Uncovering the Unvoiced? A Study on Taboos in Initial Teacher Education
Author(s):
Nadja Köffler (presenting / submitting) Evi Agostini (presenting)
Conference:
ECER 2016
Format:
Paper

Session Information

10 SES 10 C, Giving Voice to Teacher Educators

Paper Session

Time:
2016-08-25
15:30-17:00
Room:
NM-C214
Chair:
ML White

Contribution

Nothing is more powerful and effective than unspoken agreements and implicit rules. They maximize the efficacy of institutions due to their subtle and unseen forces (cf. Bentham 1995) and stabilize institutional processes. Taboos represent such influential phenomena. From a sociological, anthropological and religious point of view, taboos are resistant to change and regulate behaviour in social communities. Correspondingly, taboos build identity and aim at various forms of inclusion and exclusion. Some areas of society are replete with taboos; we presume that Education is one such area. Especially in the context of formal education, taboos as well as their related implicit (cultural) norms play a significant role in shaping educational processes and promote the preservation and reorganization of academic systems. Particularly in teacher education, the confrontation with educational taboos is advisable as teachers are key figures in passing on cultural, ethic and educational values in schools.

Consequently, there is an urgent need for a professional and research-based discussion on tough topics that are not addressed in education, so called taboos. But what does the word taboo mean? Does its vagueness and conceptual multiplicity offer the potential to interpret the word anew, for example, in the context of initial teacher education?

The term “taboo” (or Hawaiian Tapu) is of Polynesian origin and has not been translated but only adopted to European languages. Its untranslatability is one of its fundamental features and was crucial for its further use. First recorded in Captain James Cook's travel reports, the term “taboo” was initially exclusively used for religious phenomena which were considered sacred, untouchable, forbidden and powerful (cf. Cook 1967, p. 947). A few years later, Freud (1989, 1979) recognized the importance of the transcultural dimension, the ambivalent meaning as well as the creative, culture-constituting power of taboos. According to him, the beginning of culture is marked by the breach of a fundamental taboo: Adam and Eve ate from the tree of knowledge and thereby caused their own expulsion from paradise (cf. Freud 1979, p. 61). This enforcement of taboos is unthinkable without conscience as an inner censoring mechanism. Thus, the internalization and incorporation of unknown regulations leads to the prevention of certain human actions. In contrast to explicit religious or legal prohibitions, taboos are of an implicit character. Furthermore, in the sense of Kant’s ethical categorical imperative, taboos function prohibitively and, therefore, protect a wide range of personal, ideological, symbolic and material values (cf. Freud 1989, p. 30). Hence, taboos are ethically, morally and emotionally coded. Besides, recent studies on taboos emphasize that they are shaped in a situational, group-specific and context-specific manner (cf. Benthien & Gutjahr 2008).

As little research has been carried out on taboos in educational contexts so far (except Adorno 1965), there is an urgent need for further analysis. Therefore, the main intention of the presented research project is to shed light on unspoken and discreet topics in the area of initial teacher education. It will therefore be asked

  • what kind of taboos can be found in the context of initial teacher education?
  • can any cultural differences be identified in a European context (Austria vs. Italy vs. Germany)?
  • what role do they play?
  • which taboos are conducive to the university context and
  • how do they defy attempts to rationalization?

The study will also investigate the nature of educational taboos as well as mechanisms on how they are preserved or overridden in formal educational contexts.

Method

Taboos persist due the fact that they remain unspoken and undiscussed. They elude from verbal reference, which leads to the conviction that language and therefore the use of verbal methods might complicate or even impede their elicitation in a first approximation. According to Bourdieu (cf. 1997, p.792), images facilitate access to topics people are reluctant to talk about. They support the bypassing of discursive rationalisation and cognitive obstacles (cf. Bremer & Teiwes-Kügler 2007, p.85) like the decision whether to talk about taboos or not. Taboos are also emotionally coded, as people for example feel ashamed when breaking a taboo. Therefore, methods need to be applied that accomplish a solid connection to emotional feelings. Bremer and Teiwes Kügler’s studies on the use of collages to analyse the habitus of various educational groups (e.g. students, adult educators) showed that images facilitate the expression of sensual, erotic and emotional feelings and thoughts (Bremer-Teiwes Krüger 2007, p.99). Images can therefore be seen as an associative and expressive manner to convey controversial topics (cf. Kepper 1996). Taboos also seem to function on a latent level. Bremer & Teiwes-Krüger (2007) are of the opinion that especially visual representations have the capacity to support the advancement to deeper layers of latent and less-reflected issues. Consequently, images enable the uncovering of taboos people are possibly unaware of. Another reason to use images for revealing taboos is based on their polysemic nature. There are various ways to interpret and understand images. This phenomenon might reduce fear of emotional punishment as it can never be fully understood and fixed what the painter wanted to express with his/her image, besides he/she verbalizes his/her intentions. So people might hopefully lose fear of uncovering topics that for several reasons should remain unspoken. In a nutshell, images are a useful tool to address taboos in a first approach but need to be complemented by other methods. This study will take both teacher students and teacher educators’ views and feelings on educational taboos into consideration. Teacher students (N=100) and teacher educators (N=30) at three different European Universities (Leopold-Franzens-University Innsbruck/Austria, Free University of Bolzano/Italy and Philipps-University Marburg/Germany) will be invited to draw, photograph and also film situations in which educational taboos seem to appear. The visual material will then be analysed (multidimensional approach; Niesyto 2006) and in a final step applied to stimulate a discussion on taboos in teacher education.

