Academy of Management Journal, 41(4), 464–476.
Update Modus of this Database
The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER.
Search the ECER Programme
- Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
- Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
- Search for authors and in the respective field.
- For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
- If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.