Principals’ Leadership and Teachers’ Professional Development: Motivation as Critical Factor in Schools in Challenging Areas in Poland and South Africa
Author(s):
Joanna Madalinska-Michalak (presenting / submitting) Jan Heystek (presenting)
Conference:
ECER 2015
Format:
Paper

Session Information

01 SES 06 B, Teacher development and motivation

Paper Session

Time:
2015-09-09
15:30-17:00
Room:
204.Oktatóterem [C]
Chair:
Jan Heystek

Contribution

There is considerable interest in teacher development at present because there are global as well as national transitions for example migration, demands to improve performances in international assessment exercises , e.g. TIMMS, PIRLS and PISA which leads to curriculum as we well methodological approaches for schools. Teacher development is seen as an essential ingredient in transforming these schools and creating quality education for every child. Many teachers may be reluctant or even resist the change and therefore to participate in development activities. Principals have an important role in this context in motivating teacher’s professional development. 

The rationale for this research is that motivated people may perform better over a longer period of their career rather than people who are controlled with an agreement which is potentially a threatening document (Owens and Valesky 2011; Latham 2007). Motivation, leadership and development is contextual, hence not only the local context per school but also the local education environment and the whole system of education play an important role in this area. 

Poland and South Africa, countries that undergone transition of economic, social, educational systems, are coming from a historical context with limited equal democratic and economical opportunities for all citizens. This major change to an all-inclusive democracy and equal opportunity rippled down to schools which demand good contextual leadership. South Africa is after 20 years still in a transition stage from a separation system between race groups to an all-inclusive democratic system. Racial economical and societal factors are still expressive which influence the change and demand for development. Principals work in significantly diverse context with most schools in low socio economic environments and poor academic performance. The Polish community as well as other former socialistic states, which broke with the old regime and followed the path of democratization and decommunisation, has witnessed massive social, economic, and political changes.

In both countries these dramatic changes at the end of 20th century have stimulated policymakers and citizens to examine the goals and purposes of the educational system more deeply. Poland and South Africa have led to establishment of a new law for their educational systems and introduction of a far-reaching reform programmes of theirs educational systems.

Emerging new demands have led to analyses of governance of schools, principal roles and, responsibilities, relations in schools and beyond them, work of school principals and teachers related to the quality of education provided in their schools.

This context provides significant challenges for principal’s self-motivation and development which may have an influence on the motivation and development of teachers which influence academic performance in schools. Inherently ingrained in leadership as position and role it is expected that leaders (principals) must motivate and communicate teachers, have good relationships with teachers which includes trust, and create the best environment and climate for the best performance for teachers and learners. These leadership activities or lack of action in the local context will be discussed against the motivational theories. A special attention will be paid to the importance of trust as a motivational factor (Tschannen-Moran, 2009).

The research question for the studies that were conducted by both Authors in their countries was concentrated on the key aspects of successful leadership practices used by headteachers in schools in a challenging urban and rural context. The research question for this paper is: “What is the role of principals in motivating teachers to participate in development activities?” The aim of the presented paper is to deepen the knowledge on the complexities of principal’s role in creating the high quality education for every child.

Method

The paper reports on qualitative studies that were used to explore the role of the principals in motivating teachers to participate in development activities. The research projects were conducted by Heystek (2014), Heystek and Terhoven (2014), Heystek and Van Louw (2012) and Madalinska-Michalak (2014, 2012). All the studies used qualitative methods with an interpretivist approach. Terhoven used a case study of two schools and interviewed seven teachers. Heystek (2014) conducted five focus group interviews with approximately 40 principals, and school management team members. Heystek and Louw (2012) conducted interviews with three focus groups including 15 principals and school management team member. Madalinska-Michalak conducted a case study of eight schools in Poland and interviewed 8 principals and 40 teachers. The conducted studies helped us to identify and examine the characteristics and strategies of successful leadership and management in the researched schools in both countries: Poland and South Africa. We compared and contrasted the findings: components and strategies of successful leadership with a special focus on the role of the principals in motivating teachers to participate in development activities. Comparative perspective in this study allowed to have a better understanding of the successful key leadership practices in the researched schools in different countries in reference to the socio-cultural, economic and political circumstances of these countries. It was assumed that analysis of the impact of these circumstances on key leadership practices can contribute to the development of knowledge on successful leadership practices in schools in challenging contexts. An interpretivist approach to data analysis established primary patterns in the data and identified meaningful and significant issues (Dey, 1993; Patton, 1990). All interviews were recorded and later transcribed. Transcripts were returned to the interviewees for correction and validation purposes. Interview data enabled in-depth, cross-case comparisons to be undertaken. This analysis led to the emergence of a number of common themes and key findings.

