Analysis of Schooling and Institutional Support in the Transition From Lower Secondary Education to Post-Compulsory Level in Southern Switzerland

Session Information

14 SES 01 B, School-Related Transitions Within a Life Course Perspective (Part 1)

Paper Session: to be continued in 14 SES 02 B, 14 SES 08 B, 14 SES 09 B

Time:
2014-09-02
13:15-14:45
Room:
B326 Sala de Aulas
Chair:
Ewelina Rydzewska

Contribution

Based on the results of a longitudinal study that has involved a cohort of over 3,000 students in the Swiss Canton of Ticino, this paper aims primarily to describe the transition from compulsory to post-compulsory school or vocational tracks, highlighting its typical features, delays and reorientation.

The transition from one stage to another can in fact be linear or present elements of discontinuity. The latter may occur at the time of entry into a particular formation, in subsequent years, or result in the abandonment of a formation before its conclusion (Keller, Hupka Brunner & Meyer, 2010). If a  successful transition usually corresponds to the direct transition from the lower secondary to the upper secondary educational or vocational level, a missed or difficult transition distinguishes itself for a more dilated time and for several subsequent changes which, in the worst case, lead to early school leaving (Pagnossin & Armi 2011) and to permanent problems in entering the labour market or having a long-lasting job.  A risk often connected with a missed transition is also ending up being trapped in “rescue solutions” such as the social assistance that can cause chronic dependency from public or private aid. According to the Eurostat data of 2012, the Swiss Canton of Ticino is one of the Swiss regions with the lowest percentage of early school leavers (according to Eurostat definition these are persons aged between 18 and 24 years with at most lower secondary education and are not involved in further education or training). This percentage, which amounts to 4.7% against a Swiss average of 5.5%, has decreased by half over the past 5 years and is significantly lower than in other European countries.

The second goal of this paper ,is to get a better comprehension of the transition and of the role played by individual and systemic factors in this particular moment. Moreover, a description of the measures and initiatives provided at an institutional level by the Canton and aimed at supporting young people during the above mentioned school transition and an analysis of the ties among them will be furnished. One particular category of these measures is represented by transitional solutions. According to Meyer (2003) they began to be widespread in Switzerland in the 1990s (Egger Dreher e Partner AG, 2007). They perform three main functions: 1) a compensatory function: educational, linguistic or other difficulties are addressed; 2) an orientative function: provision of support and assistance with choosing a post-compulsory education track; 3) a systemic cushioning function which, for example, can tackle the imbalance between supply and demand regarding apprenticeships - often an obstacle to young people entering their preferred profession. This type of solution can also be used by young people who wish to take up training for which they cannot enrol immediately after compulsory education (training which requires a minimum age for entry). One of the most frequently used transitional solution in Ticino is the so-called Pretirocinio di orientamento (PTO), namely a pre-apprenticeship orientation programme offered to students to help them choose a career. The programme lasts a school year and no certificate is issued at the end of it. Although it helps many young people to find a place in the training system, it is not suitable for some of them and other provisions are necessary (Marcionetti, Donati & Casabianca Schlichting, 2010).

Method

The transition from compulsory to the post-compulsory school or vocational tracks and the system supporting school transition in Ticino have been investigated by different points of view. Firstly Ticino’s Department of Education, Culture and Sport has developed an application that makes available - in the form of database - student-specific informations, including some social and biographical details, data on the student’s past and current training, subjects studied, marks, days of absence from school and end of the year results. The database (called 'GAGI' - literally meaning: Management of Students and Institutes) has allowed us to analyse the transitions of a cohort of 3023 students attending the third year at any of Ticino’s public middle schools during the school year 2008-2009 and the following five years. In parallel with the description of students’ flows, which provides us a macro-perspective of post-compulsory educational or vocational pathways, other types of analysis were conducted in order to study the impact of individual, family and educational factors on the students’ choices. The third perspective consists in the analysis of the institutional support (initiatives, measures and projects) provided to youth during the post-compulsory school transition. Key players involved in these initiatives were interviewed with the aim of getting a more detailed picture of the set of the several support measures existing in Ticino, having a deeper idea of the role played by individual and systemic factors on post-compulsory school transition and collecting information about the intensity and frequency of formal and informal ties among the actors active in the several initiatives and measures. Regarding this last point Social Network Analysis techniques were used in order to determine how cohesive is the post-compulsory school support network and to identify eventual dysfunctional elements.

Expected Outcomes

In Ticino, three years after completing lower secondary education, more than 85% of youngsters are still present in one of the post-compulsory educational tracks. More precisely, over 60% of students who begun an upper secondary school in 2010, three years later were found to be attending, without any previous failure or change, the last year at the same school. The interviews allowed us to identify multiple factors that have an impact on transition. Concerning social components, cultural elements have been identified among others. In Ticino, a quite stereotyped perception on vocational education is detectable, and this has an influence on the transition. Vocational paths, if compared to academic, are often perceived at a lower level and only suitable for those who don’t have good scholastic results. One of the individual factors involved in transition, is students’ lack of information about the different opportunities after compulsory school: students make their choices on the basis of scholastic results and in a condition of limited information. As a consequence, those with good results, tend to choose the academic education in high school, which is a rather “easy” choice. Those with poorer scholastic results are automatically driven toward vocational education and choose among the limited number of professional options they are aware of. For what regards the institutional support, in Ticino there are numerous initiatives, especially for the most vulnerable people. The almost 30 measures that have been identified can be classified into five categories by the purpose they follow. The presence of so many measures if on one hand is an indicator of the considerable efforts spent or youngsters, on the other hand can cause duplications, and disorientation among them: a hard work of coordination is required in order not to undermine the efficacy of these measures.

References

Egger Dreher e Partner AG. (2007). Étude approfondie sur les offres de formation transitoire entre scolarité obligatoire et formation professionnelle. Bern, Egger, Dreher & Partner AG. Keller A., Hupka-Brunner, S., & Meyer, T. (2010). Post compulsory education pathways in Switzerland: the first seven years. Results of the Swiss youth panel survey TREE. Online: http://tree.unibas.ch/index.php?eID=tx_nawsecuredl&u=0&file=fileadmin/tree/redaktion/docs/Keller_Hupka_Meyer_2010_Results_Update_engl.pdf&t=1358943843&hash=f8ef2ddba6982dcb4e3494c528c0577d Marcionetti, J. , Donati, M. & Casabianca Schlichting, E. (2010). Alla ricerca del mio futuro: sguardo sulle scelte e i percorsi degli allievi del pretirocinio d’orientamento. Dati statistiche e società, 2010, X, pp.50-57. Meyer, T. (2003). Les solutions transitoires – un pis-aller?, in : TREE (Eds.), Parcours vers les formations postobligatoires. Les deux premières années après l’école obligatoire. Résultats intermédiaires de l’étude longitudinale TREE. Neuchâtel, Office fédéral de statistique, pp. 101-109. Pagnossin, E., & Armi, F. (2011). Transition entre la formation et le monde du travail. État de la recherche en Suisse. Papers : revista de sociologia, 96(4), 1163-1179.

Author Information

Serena Ragazzi (presenting / submitting)
SUPSI, Switzerland
SUPSI, Switzerland
SUPSI, Switzerland
SUPSI, Switzerland

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.