Session Information
32 SES 07 B, Whose Knowledge Counts - Agency, Counter-Practices and Organizational Learning
Paper Session
Contribution
The study also contributes to our understanding of the factors that influence the three types of strategic responses of teacher organizations to the rise of neo-liberal policies: (1) resistance to proposed or actual changes; (2) rapprochement, or acquiescing to changing circumstances, often viewed as a necessary trade-off; and (3) renewal, or an adherence to the organization’s own priorities, making “use” of change in order to advance the organizational agenda (Carter, Stevenson, & Passy, 2010).
This paper investigates how the Union of Education Norway (UEN) has understood and responded to neoliberal reforms over the past three decades. The case study of the UEN is one of four teacher organizations that participated in a longer-term study initiated in 2020 – the Queensland Teachers’ Union (QTU), New Zealand Educational Institute (NZEI) and the California Teachers’ Association (CTA).
The research project considers the perspectives of senior organizational leaders to examine the extent to which and under what conditions their organizations have taken proactive, agentic stances in support of teachers, teaching, and the quality of public education in relation to the impacts of neoliberalism on education and the “global educational reform movement” or Global Education Reform Movement (Sahlberg, 2011, 2013; Verger & Altinyelkin, 2013). These ideological shifts have intensified teacher organizations’ disadvantageous position within education systems. Furthermore, Robertson (2012) and Lingard (2010; Lingard et al., 2013) articulate the "architectures" of neoliberal globalization that have impacted the education sector, detailing how global policy actors and organizations (such as the OECD and World Bank) construct supranational governance structures that bypass national democratic debate, reshaping education systems toward economic competitiveness and human capital formation.
Rather than offering a chronological history of each union over the span of the leaders’ careers, the study utilizes a specific conceptual framework proposed by Huidan Niu (2025) to analyze union strategy. Niu’s systematic review posits that teacher organizations efforts to advocate for their members is a dynamic process shaped by the interplay of three strategic activities:
1. Discursive strategies: How unions frame problems, define teacher professionalism, and utilize language to shape public and member understanding.
2. Relational strategies: How unions configure their relationships with the state, employers, communities, and other social actors.
3. Contextual strategies: How unions read, adapt to, and leverage the specific political, historical, and institutional structures in which they operate.
We apply Niu’s (2025) tripartite framework across three distinct domains or spheres of activity common to all four unions: 1. Governance, 2. Curriculum and Assessment, and3. the COVID-19 Crisis.
Domain 1: Governance
The domain of governance concerns the fundamental architecture of decision-making in education: who has the authority to decide policy, how resources are distributed, and the mechanisms through which teachers act as either subjects or agents of the system. Under neoliberal architectures (Robertson, 2012), governance has often shifted toward managerialism, decentralization of responsibility coupled with centralization of control, and the erosion of intermediary bodies like unions.
Domain 2: Curriculum, Assessment, and Accountability
This domain sits at the core of the neoliberal project in education: the redefinition of learning as measurable output, the standardization of curriculum, and the use of data for surveillance and market competition (Lingard, Martino, & Rezai-Rashti 2013). This is where the Global Educational Reform Movement is most visible.
Domain 3: Responses to the COVID-19 Crisis
The pandemic acted as a sudden stress test for the neoliberal education settlement. It stripped away the normal routines of schooling and forced a confrontation with the essential nature of teaching, safety, and system capacity. It represented a unique "state of exception" where the usual rules of governance and accountability were suspended, potentially illustrative of Klein's (2007) shock doctrine in real-time.
