Queering STEM: Innovative Curriculum and Teaching Techniques in Science Education
Author(s):
Helene Götschel (presenting / submitting) Florian C. Klenk (presenting)
Conference:
ECER 2017
Format:
Paper (Copy for Joint Session)

Session Information

22 SES 07 F JS, Gender Issues in Higher Education

Joint Paper Session NW 22 and NW 27

Time:
2017-08-23
17:15-18:45
Room:
K3.02
Chair:
Chantal Amade-Escot

Contribution

Queer pedagogy is an umbrella term for, among others, the reflection of the philosophy of pedagogy from a deconstructivist and non-normative perspective (Tierney 1997), the empirical research on queer teachers and/or queer students (Fifield & Swain 2002), the development of anti-oppressive teaching methods (Czollek et al. 2009) as well as implementing queer perspectives and queer contents to the syllabus (Harbeck 1992), and impart the reflection of normativity (Fifield & Letts 2014). In German speaking countries, queer theory has been increasingly discussed within the subject of Gender Studies. Far from being mainstream, most of the discourses take place in social sciences and cultural studies (Hark 2001) and began to inspire the discussion in philosophy of education, general pedagogy, sexual pedagogy and social work (Hartmann 2012, Tuider et al. 2012). Pedagogical research has shown that heteronormativity and a supposed binary gender order are still a great challenge in teaching and education (Kleiner 2015). The restrictive, often unspoken norms are a burden for those students who cannot or do not want to adapt to those norms (Heasley & Crane 2012).

These research results clearly illustrate the relevance of queering STEM. Competencies on the cultural representation and social construction of gender, identity, norms, culture, and otherness are vitally needed from future science teachers as well as from practicing science teachers. Our paper reflects on (1) the curriculum development project ‘Raising awareness for gender aspects in science education’ at Technical University Darmstadt/Germany and (2) the methodic-didactic conception project ‘Promoting Gender-and-Diversity-Awareness in Physics’ at Hannover University of Applied Sciences and Arts/ Germany. (1) As lecturers in future teacher training at a technical university we aim to disclose discourses about sex, gender, and desire that form and constitute our identity and to show the students that they participate in the reproduction of these exclusionary, binary norms (Butler 2004). Our central aim is to rethink science education in a transdisciplinary way and to expand the teacher training through contemporary issues of gender studies. We develop new seminar conceptions for teacher trainees focusing on gender studies and queer theory. By doing so, we encourage the students to adopt a responsible attitude towards the repetition of these norms (Balzter et al. 2016).

(2) As lecturers in science education at a university of applied sciences we adopt these concepts to our own teaching of science. Here, first year students of electrical, mechanical and industrial engineering attend a four-hour lecture introducing them to experimental physics. So far, German discussions of best practice approaches towards “gender and diversity in academic teaching” with regard to physics, mechanical, electrical or industrial engineering are both rare and hardly convincing. They are not up to date with current gender research and gender informed pedagogy, take the reflexion of the knowledge of physics rather half-heartedly into account and do not challenge the two-gender hegemony. Despite all the criticism, there are some publications dealing with “gender and diversity in the teaching of STEM subjects” which include proposals on how to develop gender- and diversity-informed science education from a queer-deconstructive standpoint. In the project ‘Promoting Gender-and-Diversity-Awareness’ we develop ways to put these ideas into practice. We create examples of gender informed teaching of basic physics courses at Hannover University of Applied Sciences and Arts. These explorative ventures into physics education reveal methods in academic teaching that may well help critically assess the image of physics, include the self-conception of physical science, criss-cross its masculine connotations, and, finally, upset the usual ideas about physics and gender.

Method

Our presentation addresses gender, more precisely a deconstructivist understanding of gender as performative order and queer theory as the reflection of normativity, in relation to developing innovative curriculum and teaching techniques. The ‘Raising awareness for gender aspects in science education’ project as well as the ‘promoting gender and diversity awareness’ project are based upon a comprehensive analysis of the available national and international literature (in German and English) in educational research on deconstructivist and queer studies in gender and science education as well as on gender and physics. To ensure a high quality standard of teaching, each term we get evaluated from the Central Academic Advising on empirical grounds. Up to now more than 400 questionnaires provide information on the contentedness of the participants with the contents, organization, activities, learning success, and achievements and information on their critiques and suggestions. In addition some of the lessons have been video recorded for research purpose. At the time of writing data is in the process of being analysed both quantitatively and qualitatively through a concurrent mixed methods approach.

Expected Outcomes

Critical conceptions such as a deconstructivist understanding of gender and queer theory can be used to inspire the development of innovative curriculum and teaching techniques. Despite the high abstract level of these concepts they can be transformed into teaching practice in a fruitful way. This we have shown in our projects. These concepts can be used to support teaching science in a way that is welcoming, open, and encouraging to all students. It enables students in science as well as in science education to reflect on their understanding of physics and physical knowledge, to understand their attitudes as learners (and future multipliers) of ‘physical conceptions’ rather than ‘physical facts’. The evaluation results show that the aim of ‘Raising Awareness’ (teaching gender to future science teachers) was reached while the ‘Promotion gender and diversity awareness’ project (teaching basic physics in a gender informed way) needs further experience and research to develop it. We are seeking for a change to share and learn from other researchers using deconstructivist theory and queer theory to make a difference to pedagogical practice in science education.

References

Balzter, Nadine, Klenk F. C. & Zitzelsberger O. (eds.) (2016): Queering MINT. Impulse für eine dekonstruktive Lehrer_innenbildung. Leverkusen: Barbara Budrich Butler, Judith (2004): Undoing Gender. New York, Taylor & Francis. Czollek, Leah Carola, Perko, G. & Weinbach, H. (eds.) (2009): Lehrbuch Gender und Queer. Grundlagen, Methoden und Praxisfelder. Weinheim: Juventa Fifield, Steve & Letts W. (2014): [Re]considering queer theories in science education. Cultural Studies of Science Education, 9, 393-407. Fifield, Steve & Swain H.L. (2002): Heteronormativity and common sense in science (teacher) education. In: Kissen, Rita M. (ed.): Getting ready for Benjamin: Preparing teachers for sexual diversity in the classroom. Lanham, Rowman & Littlefield, p. 177-189. Harbeck, Karen M. (1992): Coming out of the classroom closet: Gay and lesbian students, teachers and curricula. New York, Harrington Park, 1992. Hark, Sabine (2001): Disputed Territory. Feminist Studies in Germany and its Queer Discontents. Amerika Studien/American Studies 46/1, p. 87-103. Hartmann, Jutta (2012): Improvisationen im Rahmen des Zwangs. Gendertheoretische Herausforderungen der Schriften Judith Butlers für pädagogische Theorie und Praxis. In: Ricken, Norbert & Balzer N. (eds.): Judith Butler: Pädagogische Lektüren. VS Verlag, Wiesbaden, p. 149-178. Kleiner, Bettina (2015): subjekt bildung heteronormativität. Leverkusen: Barbara Budrich Tierney, William G. (1997): Academic outlaws: Queer theory and cultural studies in the academy. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Tuider, Elisabeth/Müller, Mario/Timmermanns, Stefan/Bruns-Bachmann, Petra/Koppermann, Carola (eds.) (2012): Sexualpädagogik der Vielfalt. Weinheim, Beltz Juventa, 2nd edition.

Author Information

Helene Götschel (presenting / submitting)
Hannover University of Applied Sciences and Arts
Florian C. Klenk (presenting)
Technical University Darmstadt

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.