Session Information
32 SES 07 B, Whose Knowledge Counts - Agency, Counter-Practices and Organizational Learning
Paper Session
Contribution
In light of current polycrises, the long-unquestioned notion of agency as a uniquely human capacity to intentionally shape a shared future has come under increasing scrutiny. While some contemporary sociological accounts see individual and collective agency eroding due to mounting institutional restrictions (Rosa 2026) or due to the perceived disintegration of political movements challenging the unsustainable status quo (Blühdorn 2024), recent posthuman and new materialist scholarship has raised more fundamental theoretical questions about the concept of human agency as such. As a result, planetary and political crises, together with these academic debates, have led to a degree of disorientation in educational research. This has compelled researchers and practitioners to re-evaluate whether and how education can inform meaningful action and foster individual and collective agency (e.g. Schenk 2025, Scherrer & Obex 2023).
At the same time, educational research faces growing public and political expectations to demonstrate societal impact by providing research-based knowledge and evidence intended to inform education policy and support actors’ agency in responding to contemporary crises. These demands have led, among other effects, to increased impact requirements in public funding programmes for educational research and beyond. Amplified by the growing reliance on third-party funding in academia, these institutional pressures have made the question of how educational research can foster meaningful agency increasingly salient for academics. Nevertheless, researchers continue to point to the limited impact of research on practice and a persistent research-practice gap (e.g. Penuel et al. 2020).
As a particular approach to bridging this gap between knowing and acting, research-practice-partnerships (RPPs) have proliferated in recent years. RPPs explicitely aim to narrow this divide by bringing together researchers’ and practitioners’ perspectives and ways of knowing to address complex societal problems and facilitate social change (e.g. Farley-Ripple et al. 2018; Coburn & Penuel 2016). This trend is reflected in a growing body of research that has generated empirically grounded insights into the potentials and pitfalls of RPPs (e.g. McGeown & Sjölund 2025; Coburn & Penuel 2016). Recent studies focus on knowledge and boundary work in RPPs, providing more detailed conceptually informed insights into the epistemological practices in RPPs (e.g. Farrell et al. 2019; Sjölund et al. 2022a; 2022b). However, while existing research primarily examines how knowledge work is carried out in RPPs, there has been little reflection on the substantive content of this work and the broader discourses that actors draw upon as they attempt to build collective agency to address societal problems.
Moreover, empirical research – predominantly based on case studies – rarely considers the material and discursive effects of third-party funding and project-based organization that often structure knowledge work in RPPs, treating these contexts instead as unquestioned preconditions. From a critical organizational perspective, the underlying assumption that improved outcomes – such as better access to education for disadvantaged children – can be achieved through enhanced networking and collaboration among organizations and individual actors in local educational landscapes has been described as a rationalized myth. As such, it may obscure the tensions between managerial logics and inclusive ambitions that structure these projects and downplay potential conflicts between stakeholders (Schmachtel 2022; 2016). Similar objections have been raised regarding another common premise in publicly funded research projects: that research evidence can inform local educational RPPs and thereby facilitate organisational change through a dialogic process of knowledge ‘transfer’ or ‘transformation’ (Janowitz et al. 2025).
In light of these underexplored issues, we examine factors that enable or constrain the discursive construction of collective agency in the knowledge work of the RPP analyzed in our study. Specifically, we focus on how actors negotiate the contradictory imperatives arising from political, institutional and funding contexts.
Method
To pursue these questions, this article draws on a practice- and subject-theoretical perspective that foregrounds the ideological dimension of how actors develop agency in their situated knowlegde work within RPPs, conceptualizing this as a process of relational place-making (cf. Pierce et al. 2011). We analyze data from a case study of a publicly funded German RPP that follows a transdisciplinary research agenda and aims to explore and reduce educational barriers for children of primary school age in disadvantaged urban and rural communities. The study employs an ethnographic approach to explore the collective knowledge work of ‘doing transfer’ between the researchers, practitioners from various educational institutions and local government employees participating in the RPP. We focus on one key event of the RPP that brought together academics, municipal actors, practitioners and parent representatives and that was designed to discuss research-based knowlegde in relation to practitioners’ everyday professional work. Following Pierce et al. (2011), we shed light on conflicts that arise among actors in processes of relational place-making, taking place contestation to be an integral element of these processes. In doing so, we ask which place-frames underpin the different positionalities in this RPP event and shape the power dynamics among them, as well as which ideologies become performatively effective in these interactions. To enable a more fine-grained theoretical and methodological pespective on actors’ agency in this contested process of relational place-making, we draw on Nissen's (2012; 2018) critical cultural-historical work. Following Nissen, we understand the actors’ practice as a process of building a shared common sense and collective subjectivity with regard to the event as a common space. We pay particular attention to how the RPP’s third-party funding context discursively and sociomaterially shapes the place-frames at play, and to the different, partially conflicting levels – individual, collective, political – at which agency is accomplished. Nissen’s understanding of common sense as ideology further allows for a critical perspective that provides insights into the unquestioned assumptions underlying the knowledge work in the RPP. As a theoretically grounded perspective on the discrepancies between knowing and acting, a critique of ideology offers insights into the ways these assumptions reproduce prevalent narratives around educational inequality, collective agency and the possibilites for knowledge to inform action.
