Understanding the interaction of young people's social networks, social disadvantage and high educational attainment.
Author(s):
Alastair Wilson (presenting / submitting) Katie Hunter
Conference:
ECER 2011
Format:
Paper

Session Information

05 SES 12 A, Urban Education and Children and Youth at Risk

Paper Session

Time:
2011-09-16
08:30-10:00
Room:
JK 28/112,G, 58
Chair:
Ross Deuchar

Contribution

The link between social disadvantage and low educational attainment has been persistent over the past few decades and is a particular, unwelcome feature of Scottish Education (OECD, 2004).  Addressing this problem has been the focus of a range of different policy initiatives that can, arguably, claim only limited success. In the UK recent research exploring this issue has challenged the dominance of ‘school effectiveness’ and indicated the importance of out of school factors in explaining educational attainment (Ball, S 2010; Gorard, S 2010; Lupton, R 2004 ). In examining the lives of young people outside school researchers have drawn heavily on the explanatory power of social capital theory as illuminated by the work of Bourdieux, Coleman and Putnam. Often this work has challenged the imposition of ‘middle class’ values and aspirations on disadvantaged young people, a process that demands their individual adaptation and fails to sufficiently address crucial structural factors (see Archer et al., 2010). A further feature of this research has been an emphasis on the social relationships and networks that young people have access to and the role that these play in their realising of ‘valued’ educational opportunities. Heath et al, (2010) for example focused on the importance of social networks and the transmission of social capital as being crucial to educational attainment and entry into higher education in particular.  In this research we narrow the focus further by examining the role of social networks in the educational attainment of a small group of high attaining pupils in a school experiencing a high level of social disadvantage and from which only a small percentage of pupils proceed to higher education. Three research questions have framed the development of this work:

·       What is the landscape of the young people’s social networks?

·       In what ways do young people draw on these networks in planning their futures?

·       What contribution do these social networks make to young people’s educational attainment?

To explore these questions the research team has drawn on very different sources of data.  Firstly it made use of the fact that mobile phones are now ubiquitous across all sectors of society.  Not only are they powerful enough to allow a rich user experience in accessing the internet, but their functionality can be used to monitor user activity; the applications they use and the people they communicate with.  The research made use of mobile phones as a valuable tool for social analysis. The data this strand of the research generated was combined with data gathered by a substantial period of qualitative research.  The potential contribution of new mobile technologies to educational research provides a further dimension to this research.

 

Method

This research project involved working with a large secondary school within a socially disadvantaged area of a large Scottish city. Of the 150 pupils in the 5th year group, 31 were identified by the school as having the 'potential' to enter higher education. This group of 30 pupils were each given a modern smart phone with added software capable of recording their text message traffic 9numbers sent to and received from, not content), phone calls (numbers called and received)and proximity to other (within group) phones. These data were collected by each phone and automatically pushed to a university server for collation and analysis at regular intervals. In parallel with this process researchers conducted a qualitative mapping of the young people and their potential social networks using a variety of methods including interviews, observation and photo based analysis. The project collated these varied data over a period of nine months in the run up to the pupils’ higher exams which are crucial to university entrance. The project involved a continuous iterative dialogue between the two research teams in which explanations for emerging findings were discussed resulting in further data collection methods.

Expected Outcomes

Initial findings from this research indicate that the highest attaining young people were members of several, small social networks composed of other young people in the wider study group. In addition these networks were the young people's main social networks and there was little evidence of their membership of other equally developed peer networks. Further research will ascertain the genealogy of these networks but these initial findings have important implications for the ways in which policy makers and schools recognise and perhaps nurture young people's social networks. In addition this research provides an indication of the ways in which new mobile technologies can be incorporated into research design to complement intensive qualitative approaches.

References

Archer, L; Hollingworth, S & Mendick, H (2010) 'Urban Youth and Schooling' Open University Press, Mcgraw-Hill Education: England. Ball, S. (2010) 'New Class Inequalities in Education: why education policy maybe looking in the wrong place! Education Policy, Civil Society and Social Class', International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 30 (3/4), 155-166. Gorard, S. (2010). Serious doubts about school effectiveness, British Educational Research Journal, 36,5, 745‐766. Heath, S; Fuller, A & Johnston, B (2010) ‘Young people, social capital and network-based educational decision-making’ British Journal of Sociology of Education Volume 31, Issue 4 July 2010 , pages 395 - 411 Lupton, R (2004) Schools in disadvantaged areas: recognising context and raising quality. CASEpaper, 76. Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion, London School of Economics and Political Science, London, UK

Author Information

Alastair Wilson (presenting / submitting)
University of Strathclyde
School of Education
Glasgow
University of Strathclyde, United Kingdom

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.