National Identity Construction Through the Social Representations Presented on Finnishness in Schools
Author(s):
Pia-Maria Niemi (presenting / submitting) Arniika Kuusisto (presenting) Arto Kallioniemi
Conference:
ECER 2013
Format:
Paper

Session Information

07 SES 02 A, Identity Policies

Paper Session

Time:
2013-09-10
15:15-16:45
Room:
D-302
Chair:
Dana Moree

Contribution

This paper examines the ways in which school environment contributes to the national identity construction of Finnishness in the comprehensive schools in Finland. The question of national identity construction has become topical also in the Finnish schools, as the number of home languages, religions and worldviews in pupils’ backgrounds has increased in the late 2000s (Rapo 2011, Yuen 2010, Melich 2010).

The construction of national and cultural identity in Finland has been based on the idea of unity created in the nationalistic turn of the 19th century. The Finnish language, the Lutheran religion and the mythic idea about the historically unitary nation have created a monocultural view about the nation, despite of the minorities that have lived in the country for centuries. (Jalovaara  & Martikainen 2010.) Due to the globalisation and the increased diversity in classrooms, the need for intercultural skills has become crucial around the world (Demereth & Mattheis 2012). In Helsinki, there were 40 other languages taught as the pupil’s mother tongue in the comprehensive schools in 2012. (Opetusvirasto 2012).

Immigration has also increased the number of members belonging to other than the traditional Lutheran religious communities, and there is an increasing number of practitioners of religions not belonging to any official communities[A1]  (Ketola 2011a, Jalovaara & Martikainen 2010). The role of religious and worldview diversity has become important as the cultural difference is often based on religious or worldview differences (Verkuyten et al 2012, Kuusisto & Lamminmäki-Vartia 2012). However, as Kuusisto & Lamminmäki-Vartia (2012) point out, the diversity doesn’t automatically lead to empathy. Examples about contradictions created by religious symbols in schools have been seen in many European countries (McGoldrick 2011, Niemi 2012).The need for ethical considerations and reflection on one’s own worldview’s (Kuusisto & Lamminmäki-Vartia 2012)

According to Seedberg & Minick (2012) cross-cultural competences include the reflection of one’s own cultural identity and it’s relation to other cultures in a way that leads to the understanding and respecting of those that are culturally different from the self. However, this noble goal may turn against itself if cultures are viewed as static and permanent notions that affect all people the same way (Dervin et al 2012; Holm & Nokelainen 2011) As studies show, teachers’ knowledge about cultural aspects is often insufficient in order to promote them in education (Demerath & Mattheis 2012, Seeberg & Minick 2012) For example about Kuusisto & Lamminmäki-Vartia’s (2012) study that shows that the increase in various worldviews is not visible in the Finnish kindergartens’ practices.

Social representations are important creators and markers of social identity as they constitute of meaning perceived by the group in the same way.  (Moscovici 2000 [1988]). Elements presented in schools are ways to create and transmit cultural values and national images (Kallioniemi et al 2009).

In this article we will examine the following research question: In what ways school celebrations contributes to the national identity construction of Finnishness?

Method

The article is based on the qualitative data gathered with thematic interviews with 12 teachers from a secondary school in Helsinki (Niemi 2012). The thematic analysis of the data is compared to the quantitative data (n=1301) from the comprehensive schools in Helsinki and Pori. The study utilizes a mixed method approach (Tashakkori & Teddlie 1998), combining quantitative and qualitative methods and data analysing strategies. The data (n=1301) will be analysed statistically for the quantitative parts (survey) and with Atlas.TI aided content analysis for the open ended questions (survey) and for the interviews. The data analysis aims to find out which elements are presented as seemingly persistent markers of the Finnish national identity.

Expected Outcomes

The findings will illustrate the perspectives of the pupils to the ways in which school environment contributes to the national identity construction of Finnishness in the comprehensive schools in Finland. It also provides information on the position of the Finnish situation in a wider international context (findings compared with EDEN international data & previous research literature on WRERU & REDCo2 findings). The expected outcome of the study is that the image created in school celebrations about Finnishness is easily perceived as a cultural unit that may be separated from other religious traditions (meaning non-Lutheran), other languages and other nationalities (Niemi 2012, McGoldrick 2011). Based on previous research (Kuusisto & Lamminmäki-Vartia 2012, Kallioniemi et al 2009, Niemi 2012) it is expected that the organizing of school celebrations is often done in haste and lacks deeper consideration about the cultural connotations implemented in the traditions. It is also expected that new approaches are needed in order to make good use of school celebrations as opportunities to enhance reciprocal learning about various national and religious traditions.

References

Dervin, Fred, Paatela-Nieminen, Martina, Kuoppala, Kaisa & Riitaoja, Anna-Leena 2012 Multicultural Education in Finland. Renewed Intercultural Competencies to the Rescue? 1-13. International Journal of Multicultural Education. Vol 14 (3). Holm, Kristiina & Tirri, Kirsi 2011 Intercultural and interreligious sensitivity scales. 101-120. Kirsi Tirri & Petri Nokelainen (eds.) Measuring Multiple Intelligences and Moral Sensitivities in Education. Rotterdam: Sense Publishers. Jalovaara, Ville & Martikainen, Tuomas 2010 Suomi maallistumisen jälkeen. Valtiokirkollisuudesta uskontojen markkinoihin. 27-39. Tuomas Martikainen & Ville Jalovaara (toim.) Uskonnon ylösnousemus. Kirkon, uskonnon ja kulttuurin murros. [http://www.magma.fi/images/stories/reports/ms1004_religionen_web.pdf] Cited 20.1.2012. Kallioniemi, Arto, Lyhykäinen, Kaarina & Räsänen, Antti. 2009 Headmasters’ conceptions of school festival traditions. 161–170. Mirja-Tytti Talib, JyrkiLoima, Heini Paavola & Sanna Patrikainen (toim.) Dialogs on Diversity and Global Education. Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang. Kuusisto, Arniika & Lamminmäki-Vartia, Silja 2012 Moral Foundation of the Kindergarten Teacher’s Educational Approach. Self-Reflection Facilitated Educator Response to Pluralism in Educational Context. Education Research International. doi:10.1155/2012/303565. Cited 20.1.2013. McGoldrick, Dominic 2011 Religion in the European Public Square and in European Public Life Crucifixes in the Classroom? 451–502. Human Rights Law Review. Vol 11 (3). Melich, Jiri 2010 Multiculturalism and Integration. Lessons to Be Learnt from Cases of Canada and Europe. 169-191. Christian Lammert & Katja Sarkowsky (eds). Travelling Concepts. Negotiating Diversity in Canada and Europe. Unknown: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften Moscovici, Serge. 1988 Social Representations. Explorations in Social Psychology. Gerard Duveen (ed.) Cambridge: Polity Press. Niemi, Pia-Maria 2012 Suomalaisuus koulun juhlissa. Master’s thesis. Rapo, Markus 2011 Kuka on maahanmuuttaja? Tieto&Trendit 1/2011. [http://tilastokeskus.fi/tup/tietotrendit/tt_01_11.html] Cited 20.1.2013. Yuen, Celeste 2010 Dimensions of diversity. Challenges to secondary school teachers with implications for intercultural teacher education. 732–741. Teaching and Teacher Education. Vol 26 (2010) .

Author Information

Pia-Maria Niemi (presenting / submitting)
University of Helsinki
Department of Teacher Education
Helsinki
Arniika Kuusisto (presenting)
University of Helsinki, Finland
University of Helsinki, Finland

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.