Method
For each teacher organization, two senior long-standing organizational members (i.e. chief executive officers, presidents) were interviewed regarding the events that had shaped their organizations’ stances toward changing circumstances and how, if at all, these changes had led to shifts in organizational capacity to respond to or catalyze changes to educational policy and practice. For each organization, two to three one-hour one interviews were conducted over the space of two years. The interviews were anchored on responses to these questions: • Describe how you became involved in the organization and any significant influences that led you to taking on your leadership role. • We are interested in the kinds catalytic or ‘big’ events that may have had an impact on the organization. Please think back over the course of your work and describe the impacts these events may have had on how the organization operated. (Variations included references to the capacity to plan and react to short and long-term changes.) • What opportunities and constraints influenced the responses to these events and their effectiveness? (Variations included references to the effectiveness of responses and internal and external influences.) • Given your previous responses, how has the organization changed in terms of its ability to adapt to and anticipate change? • How did the organization respond to the pandemic and what have been any impacts on its work moving forward? Based on recordings and transcripts, a summary was developed for each organization, and cross-case analyses helped to develop more robust understandings of the choices of teacher organizations in relation to changing circumstances. Individuals who were interviewed were asked to read and comment on their own organization’s case and on lessons emerging from cross-case analysis. In follow-up feedback to the summaries, those interviewed stressed the need to recognize that every teacher union is unique and operates within its own unique context.
Expected Outcomes
The following highlight the key findings of the UEN case study across the three domains of governance, curriculum and assessment and the response to the Covid 19 pandemic: • UEN’s strategies are deeply embedded in the Nordic model of tripartite cooperation. Despite the "PISA shock" of 2001, which introduced neoliberal anxieties, the union maintained its influence by leveraging connections with members of parliament to bypass hostile ministries. • Moving beyond arguments about test validity, the UEN embraced the language of Gert Biesta’s (2010) "beautiful risk of education." It frames the obsession with PISA and measurement not just as bad policy, but as an ontological error—a misunderstanding of what education is. • UEN’s relational strategy involved "subversive compliance." While Norway adopted national tests, the union worked through its partnership channels to strip them of high-stakes consequences for teachers and schools. By examining how the UEN deployed discursive, relational, and contextual strategies, the study identified key convergences and divergences in the responses of the UEN to neoliberalism as compared to the other three cases. We conclude by addressing two overarching questions: how can understanding the intersection of discursive, conceptual and relational strategies help compare the responses and capacities of teacher unions engaging neoliberalism, and 2) what does this reveal about the conditions under which unions can shape, resist, or redirect reform agendas?
References
Carter, B., Stevenson, H., & Passy, R. (2010). Industrial relations in education: Transforming the school workforce. New York: Routledge. Klein, N. (2007). The shock doctrine: The rise of disaster capitalism. Metropolitan Books. Lingard, B. (2010). Policy borrowing, policy learning: Testing times in Australian schooling. Critical Studies in Education, 51(2), 129-147. https://doi.org/10.1080/17508481003731026 Lingard, B., Martino, W., & Rezai-Rashti, G. (2013). Testing regimes, accountabilities and education policy: Commensurate global and national developments. Journal of Education Policy, 28(5), 539-556. https://doi.org/10.1080/02680939.2012.718356 Niu, H. (2025). How do teacher unions frame professionalism discourses in contemporary socio-political contexts? A systematic literature review. Cambridge Journal of Education, 55(2), 287-310. https://doi.org/10.1080/0305764X.2025.2486982 Robertson, S. L. (2012). Globalisation, education and the state: Contracts, competition and the commercialisation of education. In S. L. Robertson (Ed.), Globalisation and social inequalities: New exposures, old inequalities. Edward Elgar. Sahlberg, P. (2011). Paradoxes of educational improvement: The case of Finland. Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research, 55(5), 561-578. Sahlberg, P. (2013). Teaching and globalization: The end of teacher development? Retrieved from PasiSahlberg.com Verger, A., & Altinyelken, H. K. (2013). Global education reforms and the new management of teachers: A critical introduction. In A. Verger, H. K. Altinyelkin, & M. de Konig (Eds.), Global managerial education reforms and teachers (pp. 1-33). Education International.
Update Modus of this Database
The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER.
Search the ECER Programme
- Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
- Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
- Search for authors and in the respective field.
- For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
- If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.