Does Leadership Matter in Adverse Circumstances? Conditions for Teacher Professional Development

Session Information

01 SES 01 A, Teacher Leadership as Professional Agency

Paper Session

Time:
2017-08-22
13:15-14:45
Room:
K3.17
Chair:
Maria Assunção Flores

Contribution

This paper reports on findings from funded research carried out over a three-year period aimed at examining conditions for teacher leadership in challenging circumstances. It also discusses the implications of the findings for understanding changes in teachers’ work and the role of schools in the continuing professional development of teachers.

Teacher leadership has gained increasing attention from researchers in recent years, especially internationally. This notion has been developed in the USA (Little, 1988; Lieberman, 1992; Lieberman & Miller, 2004; Lieberman & Friedrich, 2008), UK (Frost & Durrant, 2002, 2003; MacBeath et al 2006; Frost, 2004; Durrant, 2004), and Australia (Crowther, 1999), amongst others. All this work has drawn attention to the need for a vision of teacher leadership as a key element in improvement efforts in Education. Existing literature points to a number of principles that might inform the development of teacher leadership initiatives in schools: teachers are key elements in the change process; schools are learning communities in which (distributed) leadership may be enhanced; schools as learning communities are most likely to enable children to become educated, capable and active citizens; the reform of education systems is most likely to be successful when teachers’ professionalism includes the leadership of processes of innovation and improvement in practice; teachers’ exercise of leadership will become an integral part of the organization of schools; teachers interact with each other and share their knowledge (Little, 1988; Lieberman & Miller, 2004; Frost & Durrant, 2003; Durrant, 2004; Katzenmeyer, & Moller, 2001).

Within the view of schools as learning communities, members are encouraged to exercise leadership and to engage themselves in improvement and change in the settings in which they work. There is scope for further developments in this area by promoting strategies to enable teachers to develop further their capacity for leadership in their schools and across schools. However, this is dependent upon the ways in which teaching and being a teacher are understood, in other words, teacher professionalism and professional development.

Clearly the extent to which teachers are able to engage in strategic action for change depends on the way their professionalism is perceived by themselves and their colleagues and on the conditions for them to exercise leadership, to lead innovations in schools and to transform their educational practice (Frost, 2007).Research on teacher leadership would need therefore to account for the way professionalism is constructed within policy and institutional settings, and in particular in the Portuguese context which has been critical for the teaching profession over the last few years due to the economic, financial and social crisis.

The goals of the project are: i) to understand the wider social, cultural and political setting and the policy environment in which teachers’ work is framed, especially in terms of challenges and opportunities; ii) to analyze the professional and organizational culture and structures of the schools in which teachers work; iii) to understand the ways in which teachers construct their professionalism; iv) to develop strategies in order to enhance teacher leadership in schools.

Method

A mixed-method research design was devised. The project includes literature review, a survey on teacher professionalism and wider policy context of teaching in a sample of schools nationwide; interviews to key informants about professional culture and organizational features of the schools (e.g. headteachers, leadership team; heads of departments), and portraiture to examine school culture (with teachers and students); focus group with teachers; development and evaluation of strategies to involve teachers exercising leadership in their schools; evaluation of the impact of leadership initiatives in the participating schools. In order to achieve these, a mixed-method research design was devised. The project includes; i) the phase one of data collection - a survey on teacher professionalism and wider policy context of teaching in a sample of schools nationwide (n=2702 teachers); the pahse two - interviews to principals in 11 schools nationwide (n=11), and 45 focus group (n=99 teachers and n= students), and phase three – the development and evaluation of strategies to involve teachers exercising leadership in their schools (n=66 teachers). In the process of analysis, an inductive approach was used, and substantive themes were defined as they emerged from the data, according to the overall principles of ‘grounded theory’, as suggested by Glaser and Strauss (1967) and Strauss and Corbin (1990). The process of data analysis was undertaken according to two phases: a vertical analysis (Miles and Huberman, 1994) according to which each of the respondents’ interviews was analyzed separately. A second phase was then carried out according to a comparative or horizontal analysis (cross-case analysis) (Miles and Huberman, 1994). In this phase, the method of ‘constant comparative analysis’ (Glaser and Strauss, 1967) was used to look for common patterns as well as differences. This process was undertaken iteratively and adjustments in the coding process were made where necessary. Quantitative data were analyzed statistically with the use of SPSS 18.0. In this paper, data drawn from the nationwide survey and from the focus group are presented.

