Session Information
32 SES 10 B, Change Agents in Schooling, School Development and Innovation - Organizational Education Perspectives
Paper Session
Contribution
Across German-speaking countries, schools are increasingly confronted with unprecedented challenges in responding to societal change, learner diversity, and systemic constraints. While many schools struggle with incremental adjustments, a growing number demonstrate the potential of radically innovative school development—approaches that rethink structures, cultures, and pedagogical practices in profound and sustainable ways. Drawing on the conceptual frame of the Mutmacherand Musterbrecher projects, this proposal introduces a research-based model of innovative school development that emphasizes professionalism, persistency, and strategic coherence. These innovative schools, some recognized as award-winning institutions and others less publicly visible, provide compelling real-world examples of transformative practice aligned with the principles of Next Practice, rather than mere best practice replication.
The point of departure for this inquiry lies in understanding why schools embark on developmental journeys. Consistent with the findings from the Mutmacher project, the motivations are highly diverse: threats of closure, internal crises or conflicts, dissatisfaction with learning outcomes, a lack of student autonomy, heterogeneity challenges, impulses from professional learning, and school redesign initiatives. School development is rarely linear; instead, transformation unfolds iteratively, shaped by contextual conditions and a school’s evolving identity. Across cases, a shared pattern emerges: successful innovation pivots on a clear sense of purpose, stepwise implementation, and a willingness to redesign nearly all aspects of school life. Innovation rarely begins from ideal conditions; rather, pressure and opportunity operate together as catalysts when schools interpret them through a lens of agency and purpose.
The radical approaches presented here are informed by multi-layered conceptual models seen in the uploaded materials: the BIO+S strategy (Bolster, Innovate, Optimise, and Suspend), the interconnected development of learning culture, school culture, and leadership culture, the emphasis on meaningful cooperation, and the focus on quality of education supported by structured quality management and strategic processes (e.g., vision work, evaluation loops, pilot projects). Innovative schools shift from teaching to learning: they foster self-organized learning, adopt learning coaching roles, expand learning environments, integrate collegial observation, leverage project-based learning, and use agile processes that encourage prototyping, iteration, failure tolerance, and reflection.
Across cases, recurring milestones include guided self-organized learning, redesigned learning spaces (“learning space as a third educator”), strengthened coaching and collegial observation, and professionalized project structures.
This proposal is grounded in two complementary qualitative research strands:
(1) A detailed case study of one innovative school, including ten semi-structured interviews, participatory fieldwork, and a whole-staff BIO+S survey exploring what should be preserved, innovated, optimized, or suspended.
(2) An interview study involving 12 schools in Germany, Austria, and Switzerland, representing all major school types. These interviews with school leaders examine historical development trajectories, present conditions, and the strategic approaches that drove successful innovation.
The findings can be synthesized into four interrelated domains: (1) triggers and drivers of innovation, (2) developmental pathways and milestones, (3) cultural and structural enabling conditions, and (4) strategic tools and processes that support sustained transformation.
Findings across both strands reveal that radically innovative schools share a strong commitment to cooperation, shared responsibility, purpose-driven leadership, and the courage to rethink established practices. Their developmental pathways emphasize relationship-centered education, systemic coherence, resource-orientation, and values-based decision-making. They exhibit a “forest rather than monoculture” mindset: diversity, collaboration, and mutual learning serve as engines of innovation.
Taken together, the analyses show that innovative schools create new professional cultures and future-oriented learning environments by combining strategic clarity with pragmatic iteration. Their radical approaches are not disruptive in the sense of abrupt upheaval, but transformative through persistent, thoughtful, and data-informed action. With these insights, this contribution aims to inspire other schools—“Next Schools”—by showcasing pathways for becoming resilient, student-centered, and future-ready educational organizations.
Method
This study employed a qualitative multi-method design combining in-depth case analysis with a broader cross-case comparative approach. 1. Case Study of One Innovative School The first research component involved an intensive case study of a school recognized for its pioneering transformation initiatives. Data collection included: • Ten semi-structured interviews with school leaders, teachers, internal change agents, and selected stakeholders. These interviews explored developmental motivations, structural changes, cultural shifts, and leadership strategies. • Participatory fieldwork, during which the researcher engaged in on-site activities, team meetings, informal discussions, and classroom observations. This immersive approach enabled a nuanced understanding of everyday school practices and the lived culture of innovation. • A whole-staff survey using the BIO+S Analysis (Bewahren–Innovieren–Optimieren–Sistieren), developed by Huber. Staff members assessed which elements of the school should be preserved, newly introduced, further optimized, or temporarily or permanently discontinued. This resource-oriented inventory provided quantitative and qualitative indicators of perceived strengths, challenges, and priorities. The analysis followed grounded theory principles, combining open coding with iterative comparison. The triangulation of interview data, participatory insights, and BIO+S results generated a rich account of the school’s developmental logic, cultural patterns, and strategic alignment. 2. Interview Study Across 12 Schools (Germany, Austria, Switzerland) The second research component broadened the scope to a comparative analysis involving 12 schools across different types and national contexts. Each participated in a structured interview focused on: • Historical development: How the school’s situation evolved over time. • Current status: Challenges, innovations, and structural characteristics. • School improvement approaches: Strategies, models, and processes used to achieve desired changes. The sample intentionally included schools in urban, rural, and mixed settings and spanned various school types to ensure representativeness. Interviews were analyzed thematically, identifying recurring motifs such as systemic coherence, stepwise development, cooperation structures, leadership practices, and iterative improvement cycles. 3. Cross-Case Synthesis Data from both components were synthesized through pattern analysis, identifying mechanisms that consistently contribute to successful radical school innovation. The combined approach allowed for both depth (case study) and breadth (12-school comparison), producing insights into the conditions, processes, and practices that enable sustainable school transformation.
