Families, Schools, Social Inequality and ICT: Some Facts and Thoughts
Conference:
ECER 2013
Format:
Paper

Session Information

14 SES 05 B, Family Education and Parenting - Technological Aspects of School-Family-Community Partnerships

Paper Session

Time:
2013-09-11
11:00-12:30
Room:
BCEP
Chair:
Raquel-Amaya Martínez-González

Contribution

Schools, families and communities interwave complex and multifaceted relations and are in a process of reconfiguration (Stoer & Silva, 2005). Home-school relations, as any other, are power relations and have the potentiality of leading to a true partnership or, on the other end of the spectrum, to its opposite, an open conflict. This means that the relationship among schools, families and their communities might turn out to be a way of social and cultural reproduction, very often through subtle ways that prevent many people of being aware of it (Lightfoot, 1978; Lareau, 1989; David, 1993; Vincent, 1996; Silva, 2003). Theorizing this relationship as one among cultures (Silva, 2003) - i.e., a relation between the local culture(s) and the school culture (this one characterized by Bourdieu and other sociologists as representing and legitimizing an urban, written, middle class one) - is a way of pointing to that possibility; thus, of avoiding that reproduction. The structurally unequal relationship between schools and families, depending on factors such as social class, gender and ethnicity (Lightfoot, 1978; Lareau, 1989; David, 1993; Vincent, 1996; Silva, 2003), stresses the importance of ICT as eventually playing a mediation role between the "two worlds" (Silva, Coelho, Fernandes and Viana, 2010), and highlights the possibility of perverse effects of public policies in this area, as well. These and other questions begin to be considered by several experts, even though there is still a deficit of research in this area, which seems, however, to be a promising one (Pieri, 2005; Wiedemann, 2003, Martinez-Gonzalez et al., 2003, 2005; Diogo & Silva, 2010; Silva et al., 2010).

One of the problems of the so-called information society - of which Europe is, in general, a good example - refers to inequalities and power relations that underlie it, something known by different labels such as digital gap, info-exclusion and digital divide. Mostly, what appears to be concerned is the gap between two opposing groups: those with and those without access to ICT. However, the question goes beyond the access one: we should address its uses, too.

In this paper we will address the results from a sociological research on the uses and effects, school and social, of the Magalhães computer[1] in an administrative group of schools in Leiria, Portugal. We will focus on how information and communication technology can become a bridge among different sociocultural groups or, on the contrary, can contribute to the reproduction of social inequalities.

This concern is part of a broader research, which, originally, aimed at finding answers to multiple questions, including: who uses the Magalhães computer? What are its uses? In what contexts? What are the modes of regulation of its uses? By whom? What are the effects, school and social, of its uses by the various social actors and their interactions? In particular, in the classroom and in the school-family relationship?  

[1] The Magalhães computer is the result of a government policy that distributed a laptop specially conceived for elementary children, at a national level, for a very low price or even free for poor families. This mediatic and controversial program started in the school year of 2008-2009.

Method

Having in mind the problem and the questions, the research took a longitudinal nature, from October 2009 to December 2011. So, the team decided to build a mixed design, ie, crossing a quantitative methodology with a qualitative one, adopting, thus, the perspective of the existence of a continuum (rather than a rupture) between what has been called quantitative and qualitative research. Thus, with regard to the extensive nature of the research, we applied questionnaires to all the elementary teachers (30 teachers with class and 2 without class), and to half of the elementary students (around 210) and their families. The questionnaire was applied four times to teachers and two times to students and families. The collected data were subjected to statistical analysis with the help of the SPSS software. In what concerns the intensive component of the research, we decided to make an ethnography of a class, that was followed during two years. The classroom teacher was asked to fill in a pre-built grid on a weekly basis and was subjected to an in-depth interview near the end of the research. Fieldnotes were subjected to a coding process. We also relied upon documents produced by children (research tasks, compositions, drawings).

Expected Outcomes

The data point to the fact: a) of a massive adhesion to the Magalhães computer (around 93%), being most families from disadvantaged backgrounds, since some middle class families refused to buy a Magalhães owing to the fact they already had, at least, one computer at home; b) of a regular use of this laptop by children, firstly in the home, secondly in the classroom, and thirdly in other contexts (relatives and friends’ homes); c) that the Magalhães tends to become a real personal computer for the child, who, in general, uses it regularly under his/her own initiative during extra school activities, including weekends and holidays; d) that the Magalhães becomes, in part, a family computer, namely in the low SES families, where the Magalhães was the first computer to enter home; e) that the use of the Magalhães by children displays some social class differences. We believe that local knowledge, as the information provided in this research, is relevant to understand broader dynamics and policies, including at the European level.

References

David, M. (1993). Parents, Gender and Education Reform. Cambridge: Polity Press. Diogo, A. & Silva, P. (2010) “Escola, Família e Desigualdades: Articulações e Caminhos na Sociologia da Educação em Portugal” in P. Abrantes (Org.) Tendências e Controvérsias em Sociologia da Educação. Lisboa, Mundos Sociais, 51-80. Lareau, A. (1989). Home Advantage - Social Class and Parental Intervention in Elementary Education. New York: The Falmer Press. Lightfoot, S. (1978) Worlds Apart - Relationships Between Families and Schools, Nova Iorque, Basic Books. Martinez-Gonzalez, R-A.; Herrero, H. P.; Esteo, J. L. J.; León, C. C. (2003). New Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) at Home and at School. Parents and teachers Views. In School, Family and Community Partnership in a world of Differences and Changes. Gdansk University. Martinez-Gonzalez, R-A.; Pérez-Herrero, M. H. & Rodríguez-Ruiz, B. (2005). Family and Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs): New challenges for Family Education and Parents-teachers Partnerships. In Family-School-Community Partnerships – Merging into Social Development. Oviedo: Grupo SM. Pieri, M. (2005) Virtual Communities as bridges between parents and school: The case of an Italian secondary school. In Family-School-Community Partnerships – Merging into Social Development, Oviedo: Grupo SM. Silva, P. (2003). Escola-Família, Uma Relação Armadilhada. Porto: Edições Afrontamento. Silva, P.; Coelho, C; Fernandes, C. & Viana, J. (2010). “Mediação Sociopedagógica na Escola: Conceitos e Contextos”, in Américo Nunes Peres e Ricardo Vieira (Coords.) Educação, Justiça e Solidariedade na Construção da Paz, Chaves/Leiria: APAP/CIID-IPL, 75-99. Stoer, S. & Silva, P. (Orgs.) (2005) Escola-Família, Uma Relação em Processo de Reconfiguração, Porto: Porto Editora. Vincent, C. (1996) Parents and Teachers - Power and Participation, London: Falmer Press. Wiedemann, F. (2003) Digital Cooperation Between School and Home: Limits and Possibilities. In School, Family and Community Partnership in a world of Differences and Changes, Gdansk University.

Author Information

Pedro Silva (presenting / submitting)
Polytechnic Institute of Leiria
School of Education and Social Sciences
Leiria
Agrupamento de Escolas José Saraiva, Portugal
Agrupamento de Escolas José Saraiva, Portugal
University of Lisbon, Portugal

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.