Didactics in VET - crisis, demands, concepts and open issues
Author(s):
Michael Gessler (presenting / submitting) Falk Howe (presenting)
Sönke Knutzen (presenting)

Lázaro Moreno Herrera (presenting)

Viveca Lindberg (presenting)
Conference:
ECER 2013
Format:
Round Table

Session Information

02 SES 05 B, Didactics in VET - Crisis, Demands, Concepts and Open Issues

Round Table

Time:
2013-09-11
11:00-12:30
Room:
A-103
Chair:
Michael Gessler

Contribution

In this round table four focus points (crisis, demands, concepts and open issues) will be addressed from three different national perspectives (sweden, germany and spain). Answers might be different, but challenges seems to be the same.

(1) crisis: on the one hand we acknowledge a massive withdrawal of didactic discussion in the educational research: first the constructivism taught us that nobody can be taught (a nice antagonism), later the output orientation taught us that just the output counts and within the empirical turn of the educational sciences the topic didactics seems to be lost. (Chevallard, 2006, Moreno Herrera, 2012)

(2) demands: On the other hand practitioners still expects that VET offers answers, methods and tools for their central questions: how can learners be empowered and learning be accelerated. Overall questions for the round table will therefore be: What implications have for didactics the fact that learning within this field happens in remarkably different context; namely, classroom and workshop? What is the value in developing a didactics for this specific complex learning context? Is the discourse on didactics a unique phenomenon for particular educational research traditions or is there a substance that is worth discussing? (Berglund & Lindberg, 2012; Ghaye, 2010)

(3) concepts: One concept we want exemplary focus within this short proposal information: the didactic concept "task- and process-oriented learning". One concretization of this concept for the field of electrical trade is the so called "Competence toolbox“, which has been continuously developed for more than 10 years to give answers to the following practice-oriented research questions: How can work processes of skilled workers be analyzed and described? How can the results of work process analyses be transferred into work process oriented educational measures? What are the potentials of digital media and internet to support this work process orientation? How can these potentials be converted into task-oriented learning? (Howe & Knutzen, 2012).

(4) open issues: see below "Conclusions, expected outcomes"

Method

The overall approach of the above mentioned concept (as an example) is the so called Design-Based:Research: DBR characterized the methodical approach of converting the obtained results into work process oriented learning software. The learning software and the accordant task-oriented learning were tested in all learning venues, meaning companies, training centers and vocational schools. In detail following methods were used: (1) Expert workshops: In the first step expert workshops were held. These workshops were moderated by vocational scientists. Experienced master craftsman validated a list of spheres of activities through discussion. The agreed upon list of spheres of activities portrays the researched vocation. (2) Work process analysis: Related to every sphere of activity work process analysis had to be conducted in the second step. This approach is twofold from a methodological perspective. Initially the researcher led a qualitative interview with an experienced skilled worker or craftsman. (3) Online survey: The outcome of this kind of work process oriented learning was finally evaluated by an online survey of apprentices. After accomplishing a task the learners provided feedback relating to the learning software and task -oriented learning by filling in an online questionnaire.

Expected Outcomes

Expected outcomes of the round table is to fix (4) "open issues": In our view there is a great need to continue developing the basis of a didactic that will be encompassing and dynamic enough to deal with the complex and varied situation of guidance of the learning process in the VET field. In addition to the variety of context it is equally significant to consider the complexity derived from the various interacting components of the teaching and learning process. More is to be done in creating or continuing developing a didactics that encompasses the complexities of VET considering its different levels and different settings. (Marhuenda, 2011; Selander, 2008)

References

Berglund, I.; Lindberg, V. (2012): Assessment of vocational knowing : experiences from the Swedish pilot project with Upper secondary apprenticeship 2008-2011. Nagoya Repository. Bulletin of Institute of Technology and Vocational Education. Chevallard, Y. (2006): Readjusting Didactics to a Changing Epistemology. European Educational Research Journal, 6 (2). Ghaye, T (2010): Teaching and Learning Through Reflective Practice. London: Routledge. Howe, F.; Knutzen, S. (2012): Entwickeln von Lern- und Arbeitsaufgaben. Konstanz: Christiani-Verlag. Marhuenda, F. (2011): Curricular and Organizational Coordinates Supporting School Dynamics. Revista de Educación, 356. Moreno Herrera, L. (2012): A didactic for Vocational Education and Training? – Critical exploration of the relation between general and subject didactics. Cadiz: ECER-VETNET. Selander, S. (2008): Designs of Learning and the Formation and Transformation of Knowledge in an Era of Globalization. Studies in Philosophy and Education, 27 (4).

Author Information

Michael Gessler (presenting / submitting)
Universität Bremen
Institut Technik und Bildung
Bremen
Falk Howe (presenting)
University of Bremen
Institute Technology and Education
Bremen
Sönke Knutzen (presenting)
Technical University Hamburg-Harburg, Germany
Stockholm University
Department of Education
Stockholm
Viveca Lindberg (presenting)
Stockholm University
dept of education
Stockholm

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.