Expected Outcomes
The study provides compelling evidence that radically innovative school development is both possible and replicable across diverse educational contexts. While each school’s trajectory is unique, successful innovation rests on several shared foundations: a strong pedagogical purpose, collaborative culture, role clarity, and persistent strategic action. Radical innovation does not emerge from disruptive gestures but through coherent, value-driven, iterative development supported by a professional learning culture. A core contribution of this research is demonstrating the utility of the BIO+S strategy as a structural and cultural compass. Schools that intentionally analyze what to preserve, innovate, optimize, or discontinue are better positioned to allocate resources meaningfully and to maintain developmental balance. At the same time, distributed, participatory leadership—rooted in trust, mutual respect, and clarity—enables the collective ownership necessary for complex organizational change. The findings highlight that innovation thrives where learning culture, school culture, and leadership culture evolve together. Tools such as collegial observation, pilot projects, agile methods, reflective collaboration formats, and shared norms enhance coherence. Schools that embrace experimentation and accept failure as part of learning develop the resilience needed to navigate complex futures. Importantly, the results suggest that innovation is not primarily a technical process but a cultural one. Sustained transformation was observed where purpose-driven cooperation, shared norms, and strong relational cultures shaped everyday practice (“education is relationship work”). In addition, the data highlight affective and motivational factors (shared commitment, perceived relevance, and joy in meaningful collaboration) which strengthened collective efficacy and professional satisfaction and supported long-term change. Ultimately, radically innovative schools demonstrate that educational transformation is not an abstract ideal but a concrete possibility. Their experiences offer inspiration and strategic guidance for schools seeking to redefine learning as a joyful, meaningful, student-centered endeavor.
References
Burow, O.-A. (2021). School development 2030: Trends and implementation steps. In J. Zylka (Ed.), Flip your school! Impulses for the development and design of hybrid, personalized teaching-learning settings (pp. 98–116). Beltz. Fratton, P. (2017). Instead of “school-ready” children: A child-appropriate school – The learning village of Wutöschingen. In J. Zylka (Ed.), School on the way to a personalized learning environment: Models of new teaching and learning (1st ed., pp. 25–33). Beltz. Fullan, M. (2016). The New Meaning of Educational Change. Teachers College Press. Göhlich, M., Weber, S.M., Schröer, A. u.a. (2014): Forschungsmemorandum Organisationspädagogik. online unter https://www.dgfe.de/sektionen-kommissionen-ag/sektion-14-organisationspaedagogik/forschungsmemorandum-organisationspaedagogik Hargreaves, A., & Shirley, D. (2012). The Global Fourth Way: The Quest for Educational Excellence. Corwin Press. Hopkins, D. (2010). Realising the potential of system Leadership. In S.G. Huber (Hrsg.), School Leadership – International Perspectives (S. 211-224). Dordrecht: Springer. Huber, S. G. (various years). BIO+S: Bewahren, Innovieren, Optimieren, Sistieren – A Resource-Oriented Approach to Strategic School Development. Research Group for Leadership, Quality Management and Innovation, Johannes Kepler University Linz. Huber, S. G., Bentele, A., Schneider, N., & Koch, F. (2025). Mutmacher – Musterbrecher: Strategisch professionell, profund und persistent handeln. Presentation at the DSLK 2025, Düsseldorf. Konrad, Klaus (2014): Lernen lernen - allein und mit anderen. Konzepte, Lösungen, Beispiele. Wiesbaden: Springer VS OECD. (2019). Future of Education and Skills 2030: OECD Learning Compass. Robinson, V. (2011). Student-Centered Leadership. Jossey-Bass. Schröer, Andreas & Freis, Tamara (2025). Sense-Making zwischen Widerstand und Implementierung–Führung als Kopplung differenter Sinnformen im Kontext der digitalen Transformation von Meta-Organisationen. Gruppe. Interaktion. Organisation. Zeitschrift für Angewandte Organisationspsychologie (GIO) 4/25, 1-9. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11612-025-00840-1 Schröer, A. (2021): Social Innovation in Education and Social Service Organizations. Challenges, Actors and Approaches to Foster Social Innovation. In: Frontiers in Education: https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2020.555624 Senge, P. (1990). The Fifth Discipline: The Art and Practice of the Learning Organization. Doubleday. Timperley, H. (2011). Realizing the Power of Professional Learning. McGraw-Hill. Weber, S.M. (2017). Strategieentwicklung als Gegenstand der Organisationspädagogik. In M Göhlich, A., Schröer & S.M. Weber (Hrsg.), Handbuch Organisationspädagogik (S. 595-606). Wiesbaden: Springer VS. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-658-07746-4_58-1 Wüthrich, H.A., Osmetz, D. & Kaduk, S. (2009). Musterbrecher – Führung neu leben. 3., überarb. u. erw. Auflage. Gabler. Zylka, J. (Ed.). (2021). Flip your school! Impulses for the development and design of hybrid, personalized teaching-learning settings. Beltz.
Update Modus of this Database
The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER.
Search the ECER Programme
- Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
- Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
- Search for authors and in the respective field.
- For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
- If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.