Baseline Survey on the Role of School Leader in supporting Middle Leaders in Schools
Author(s):
Wakio Oyanagi (presenting / submitting)
Conference:
ECER 2014
Format:
Paper

Session Information

01 SES 06 B, Leadership for learning

Paper Session

Time:
2014-09-03
15:30-17:00
Room:
B033 Anfiteatro
Chair:
Wakio Oyanagi

Contribution

This study is one of a series of studies on the design, development and practical evaluation of a set of tools for use in teacher training in schools, local authorities and graduate teacher training programs etc. The aim in using such tools is to improve schools' educational performance by developing and supporting professional capital (Hargreaves & Fullan 2012). 

Some related research has already been conducted. This includes “Improving schools' educational performance”, “Ways of mentoring new and young teachers” and “Developing and supporting PLCs in schools” (Darling-Hammond.and Lieberman 2012, Harris 2014). It is however evident, from an examination of real practices in schools and local authorities (as reflected in planned in-school training programs, contents of current in-school training and the results of middle leader interviews), that three issues described below need to be resolved (Moir, Barlin, Gless, and Miles 2009). 

The first of these issues is as follows. Previous research shed light on the role of teaching staff responsible as middle leaders for in-school training and research and proposed, for example, effective ways of supporting beginning teachers. However, schools' support systems for these middle leaders themselves are inadequate. Teaching staff who are acting as mentors for beginning teachers and conducting in-school research frequently report that they know what is expected of them and how to do it, but they themselves would like support too. This implies that middle leaders wish for support from school leader, and that they would like to see the development of tools that school leader could use to support them. 

The second of these issues is that, as is now clearly apparent, middle leaders desire more skills and knowledge of methodology so that they can feel confident about their professional abilities when leading research projects with the aim of raising their school's educational performance, defining priorities, deciding the specific order of steps to take in implementing an initiative, pursuing evidence-driven reforms or effecting systemic change and so on. The reason for middle leaders' lack of confidence in their professional ability is that in-school research projects are often conducted from the outset with third parties as training instructors or advisors. However, middle leaders are not always able to take ownership of these projects. Comments from middle leaders such as "In fact I understood the workshop method, but when it came to analyzing results from it or creating models, then I wondered what the right words to use were or how to fit the results that we obtained together by this method into a single whole" and "We were able to have discussions during the in-school training, but I feel that we always talked about the same thing" reveal that it is difficult for middle leaders to feel confident about their professional abilities or put their skills and knowledge of methodology into words for the sake of transmitting these to others. Although they have been shown how to do in-school research, the training provided has not improved middle leaders' professional knowledge, so, clearly, there is no definite proof that this training is pedagogically effective. 

The third and last of these issues is as follows. Teaching staff who are responsible for in-school training and research expressed a desire for tools that would allow them easily and at any time to assess to what extent they possessed the skills and knowledge expected of them in this role at the outset, how far they improved their competences while performing their duties, what other competences were required of them and so on.

This study focus on the first of the above issues, the role of school leader in supporting middle leaders.

 

Method

This study, as the first in a series, will deal with the first issue mentioned in the above “Proposal Information”, looking at the effects on schools' educational performance achieved in a three-year period through the introduction of mentoring and other forms of support for beginning teachers. With the assistance of the principals of the three junior high schools involved, this study aims to describe the thinking behind this initiative, how it was conducted and what tools it employed. The method used for this study was first to attend in-school training during the three years of the initiative and then to analyze recordings of interviews with the three principals to find common points and differences between them. Next, after identifying the matters on which these school managers agreed, I looked at what they thought to be the important considerations when providing support to middle leaders acting as mentors or when pursuing systemic reforms in schools. In the final section, I shall discuss the relationship between current discourse about the role of school managers (standards for their profession) and the issues examined in this study, and offer some recommendations for the future. The Interview design and profiles of the participating 3 school principals are as follows. Principal A is woman. She has been working as a principal for seven years in an urban junior high school. Principal B is man. He has been working as a principal for three years in an urban junior high school. Principal C is man. He has been working as a principal for four years in an urban junior high school. The interviewing technique used was to work with the five questionnaire items below in a 60-minute semi-structured interview. 1) Can you tell me what outcome the mentoring and other forms of support for beginning teachers introduced in your school have had over the past few years? 2) In the process leading to this outcome, what steps were taken initially? What was done next? 3) What were the considerations when supporting beginning teachers? 4) What support is there for middle leaders (teaching staff who are mentoring)? 5) What message would you give to schools introducing this kind of initiative in the future? Recordings of the interviews were transcribed, and the interview transcripts were edited with the assistance of the school managers. The records of the interviews provided the data to be analyzed through frame of Professional Capital.

Expected Outcomes

The following two common points were identified: 1) discussing with teachers the changes occurring in students and 2) convincing staff that the outcome of initiatives depends on teamwork and their own decisions. In addition, all three principals clearly agreed that, to develop and support professional capital in the school, commitment to middle leaders and creating a culture in which teachers collaborate to improve their professionalism were important. How should school principals interpret the above results? What should be their common understanding of their role in supporting middle leaders? Hargreaves (1998) drew attention to the fact that best practice in education was associated with teachers' positive feelings. He also emphasized that even research into areas such as teachers with a high capacity to empathize with students, "insight" in teachers and their individual and practical knowledge would benefit from paying attention to teachers' emotions. In line with this development, from the late 1990s onward, researchers examined education reform and teachers' emotions (Cochran-Smith and Fries 2005). Teachers spoke of being emotionally hurt by the explanations that their schools had to give. However, emotional responses to education reform and its effect on professional self-understanding in specific settings have not been fully examined. Of course, if teachers do not carry out their role in the classroom, then it will not be possible to improve lessons or change learning outcomes (Day & Chi-Kin Lee 2011). The need for research into the relationship between teachers' professional self-understanding and their emotions while education reform is being pursued has been highlighted (Darby, A. 2008). Then, we focus on the role of school leader in supporting middle leaders regarding to emotion through frame of professional capital.

References

(1) Cochran-Smith,M. and Fries,M.(2005). Researching teacher education in changing times: politics and paradims. In M. Cochran-Smith, and K.Zeichner (Eds.), Studying teacher education: The report of the AERA panel on research and teacher education. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Publishers. (2) Darby,A.(2008).Teacher’s emotions in the reconstruction of professional self-understanding. Teaching and Teacher Education 24, pp.1160-1172. (3) Darling-Hammond,L.and Lieberman,A. (ed.)(2012). Teacher Education around the World. Changing Policies and Practices. NY: Routledge. (4) Day,C. & Chi-Kin Lee,J. (ed.) (2011). New Understandings of Teacher’s Work. Emotions and Educational Change. NY: Springer. (5) Day,C. & Gu, Q.(2014). Resilient Teachers, Resilient Schools. Building and sustaining quality in testing times. NY: Routledge. (6) Hargreaves, A.,(1998). The Emotional Practice of Teaching. Teaching and Teacher Education, Vol. 14, No. 8, pp. 835-854. (7) Hargreaves & Fullan(2012). Professional Capital : Transformng Teaching in Every School. NY:Routledge. (8) Harris, A. (2014). Distributed Leadership Matters. Perspectives, Practicalities, and Potential.CA:Corwin Publishing (9) Moir,E., Barlin,D., Gless,J. and Miles,J. New Teacher Mentoring. Hopes and Premise For Improving Teacher Effectiveness.MA: Harvard Education Press.

Author Information

Wakio Oyanagi (presenting / submitting)
Nara University of Education, Japan

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.