Expected Outcomes

As this project is at the very beginning, no detailed information can be given on the findings at that time. We hope that this project will support the spotting of so far hidden and unknown taboos in initial teacher education. After having identified a variety of discreet educational topics (phase 1), we intend to investigate the impact of and current dealing with several taboos in formal education in detail (phase 2). This might help to understand both the mechanisms and functions of educational taboos and will hopefully also contribute to the understanding and dealing of current social and political developments and challenges (refugee crises) in Europe. The expected results will be relevant for all European educational systems and can be used for teachers’ professional development and the improvement of school programmes.

References

Adorno, T. W. (1965). Tabus über dem Lehrberuf. In Adorno, T. W. & Kadelbach, G. (Eds.) (1971), Erziehung zur Mündigkeit. Vorträge und Gespräche mit Hellmut Becker 1959-1969 (pp. 70-87). Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp. Bentham, J. (1995). The Panopticon writings. Ed. and intro. M. Bozovic. London: Verso. Benthien, C. & Gutjahr, O. (Eds.) (2008). Tabu. Interkulturalität und Gender. München: Fink. Bourdieu, P. (1970). Zur Soziologie der symbolischen Form. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp. Bourdieu, P. (1997). Verstehen. In Bourdieu, P. & Schultheis, F. (Eds.), Das Elend der Welt. Zeugnisse und Diagnosen alltäglichen Leidens an der Gesellschaft (pp. 779-822). Konstanz: UVK-Verlagsgesellschaft. Bremer, H. & Teiwes-Kügler, Ch. (2007). Die Muster des Habitus und ihre Entschlüsselung. Mit Transkripten und Collagen zur vertiefenden Analyse von Habitus und sozialen Milieus. In Friebertshäuser, B., von Felden, H. & Schäffer, B. (Eds.), Bild und Text. Methoden und Methodologien visueller Sozialforschung in der Erziehungswissenschaft. Opladen: Barbara Budrich. Cook, J. (1967). The Journals of Captain James Cook on His Voyages of Discovery. In Beaglehole, J. C., Volume 3 (Ed.), The Voyage of the Resolution and Discovery 1776-1780. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Flenders, T. (1911). Speakers Give Sound Advice. Syracuse Post Standard, March 28, p. 18. Freud, S. (1974). Massenpsychologie und Ich-Analyse. In Mitscherlich, A., Richards, A. & Strachey, J. (Eds.), Studienausgabe, Band IV: Fragen der Gesellschaft. Ursprünge der Religion (pp. 61-134). Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp. Freud, S. (1989). Das Tabu und die Ambivalenz der Gefühlsregungen. In Freud, F. (Ed.), Totem und Tabu. Einige Übereinstimmungen im Seelenleben der Wilden und der Neurotiker (pp. 26-80). Frankfurt am Main: Fischer. Kepper, G. (1996). Qualitative Marktforschung. Methoden, Einsatzmöglichkeiten und Beurteilungskritieren. Wiesbaden: Deutscher Universitäts-Verlag. Nieysto, H. (2006). Bildverstehen als mehrdimensionaler Prozess. Vergleichende Auswertung von Bildinterpretationen und methodische Reflexion. In Marotzki, W. & Niesyto, H. (Eds.) Bildinterpretation und Bildverstehen. Methodische Ansätze aus sozialwissenschaftlicher, kunst- und medienpädagogischer Perspektive. Wiesbaden. VS Verlag.

Author Information

Nadja Köffler (presenting / submitting)
University of Innsbruck
Department of School Research and Teacher Education
Innsbruck
Evi Agostini (presenting)
University of Innsbruck, Austria

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.