Session Information
32 SES 10 B, Change Agents in Schooling, School Development and Innovation - Organizational Education Perspectives
Paper Session
Contribution
In current debates surrounding digital transformation and agile governance in public administration (Wirth, 2020), as well as the development of school systems (Azorín & Fullan, 2022) cooperation as knowledge and action appears as a core capacity, replacing individualized, strongly evidence focussed or hierarchical practices.
Within the framework of Educational Governance, managing interdependencies and negotiating among actors across system levels (Altrichter, 2015) are fundamental to innovation and development. Educational governance research investigates the coordination of action among different actors and considers their constellations as unit of analysis (Dietrich, 2018).
Cooperative professionalism (Hargreaves & O’Connor, 2018) manifests in the ability to perceive and represent both one’s own and others’ perspectives and to integrate them toward a shared goal. Edwards (2017) conceptualizes this two-step process as ‘relational agency’. Such open and self-reflective communication enables cyclical negotiation processes making innovations more concrete (Grosche et al., 2020) or constructive conflict resolution (Decuyper et al., 2010) and contributes to the formation of collective agency (Zumpe, 2024).
Considering diverse expectations and demands, cooperation has been widely discussed and examined in the context of instructional development (Gräsel et al., 2006; Grosche et al., 2020). However little empirical evidence exists concerning inter-level cooperation in multi-actor settings. Existing studies typically focus on dyadic relationships, such as between school supervision and school leadership, or between external evaluators and teachers (e.g., Lambrecht, 2018). Brüsemeister (2007) describes cooperation in the multi-level setting as “antagonistic cooperation” referring to different action logics of school policy, administration, and practice. The praxeology of cooperation, as integration of knowledge and action, can be described by reconstruction of practice, which is the aim of our project. To achieve this, we analyze real interactions between multi-level actors during an innovation project. We apply the Documentary Method, which allows us to uncover tensions between knowledge and action.
In our research project, actors from different levels of the school system collaborate in a joint innovation process. The project is designed as a participatory and co-creative design thinking process (Brown, 2008), initiated by administrative leaders and designed together with researchers. This project offers a dual perspective on actors’ guiding orientations toward cooperation. On the one hand, cooperation is a necessary practice for jointly generating outcomes within the design thinking process. On the other hand, cooperation becomes the thematic focus of the design challenge itself: participants are tasked with developing a prototype for a new dialogue format among stakeholders responsible for school system development. This new format aims to enable joint interpretation of school quality data and its productive use for development.
Within the project, researchers and practitioners from schools as well as administrative representatives collaborate on both the conceptual and practical levels. The resulting Research-Practice-Administration (RPA) Partnerships (Bremm & Manitius, 2019) illustrates how administration and school practitioners – and researchers as well – perform different praxeologies of cooperation. The deliberate inclusion of administrative actors generates new insights into interactions across organizational levels.
The central focus of data analysis concerns the “how” of cooperation: how cooperative practices emerge and how bodies of knowledge are discursively introduced (Weber, 2018). Another key perspective revealed through analysis pertains to speaker positions (who?) and the strategies through which actors establish authority. Gaps between knowledge and action become visible—reminiscent of Brunsson’s (1989) concept of organizational hypocrisy. The analyses illustrate how such gaps as inconsistencies within or across organizational levels may inhibit cooperation and development.
Method
The workshop format (design thinking) and innovation goal (a new cooperative dialogue format) are both grounded in principles of cooperation. This addresses participants reflexively on two levels: content and practice. By reconstructing guiding orientations through the Documentary Method (Bohnsack, 2014), different collaboration strategies pursued by individuals or groups during negotiation can be examined. Researchers accompany the process both as facilitators and as analysts. In line with the documentary method, they are considered part of the group in data analysis. The data were collected between March and September 2024. A total of three workshops were conducted involving 20 participants from diverse groups: (a) school principals, (b) teachers, (c) staff responsible for extracurricular student supervision in full-day schools, (d) school supervisors, (e) administrative system consultants, and (f) external evaluators. The group met for (1) a three-hour introductory workshop, (2) a two-day design thinking workshop, and (3) a three-hour iteration workshop. All workshop situations (both plenary sessions and group work) were audio-recorded in situ. Five cases were selected, and a total of 19 sequences were interpreted using the Documentary Method. The interpretation of in-situ documentation using the Documentary Method investigates how cooperation is enacted in the workshop situation and how it is constructed as a practice to make sense of evaluation data in a future multistakeholder conversation setting. The Documentary Method is based on the praxeological sociology of knowledge (Mannheim, 1929/2024). This approach reveals the underlying structures and patterns of social actions and orientations beyond participants' explicit perspectives. The method is continuously tested and further developed in order to address the specific characteristics of organizational contexts (Amling & Vogd, 2017). In particular, this concerns group constellations and group membership within organizations, whose shared experiential spaces differ from those of social groups. In this sense, the interpretations emerging from the actor setting within the RPA partnership open potential pathways for further methodological reflection on how to pursue the gap between knowledge and action. Such praxeological governance research (Dietrich, 2018) makes it possible to adequately consider the mechanisms of steering and negotiation in complex multi-level systems.
