Session Information
Paper Session
Contribution
The Danish educational system is associated with equal access to education and a high educational mobility, and all students are entitled to receive state grants during their education. As a part of the Danish educational system, the educational program for a Bachelor Degree in Social Education is characterized by a very high educational mobility which is reflected in the fact that the majority of the students come from lower economic background and have parents with low educational degrees. Despite the equality discourse circulating in the educational program for a Bachelor Degree in Social education, we are witnessing an uneven distribution of belonging and participation among the students. In the paper, we approach diversity as a question of belonging for all students. Following this, the longitudinal study is based on the research question: How to initiate more diverse educational settings and a more even distribution of belonging and participation?
The longitudinal study of students´ participation and belonging draws on studies that conceptualize students’ participation and processes of in/exclusion in educational settings as a matter of belonging. From other studies we know that educational and pedagogical practices that enhance students ´sense of belonging and ´connection´ are crucial for the diversity dimension within the educational setting (Thomas 2015). In youth studies, belonging refer to young peoples´ social and emotional work in relation to connect to people, places and issues that matters to them (Cuervo & Wyn 2014). The concept of belonging is a personal and intimate feeling as well as an orientation toward the surrounding places and social settings (Antonsich 2010). In relation to educational settings Gravett & Ajjawi (2021) emphasize belonging as a phenomenon intertwined with processes of identities and learning and as a phenomenon unfolding in relation to the academic content, the social relations in classroom and the places of campus.
The study is also grounded in poststructuralist and feminist gender and intersectionality studies (Butler 1993, Davies 2006, Staunæs 2003, Kofoed 2004, Wetherell 2008) that pay attention to how the construction of gendered, racialized, ethnicized, and classed differences and identities are being regulated and negotiated in the everyday life in different social settings – i.e., educational settings. Drawing on this theoretical perspective we think of students´ sense of belonging and participation as intertwined with social cultural categories - such as gender, ethnicity, and social background - and the way social categories intersect and affect each other in the educational setting and classroom culture. The interplay between different social categories and the impact on students´ belonging and participation is related to the cultural practices in classroom. Social categories work as ´tools´ by which students (and teachers) are dis/connecting to - and in- and excluding - other students and produces the criteria for what is recognized as ´appropriate student´ and ´inappropriate student´. In that sense social categories and the intersection between social categories affect differentiation and difference-producing practices in the classroom culture and the possibility for belonging and participation.
The presentation will present some preliminary findings based on the qualitative parts of the study conducted during the students first year at the Social Education Programme. The presentation is based on three themes: 1) group work, 2) student participation, 2) the framework and structures of the education.
Method
The paper draws on a longitudinal study (Holmegaard 2018, Saldaña 2003) of students´ participation and belonging in the educational program for a Bachelor Degree in Social Education that lasts 3,5 years. The longitudinal study is conducted at University College Copenhagen from 2022 to 2026. The study combines classroom ethnographic study and qualitative interviews with a survey study and an intervention study. The design of the survey study and the intervention study will be based on the findings from the qualitative part of the study (classroom ethnographic study and qualitative interviews). In the classroom ethnographic study 15-20 students, and their fellow students, are followed during the 3, 5 years. The classroom ethnographic study mixes participation observation in classroom with qualitative interviews with the students. The interviews are carried out every year during the students ‘ education. As a way of studying processes of belonging the ethnographic classroom study is zooming in on the student’s participation strategies, positioning, negotiations, dis/identifications with other students and how these student performances intertwined with social categories.
Expected Outcomes
Since the data from the qualitative part of study is conducted during the students first year at the Social Education programs, the presented findings are preliminary. In the study, we operate with several categories that are continuously discussed and adjusted. However, there are three themes that are interesting to delve into and discuss in relation to students’ sense of belonging and diversity. The paper will elaborate the three themes: 1) Group work, 2) Student participation, 3) The organization of the education. A large part of the education is organized as group work, and the students spend a lot of time and energy in participating and joining into groups. The group work allows different student positions, and academic as well as social positions are at stake. Our study indicates a significant coherence between students positions in groupwork and their sense of belonging in the educational program. Also, the students’ participation in lectures has a significant impact on the sense of belonging: During lectures and group work the students take and are offered different positions and forms of participation that are linked to social categories such as ´the talented white female student with high study intensity´, ´the non-participating student in the periphery´, ´students with minority backgrounds who stick together. Finally, the campus architecture and the daily organization of the education have a considerable impact on the students' belonging. The interior architecture at campus is characterized by white walls with no decorations, long clinical hallways, classrooms with randomly placed tables and chairs which all together are producing an atmosphere of temporality that trouble the students´ sense of belonging which is also strengthen by a very changeable daily organization of the education. During a week the students meet many different lectures and many different subjects. Al together it challenges the students’ sense of belonging.
References
Antonsich, M. (2010) Searching for Belonging – An Analytical Framework. Geography Compass. Vol. 4 (6). P. 644-650 Butler, J. (1993) Bodies that Matter. On the Discursive Limits of Sex. Routledge. Cuervo, H. & Wyn, J. (2014) Reflections on the use of spatial and relational metaphors in youth studies. Journal of youth Studies. Vol. 17 (7). P. 901-915. Davies, B. (2006) Subjectification: the relevance of Butler´s analysis for education. British Journal of Sociology. Vol. 27, No. 4. Gravett, K. & Ajjawi, R. (2021) Belonging as situated practice. Studies in Higher education. Vol. 47 (7). P. 1386-1396 Hermanowicz, J. C. (2013) The longitudinal qualitative interview. Qualitative Sociology, 36 (2), 189-208. Holmegard, H. T. (2018) Når alting er foranderligt. En longitudinal, kvalitativ, narrativ tilgang til unges overgange til og fra universitet. In. Pless, M. & Sørensen, N.U. (ed) Unge perspektiver. Tænkninger og tilgange i ungdomsforskningen. Kofoed, J. (2003). Elevpli – In- og eksklusionsprocesser blandt børn i skolen. Ph.d.-afhandling. Institut for Pædagogisk Psykologi. Danmarks Pædagogiske Universitet, København. Staunæs, D. (2004). Etnicitet, køn og skoleliv: præsentation af en Ph.d.-afhandling. Frederiksberg. Samfundslitteratur. Thomas, K. (2015). “Rethinking Belonging Through Bourdieu, Diaspora and the Spatial.” Widening Participation and Lifelong Learning 17 (1): 37–49.
Search the ECER Programme
- Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
- Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
- Search for authors and in the respective field.
- For planning your conference attendance you may want to use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference
- If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.