Expected Outcomes

Findings from this study shown that teachers’ motivation is moderate(45.5%). Interestingly, when asked about issues such as job satisfaction, self-efficacy and motivation over the last three years (during which major reforms in Education and in teaching have been put into place in schools), the majority recognize that their motivation decreased (61.6%) as well as their job satisfaction (45.5%).The participants state that individualism has increased as well as their working time. They also agree that there is an increase in bureaucracy in teaching, there is greater control on teachers’ work and there is an increase in public accountability and public criticism of teachers. They also recognize that media portrayal of the teaching profession has contributed to deteriorate the image of teachers. By and large, issues such as bureaucracy, intensification, the deterioration of social image of the teaching profession, unemployment amongst teachers due to the financial and economic crisis, endless reforms in Education are amongst the external factors that account for teachers’ lack of motivation and dissatisfaction. However, internal factors such as teacher collaboration, classroom work and the relationship with students were identified as factors and sources of personal and professional motivation which help teachers in remaining in the teaching profession despite everything. Strong professional values, sense of professionalism and the capacity for resisting as well as teacher resilience which is related to their sense of identity as teachers also emerged from the data. One might ask therefore about the effective existing conditions for a culture of leadership, which is to be related to teachers’ own understandings of leadership and their professional identities. In this regard, especially in a context marked by austerity and budget reductions for Education, one might ask about the ways in which teachers might exercise leadership in their schools and classrooms in order to foster their professional development.

References

Crowther, F. (1999) The IDEAS Project: Guidelines for Exploration and Trial in Queensland State Schools. Brisbane: Education Queensland. Durrant, J. (2004) Teachers leading change: frameworks and key ingredients for school improvement, Leading and Managing 10 (2) pp.10-29 Frost, D. (2004) Resisting the juggernaut: building capacity through teacher leadership in spite of it all, Leading and Managing 10(2), pp. 70-87. Frost, D. (2007) ‘Practitioner Research and leadership: the key to school improvement’ in Coleman, M. and Briggs A. (eds) Research methods in educational leadership and management, London: Paul Chapman. Frost, D. and Durrant, J. (2002) Teachers as Leaders: exploring the impact of teacher-led development work, School Leadership and Management, 22(2), pp. 143-161. Frost, D. and Durrant, J. (2003) Teacher Leadership: rationale, strategy and impact, School Leadership and Management, 23(2), pp. 173-186. Glaser, B. G. and Strauss, A. L. 1967. The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research. Chicago: Aldine. Katzenmeyer, A. and Moller, G. (2001) Awakening the Sleeping Giant: Helping Teachers Develop as Leaders (2nd ed) Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press. Lieberman, A. (1992) Teacher Leadership: What are we learning? in C. Livingston (Ed) Teachers as Leaders: evolving roles, Washington DC: National Education Association Lieberman, A. and Friedrich, L. (2008) Changing Teaching from Within: Teachers as leaders in J. MacBeath and Y.C. Cheng. (eds) Leadership for Learning: International Perspectives, Rotterdam and Taipei: Sense Publishers pp. 37-57. Lieberman, A. and Miller, L. (2004) Teacher Leadership, San Francisco CA: Jossey-Bass Little, J. W. (1988). Assessing the prospects for teacher leadership. In A. Lieberman (Ed.), Building a professional culture in schools. New York: Teachers College Press, pp. 78-106 MacBeath, J., Frost, D., Swaffield, S. and Waterhouse, J. (2006) Leadership for Learning: Making the Connections, Cambridge: University of Cambridge Faculty of Education. Miles, M. and Huberman, M. 1994. Qualitative data analysis. An expanded sourcebook (2nd edition). Thousand Oaks: CA, Sage.

Author Information

Maria Assunção Flores (presenting / submitting)
University of Minho
Institute of Education
Braga
University of Minho, Portugal
University of Minho, Portugal
University of Minho, Portugal
University of Minho, Portugal
University of Minho, Portugal

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.