Expected Outcomes
The data analysis reveals differing attitudes toward cooperation and distinct negotiation practices within the actor constellation. On the knowledge level—that is, how cooperation is conceptualized for the planned conversational setting—three orientations can be reconstructed. Two types embrace cooperation as a positive norm for future collaboration: Type (a) relies on a systemic perspective and task orientation, while Type (b) builds on personal experiences of cooperation within the school community. Type (c), by contrast, centers on actors' own hierarchical positions, prioritizing existing structures; attempts to link these to the new constellation fail. Regarding the shared goal, an unresolved divergence emerges within the group, persisting through negotiation. At the action level in workshop settings, this divergence exerts a clearly inhibiting effect. Type (a) adopts a moderating role, fostering dialogue. Type (c) performatively negates cooperation through external framing (positioning issues outside the group) and pseudo-participation (superficial engagement). Type (b) exhibits resignation, as actors withdraw their positions and experience-based solution proposals. Genuine negotiation as conflict communication does not occur. Instead, substantive divides are reproduced performatively in the absence of negotiation, with conflicting positions coexisting side by side. Comparing types, type (c) predominantly aligns with roles in school administration and external evaluation. These occupy powerful positions—hierarchically above schools or school leadership (supervision) or mandated to assess quality (evaluation)—serving as key reference points even amid cooperation mandates. Their strategies of external framing and pseudo-participation notably hinder the innovation project, limiting realization of inherent potentials like systemic thinking and community cooperation experience. The praxeological approach – through the inclusion of administrative actors in a Research-Practice-Administration (RPA) partnership – illuminates power dynamics at multi-level interfaces and exposes the gap between institutional programs (knowledge) and everyday practice (action), rendering them visible and discussable.
References
Altrichter, H. (2015). Governance – Steuerung und Handlungskoordination bei der Transformation von Bildungssystemen. In H. J. Abs, T. Brüsemeister, M. Schemmann, & J. Wissinger (Hrsg.), Governance im Bildungssystem Analysen zur Mehrebenenperspektive, Steuerung und Koordination (S. 21–63). Springer. Amling, S., & Vogd, W. (Hrsg.). (2017). Dokumentarische Organisationsforschung: Perspektiven der praxeologischen Wissenssoziologie. Budrich. Azorín, C., & Fullan, M. (2022). Leading new, deeper forms of collaborative cultures: Questions and pathways. Journal of Educational Change, 23(1), 131–143. Bohnsack, R. (2021). Rekonstruktive Sozialforschung: Einführung in qualitative Methoden. Budrich. Bremm, N., & Manitius, V. (2019). Knowledge brokerage through research-practice-administration partnerships. In J. Malin & C. Brown (Hrsg.), The Role of Knowledge Brokers in Education (S. 139–153). Routledge. Brunsson, Nils (1989): The organization of Hyprocrisy. Talk, Decisions and Actions in Organizations. Hoboken. Wiley. Brüsemeister, T. (2007). Steuerungsakteure und ihre Handlungslogiken im Mehrebenensystem der Schule. In Governance, Schule und Politik (S. 63–95). VS. Decuyper, S., Dochy, F., & Van Den Bossche, P. (2010). Grasping the dynamic complexity of team learning: An integrative model for effective team learning in organisations. Educational Research Review, 5(2), 111–133. Dietrich, F. (2018). Konturen einer Rekonstruktiven Governanceforschung. In M. Heinrich & A. Wernet (Hrsg.), Rekonstruktive Bildungsforschung (S. 73–94). Springer. Edwards, A. (2017). Revealing Relational Work. In A. Edwards (Hrsg.), Working Relationally in and across Practices (1. Aufl., S. 1–22). Cambridge University Press. Gräsel, C., Fußangel, K., & Pröbstel, C. (2006). Lehrkräfte zur Kooperation anregen—Eine Aufgabe für Sisyphos? Zeitschrift für Pädagogik, 52(2), 205–219. Grosche, M., Fussangel, K., & Gräsel, C. (2020). Kokonstruktive Kooperation zwischen Lehrkräften: Aktualisierung und Erweiterung der Kokonstruktionstheorie sowie deren Anwendung am Beispiel schulischer Inklusion. Zeitschrift für Pädagogik, 66(4), 461–479. Hargreaves, A., & O’Connor, M. T. (2018). Collaborative Professionalism: When Teaching Together Means Learning for All. Corwin Press. Lambrecht, M. (2018). Steuerung als pädagogisches Problem. Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden. Mannheim, K. (2024). Ideologie und Utopie: Neuausgabe der Originalfassung von 1929. Herausgegeben von Klaus Lichtblau (Hrsg.). Springer. Weber, S. M. (2018). Innovationsmanagement als Gegenstand der Organisationspädagogik. In M. Göhlich, A. Schröer, & S. M. Weber (Hrsg.), Handbuch Organisationspädagogik (S. 517–527). Wirth, K. (2020). Verwaltung agiler machen! – Hype oder kalter Kaffee? Verwaltung & Management, 26(4), 161–168. Zumpe, E. (2024). School improvement at the next level of work: The struggle for collective agency in a school facing adversity. Journal of Educational Change, 25(3), 485–529.
Update Modus of this Database
The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER.
Search the ECER Programme
- Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
- Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
- Search for authors and in the respective field.
- For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
- If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.