Session Information
ERG SES D 12, Management and Leadership in Education
Paper Session
Contribution
Since more than ten years, the German three tier-system of Land administration is under reform. According to experts these administrative reforms show a new quality of change in comparison to previous phases of modernization. Whereas former reform-measures merely affected the surface of administration, Mehde (2009) now notices systematic and incisive changings at the structural, i.e. the organizationallevel. These reforms aim to transform the input-oriented, centralized administration into an output-oriented, decentralized, and deregulated one. With regard to the sixteen school administrations of the German Länder these reforms have been connected with the implementation of a “semi-autonomous school” as well as of a monitoring system (Altrichter/Maag Merki, 2010).
To date, there exist only very few studies analyzing the inter- and intra-organizational changeswithin the Land administrations (Brüsemeister & Newiadomsky, 2008). Therefore, in educational science as well as in the Land administrations themselves there is need of specific empirical knowledge of these „black boxes“, e.g. of the specific reform-state, the reform-designs put into praxis, their trend of development, and last but not least of their impacts on the effectiveness and quality of the German school systems as well as on the potentials of innovation offering the different actors within the system (Kühn, 2012; Wacker et al., 2012).
The presentation introduces findings of a qualitative case-study on the reform of the Land administration of Hesse. In comparison to the other Länder the reform-program of Hesse shows a far more systematic, far-reaching, and advanced reform-progress. The study is based on the following research question:
To what extent does the organizational reform of the school administration of the Land Hesse lead to a fundamental change in its inter- and intra-organizational governance regime?
The presentation gives an overview on the theoretical background of the study and its methodology. An emphasis is placed on its main findings of structural change and their impact on the administrative action system. These are connected with governance-relateddiscussions in system theory, constructivism, and postmodernism (Snellen, 2006). For example, a symbiosis of administrative change and the aforementioned (meta)theories can be found in Kegelmann’s (2007) postmodern model of NPM or in (New) Public Governance as upcoming international model for administration (Bovaird/Löffler, 2009). The study further rests uponadministrative and political science, organizational theory as well as upon control- and governance-theory (Mayntz, 2009). Based onthe mentioned models for administration, on the concept of a people-processing-system (Luhmann/Schorr, 1979) as well as on Rosenbusch’s (2007) model of an pedagogical culture within the school administrations of the Länder there is made the case, that the German school administrations are more likely to become an effective and innovative action system, if they are directed according to a postmodern governance regime and thus constructed as people-processing- and network-organizations. Therefore, the administrative reform-model (New) Public Governance is taken as example how the Land administrations could be transformed into such heterarchies. Although the presentation aims to present suggestions for the German school administrations there may be identified as well helpful hints for European school systems with a similar administrative tradition.
Method
Expected Outcomes
References
Altrichter, Herbert & Maag Merki, Katharina (Ed.). (2010). Handbuch Neue Steuerung im Schulsystem (p. 219-254). Wiesbaden. Bouckaert, Geert. (2006). Auf dem Weg zu einer neo-weberianischen Verwaltung. In Bogumil, Jann, & Nullmeier (Ed.), Politik und Verwaltung. PVS Sonderheft 37/2006 (p. 354-372). Wiesbaden. Bovaird, Tony & Löffler, Elke. (2009). Understanding public management and governance. In Id. (Hrsg.), Public Management and Governance (p. 3-13). 2nd ed. London. Brunsson, Nils. (1989). The organization of hypocricy: Talk, Decisions and Actions in Organizations. Chichester u.a. Brüsemeister, Thomas & Newiadomsky, Martina. (2008). Schulverwaltung – Ein unbekannter Akteur? In Langer (Ed.), ‚Warum tun die das?’ Governanceanalysen zum Steuerungshandeln in der Schulentwicklung (p. 73-93). Wiesbaden. Kegelmann, Jürgen. (2007). New Public Management. Möglichkeiten und Grenzen des Neuen Steuerungsmodells. Wiesbaden. Kieser, Alfred & Walgenbach, Peter. (2007). Organisation. 5th ed. Stuttgart. Kühn, Svenja Mareike. (2012). Steuerung und Innovation durch Abschlussprüfungen? Wiesbaden. Luhmann, Niklas & Schorr, Karl Eberhard. (1979) Reflexionsprobleme im Erziehungssystem. Stuttgart. Lorenz, Oliver (Ed.). (2009). Jahrbuch Verwaltungsmodernisierung Deutschland 2010. Berlin. Mayntz, Renate. (2009). Governancetheorie: Erkenntnisse und offene Fragen. In Grande & May (Ed.), Perspektiven der Governance-Forschung (p. 9-19). Nomos. Mehde, Veith. (2009). Aktuelle Entwicklungslinien der Verwaltungsreform. Prinzipien, Folgen, Probleme. In Verwaltung & Management 15/1, p. 19-33. Pollitt, Christopher & Bouckaert, Geert. (2005). Public Management Reform. A Comparative Analysis. Oxford. Rosenbusch, Heinz S. (2007). Schule und Schulverwaltung – Eine organisationspädagogische Perspektive. In van Buer & Wagner (Ed.), Qualität von Schule: ein kritisches Handbuch (p. 217-227). Frankfurt a.M. Schnapp. Kai-Uwe. (2006). Comparative Public Administration. In Bogumil, Jann & Nullmeier (Ed.), Politik und Verwaltung. PVS Sonderheft 37/2006 (p. 327-353). Wiesbaden. Snellen, Ignace. (2006). Grundlagen der Verwaltungswissenschaft. Ein Essay über ihre Paradigmen. Wiesbaden. Wacker, Albrecht (et al). (2012). Schul- und Unterrichtsreform durch ergebnisorientierte Steuerung? Wiesbaden. Walkenhaus, Ralf. (2006). Governance. In Voigt & Walkenhaus (Ed.), Handwörterbuch zur Verwaltungsreform (p. 162-166). Wiesbaden.
Search the ECER Programme
- Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
- Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
- Search for authors and in the respective field.
- For planning your conference attendance you may want to use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference
- If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.