23 SES 07 C, Accountability
Parallel Paper Session
In a context of globalization and new forms of regulation and governance, public action in education is increasingly based on knowledge based regulation tools (Pons & Van Zanten, 2007). Particularly, accountability policies are developing around the world, based on a combination of several tools as such as testing, standards, in order to assess the results of education systems meanwhile « contracts », « report card », guidance or monitoring tools are regulating the consequences and sanctions that could follow for schools and education professionals.
The question of the real effects and impacts of accountability policies are under scrutiny in many european or north american national contexts, but so far research results are confusing. There are no real scientific consensus about the main intended or unintended effects of these policies either on the results of education systems (in terms of equity or efficacity) or on the schools and their professionals (Mons, 2009 ; Carnoy & Loebb, 2002 ; Lee, 2008, 2011 ; Mons & Dupriez, 2011 ; Harris & Herrington, 2006). A part of the various or contradictory results of the research could be related to methodological issues (Lee, 2008) ; at the same time, some authors have emphasized that there were various kind of accountabilities policies accross national contexts (ie low and high stake policies) (for ex. Mons, 2009 ; Hanushek & Raymond, 2004).
However, beyond « soft » and « hard » accountability policies, it is often supposed, that external testing are approximatly based on the same policy tools in various national context and that technical features of policy tools do not matter much. Meanwhile, this could be a reducing gaze on these policies, which is unable to thematize and think the policy tools which are put in place to implement the policy. The precise features of the knowledge based regulation tools (Pons & Van Zanten, 2007) put in place in each national context could matter for the process and the resulting outputs of these policies. Based on the sociology of public action tools (Lascoumes & Le Galès, 2004 ; Pons, 2010 ; Buisson-Fenet & Le Naour, 2008), our intention in this paper is to present an exploratory work, aiming to build a typology of accountability policy tools.
BUISSON-FENET, H. & LE NAOUR, G. (2008) (dir.).Les professionnels de l’action publique face à leurs instruments. Toulouse : Octares Edition. CARNOY, M., & LOEB, S. (2002). Does external accountability affect student outcomes? A cross-state analysis. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 24(4), 305-331. HANUSHEK, E.A., & RAYMOND, M.E. (2004). Does accountability lead to improved student performance? Journal of policy analysis and management, 24(2), 297-327. HARRIS, D.N., & HERRINGTON, C.D. (2006). Accountability, Standards, and the growing achievement gap: lessons from the past half-century, American Journal of Education, 112, 209-238. LASCOUMES, P. & LE GALES, P. (dir.) (2004). Gouverner par les instruments. Paris:Les Presses de Sciences Po. LEE, J. (2008). Is test driven external accountability effective Synthesizing the evidence from cross state Causal comparative and correlational studies, Review of Educational Research, 78(3), 608-644. LEE, J. (2011). Making Educational Accountability System Work for Equity : Learning from the U.S. Experiences and Studies. Education comparée-Nouvelle Série-, 5, 17-33. MONS, N. (2009). Les effets théoriques et réels de l‟évaluation standardisée‟ Revue française de pédagogie, 169, 99-140. MONS, N. & DUPRIEZ, V. (2011). Les politiques d'accountability.Responsabilisation et formation continue des enseignants. Recherche et formation, 65, 45-60. PONS Xavier & van ZANTEN Agnès (2007), Knowledge, Circulation, Regulation and Governance. In Delvaux B & Mangez E, Literature Review on knowledge and Policy, rapport de recherche know&pol, http://www.knowandpol.eu/index.php++cs_INTERRO++id=98, 104-37
Search the ECER Programme
- Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
- Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
- Search for authors and in the respective field.
- For planning your conference attendance you may want to use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference
- If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.