Expected Outcomes

The study showed that motivation can be perceived as a one of the critical factor for teacher development in schools in challenging areas in Poland and South Africa. Principal’s understanding of the factors of motivating teachers towards specifically development and improved performances is challenging but it is achievable. A lack of trust and control over their personal and school context are some of the most important challenges to transform the schools from underperforming to sustainable performing schools (Heysteck 2014; Madalinska-Michalak, 2012, 2014). Principals are one of the most important factors which can motivate teachers to change their attitudes to become more motivated for their development (Heystek and Terhoven, 2014). Principals in both countries concentrated on cooperation reinforced by mutual trust not only at school, but also outside of it. In the same way they provided foundations for creation of practitioner communities acting within different learning networks. Contextual factors for example the influence of the teacher union in South Africa as well as collaboration with department official at the governance level just above the school created problems for schools. This has a potential demotivational influence on principals as well as teachers with a lack of commitment to professional development by teachers (Heystek and Van Louw, 2012). In Poland key aspects of successful leadership in motivating teachers were visible in activities connected to favoring the teachers' leadership. They were also related to building a relationship with the local community in order to create a cooperative network and to promote collaboration between the schools and institutions or organizations outside school (Madalinska-Michalak, 2012, 2014). The study directs our attention to the importance of building collegial relationships at school that are based on trust and mutual understandings in motivating teachers for their professional learning and development, also in development of their role of school leaders.

References

Bassey M. (1999). Case study research in educational settings. Buckingham: Open University Press. Dey I. (1993). Qualtative data analysis: A user-friendly guide for social scientists. London: Routledge. Heystek J. (2014). Principals’ Perceptions about Performance Agreements as Motivational Action. “Educational Management Administration & Leadership”, 42(6) 889–902. Heystek J. and Terhoven R. (2014). Motivation as critical factor for teacher development in contextually challenging underperforming schools in South Africa. Professional Development in Education, http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/19415257.2014.940628 Heystek J. and Van Louw (2012). Leading Towards Quality Education For All: School Leader’s Perceptions About Their Challenging Context In South African Schools. Paper presented at ECER 2012, September, Cadiz, Spain. Latham G. P. (2007). Work and Motivation: History, Theory and Practice. Thousand Oaks, CA.: Sage. Madalinska-Michalak J. (2014). Successful Leadership Practices for Schools in Challenging Urban Contexts: Case Studies, “Revista Internacional de Educación para la Justicia Social” (RIEJS), 3(2), 181-197 Madalinska-Michalak J. (2012). Skuteczne przywództwo w szkołach na obszarach zaniedbanych społecznie. Studium porównawcze [Successful leadership at schools in socially disadvantaged areas. Comparative study], Lodz: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Lodzkiego. Madalińska-Michalak J. (2014). Pedagogical supervision and superintendents in Poland: On the way to the quality of education. In A. Nir (Ed.), The Educational superintendent: Between trust and regulation. An international perspective (pp. 55−74). Hauppauge, NY: Nova Science Publishers, Inc. Michalak J.M. (2009). Making a difference in challenging urban schools: Successful principals. “European Educational Research Journal”, 3(8), 387–396. Michalak J.M. and Jones S. (2010). Towards “inclusive school leadership” in highly disadvantaged urban contexts. “Edukacja”, 2(110), 5−16. Owens R.G. & Valseky T.C. (2011). Organizational Behaviour in Education. Leadership and School Reform. Boston: Pearson Patton M. (1990). Qualitative evaluation and research methods. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications. Tschannen-Moran M. (2009). Fostering Teacher Professionalism in Schools. The Role of Leadership Orientation and Trust. “Educational Administration Quarterly”, 45(2), 217-247.

Author Information

Joanna Madalinska-Michalak (presenting / submitting)
University of Warsaw
Faculty of Education
Warsaw
Jan Heystek (presenting)
Northwest University

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.