Expected Outcomes
Our analysis highlights the ways in which institutional contexts introduce material and discursive frames that shape local processes of relational place-making within the RPP. We identify power imbalances, for example related to participant selection prior to the event and to interpellations in their communications. However, these frames were also contested by practitioners – and researchers themselves – in their attempts to find common ground and gain collective agency with regard to the challenges that become apparent in discussions of local educational practice. Despite this, emerging conflicts were often avoided or not pursued further, suggesting a common-sense notion of collective agency premised on the absence of conflict. Our analysis suggests that this avoidance of conflict may constrain participants’ ability to adopt a collective position – and thereby exercise collective agency – within the contested political space surrounding educational inequality and school organization. This observed pattern and the underlying common-sense notion of collective agency can, in turn, be linked to the policy-driven project objectives of enhanced networking and cooperation between local actors, mirroring rationalized myths associated with third-party-funded and project-based research. A critical reflection of the ideologies underlying the performed collective agency revealed two key aspects: (a) Not engaging with conflicts limits actors’ relational place-making to the reproduction of an established common sense, thereby directing them back to institutionalized forms of agency and (b) the RPP’s primary object of educational barriers was barely discussed, but rather taken for granted as an implicit premise of the RPP’s knowledge work. As a consequence, educational inequality was addressed from the implicit perspective of a meritocratic ideal, rather than becoming a topic for controversial discussion. Based on these two findings we reflect possible implications for achieving collective agency and the role of research in a society increasingly shaped by crises and political polarization.
References
Blühdorn, Ingolfur (2024): Unhaltbarkeit. Auf dem Weg in eine andere Moderne. Berlin: Suhrkamp. Coburn, C. E., & Penuel, W. R. (2016). Research-Practice Partnerships in Education: Outcomes, Dynamics, and Open Questions. Educational Researcher, 45(1), 48-54. Farley-Ripple, E., May, H., Karpyn, A., Tilley, K., & McDonough, K. (2018). Rethinking connections between research and practice in education: A conceptual framework. Educational Researcher, 47(4), 235-245. Farrell, C. C., Harrison C. & Coburn C.E. (2019): "“What the hell is this, and who the hell are you?” Role and identity negotiation in research-practice partnerships." AERA Open 5.2. Janowitz, M., Zeltwanger, S., Metzler, P.K., Schmachtel, S. & Steins, K.M. (2025). Dialogische Wissenstransformation und organisationaler Wandel – Reflexionen über Potenzial und Grenzen eines Konzepts. In: Schröder, C., Alt, L., Engel, N. (eds.): Organisation und (Un-)Gerechtigkeit. Organisation und Pädagogik. Wiesbaden:Springer, 239-254. McGeown, S., & Sjölund, S. (2025). practice partnerships in education: Benefits, challenges, methodological considerations and key enablers for change. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 1-13. Penuel, W. R., Allen, A. R., Coburn, C. E., & Farrell, C. (2015). Conceptualizing research–practice partnerships as joint work at boundaries. Journal of Education for Students Placed at Risk, 20(1-2), 182-197. Pierce, J., Martin, D.G. and Murphy, J.T. (2011), Relational place-making: the networked politics of place. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 36: 54-70. Rosa, Hartmut (2026): Situation und Konstellation. Vom Verschwinden des Spielraums. Berlin: Suhrkamp. Schenk, S. (2025): Die ›Zukunftsmacher‹. Gestaltungsoptionen von Zukunft zwischen Technik, Bildung und Politik». In: Jergus, Kerstin et al. (eds.): Zukunft – Jugend – Politik. Verhältnisbestimmungen und (erziehungs-)wissenschaftliche Debatten. Bielefeld:transcript, 101-121. Scherrer, M.; Obex, T. (2023): Futures Literacy und solidarische Beziehungsweisen. In: C. Sippl et al. (eds.): Futures Literacy: Zukunft Lernen und Lehren, Innsbruck, Wien: StudienVerlag, 344-354. Schmachtel, S. (2022): Zur Performativität von sozial- und bildungspolitischen Reformideen als Rationalitätsmythen und Phantasmen. Das Beispiel Bildungslandschaften. Neue Praxis 3/22. Schmachtel, S. (2016): Local partnerships as ‘rationalized myths’: a critical examination of the micro-discourse in educational partnership working. Critical Policy Studies, 10(4), 448-467. Sjölund, S., Lindvall, J., Larsson, M., & Ryve, A. (2022). Using research to inform practice through research‐practice partnerships: A systematic literature review. Review of Education, 10(1), e3337. Sjölund, S., Lindvall, J., Larsson, M., & Ryve, A. (2022). Using research to inform practice through research-practice partnerships: A systematic literature review. Review of Education, 10, e3337.
Update Modus of this Database
The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER.
Search the ECER Programme
- Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
- Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
- Search for authors and in the respective field.
- For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
- If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.