In the Greek political scene, nowadays "excellence" is a concept that plays a leading role in political debates and public discourse. The breadth and manner of using this concept as rhetoric and ideology make it a red threat to education. A populist discourse is being developed which the conservative forces have proclaimed as a panacea for the development of educational policies, while in contrast to that, from the so-called progressives there is a reservation regarding the real aims pursued by the politics of excellence. The conservative government produces policies in favour of the "excellents", while reservation and challenge by the opposition makes the last a "persecutor" of excellence.
The main reason of this ideological rivalry was the reform of the Model (Pilot) Public Schools in 2011 following EU standards (European Commission, 2000). With the 3966/2011 Law voted during the period of the economic crisis, they became selective schools, based on, inter alia, entrance examinations. There was also a strong mobility of alumni, parents, etc. which highlighted some informal networks, making their ‘secret’ target visible, namely a kind of privatisation of these public schools (Souto-Otero, 2015; Ball, 2007). However, this issue was linked to the broader social issues of equal opportunities and social justice which were not able to express specific educational policies. Thus, the plagues of school polarities found a populist ideological pole of "excellence" that almost penetrated the educational field and broader areas of social and political life too. The culmination of the ideological controversy over "excellence" took place when the SYRIZA government in May 2015 raised the issue of halting 55 Public Model Schools, allowing only 5 Historic ones to operate as such, owing to the status of the legacies of the 'national benefactors', as a springboard for promoting excellence.
It is interesting to mention some social historical landmarks in order to illuminate the socio-political coiling that highlights "excellence" as a major educational issue and renders it superior to other critical educational issues, such as inability to consensual school policy establishing a system for the entrance to higher education, failure to implement lucrative inclusive education of refugees and vulnerable social groups, inability to overcome the discomfort and frustration of teachers caused by lack of training and/or counseling support. Thus, our research work is also closely linked to the prominent features of the Greek education system operating in a volatile political landscape because of the prolonged economic crisis, having centralized and bureaucratic administrative structures and discontinuity in school policies (Sørensen & Torfing, 2004).
This framework does not favor the development of institutionalized networks and visible forms of educational governance similar to other European decentralized systems (Tsakiris & Samara, 2018). However, these non-institutionalized networks, that seek to restore and maintain the Model Schools by promoting excellence as an ideological vehicle enhancing the quality of education, are particularly interesting. By using an improvised tool, this research aims at identifying and highlighting the factors that determine how these social networks are transformed into interest groups (Tsakiris 2018; Mele & Baccaro, 2008; Castoriadis 1975) affecting the educational policy in favour of them.
The arising research questions are the following:
- How rhetoric about "excellence" has finally become a decisive ideological pole in order to cover up or veil the ideological confrontation about educational inequalities regarding school and social justice?
- How has the state utilized its rhetoric of excellence and contributed to the operation of the non-institutionalized networks, and in particular those relating to Public Model Schools which proclaim the promotion of excellence?
- In what ways do non-institutionalized social networks linked to Model Schools become educational policy networks with interest group characteristics?