Do They Deserve It? (Folk Theories Used by Help Providing Professionals Working With Children From Excluded Localities.)
Author(s):
David Doubek (presenting / submitting) Marketa Levinska (presenting) Dana Bittnerová
Conference:
ECER 2013
Format:
Paper

Session Information

07 SES 03 B, Roma People

Paper Session

Time:
2013-09-10
17:15-18:45
Room:
D-303
Chair:
Dana Moree

Contribution

In last roughly 5-8 years, we do anthropological researches in the field of school difficulties of children from the excluded localities (mainly Roma children) in Czech republic. Originally, we saw this subject as a question of cultural mismatch, essentially a conflict of values. However, our research experiences forced us to abandon this simple model. Roma culture and connected problems cannot be seen in isolation. It needs to be considered in the context of its relation to the majority culture/ population. And the relationship towards the majority is defined by exclusion – from school, from job market, from communities. This exclusion has deep historical and economical roots and it means life in poverty and without much perspective for the future. The relationship of the state and of the majority towards the exclusion is complicated or even ambivalent. Racism is officially criticised and the phenomenon of exclusion is considered as an issue, however the state is rather clueless in how to solve the issue. During the last years, the political discourse was moreover dominated by the motive of load that unemployed people and other recipients of social benefits represent for the national budget to the point that they were (without much foundation) painted as the main cause of national economic crisis. Local communities are scared by tensions between the majority and the excluded heightened as the result of economic situation (high unemployment) and migration of Roma groups that started after privatizations of state or municipal – owned housings. The solution of the exclusion problem is undertaken now actively mainly by several NGOs, sometimes municipal governments, teachers and social workers, psychologists and educational counsellors. Their roles are also ambivalent as they provide help while sometimes (some of them) being seen as causes or bearers of responsibility for the situation.

All those helping professions enter into the complex of exclusion, help to formulate it, structure it, try to solve it and articulate it in the process. They also have to defend themselves and their position in the complex, make some sense of the whole situation. And now the core question of our research is: what concepts and folk-theories they employ for it? Their work contains many cognitive and speculative activities – based on descriptions, categorizations, operations that have immediate practical consequences. Since it always takes part in live social interactions, it is also very important how their excluded clients participate in it.

We often encountered the problem of „adequate reaction“ of the excluded towards the offered help. In our paper we concentrate on expectations that help providing professionals have regarding Roma and other socioculturally disadvantaged people. What kinds of cognitive constructs these professionals employ regarding the indigent and how it influences their decision-making and how their help is then understood by its recipients?
A main theoretical framework we employ the schema theory of Strauss and Quinn which we try to merge with psychoanalytic approach, especially Freud's analysis of anxiety and ways of its transfer on external objects.

Method

We are now in second year of our research, that builds on 6 years of previous researches. Our research employs mainly classical ethnographic research techniques. We build our network of informants in organic way in the field. It is necessary because of extemely sensitive subject matter. We start from already close informants and build on their own conacts etc. In the course of extending our informants network we collect data, conduct participant observations, and deep semi-structured interviews. We contact as NGOs, local institutions (or their deputies) as minorities members. Now we are in the mid of the project and our informants base is still growing as the research progresses. While the research advances we already start with early coding and conceptualization procedures. The collected data are analysed and interpreted according to the theory of cultural models of cognitive anthropology (C. Strauss, R. D'Andrade in Doubek 2011). Our research is was supported by the Czech Science Foundation project: Decision-making processes of helping professions in the area of intercultural relationship; P407/12/0547

Expected Outcomes

We would like to find responses to our questions regarding concepts and folk-theories that help providing professionals employ to asses, understand and manage their situation. They are on the border of exclusion, they fight it and intermediate it. It is important to to understand their view and role in the exclusion complex.

References

Allport, G. W. (2004). O povaze předsudků. [The Nature of Prejudice.] Praha : Prostor. Bittnerová, D., Doubek, D., Levinská, M. (2011) Funkce kulturních modelů ve vzdělávání. [Function of Cultural Models of Education.] Praha : Ermat, s.r.o. Kučera, Miloš. (2010) On writing and handwriting. Journal of Pedagogy, Vol. 1, Nr. 2, 2010, pp. 11- 28. Bourdieu, P. (1999). Teorie jednání. [Raison pratique] Praha : Karolinum. Člověk v tísni. [People in need ](2009). Analýza individuálního přístupu pedagogů k žákům se speciálním vzdělávacími potřebami. [Analysis of teachers' individual aproach to pupils with special needs] [On line] Praha : MŠMT, duben 2011. Available on . EUMC. (May 2006). Roma and Travellers in Public Education. An overview of the situation in the EU Member States. [On line]Vienna : EUMC, únor 2008. Available on . Foucault, M. (2000). Dohlížet a trestat. Kniha o zrodu vězení. [Surveiller at punir: naissance de la prison.] Praha: Dauphin. Freud, S. (1971). Vybrané spisy Sigmunda Freuda – Svazek III. Práce k teorii sexuality. Práce k učení o neurosách. Práce k psychoanalytické technice. [Selected writings of Sigmund Freud - III. Sexual theory.] Praha : Aviceum. GAC, spol. s.r.o. (2009). Vzdělanostní dráhy a vzdělanostní šance romských žákyň a žáků základních škol v okolí vyloučených romských lokalit. [Educational career and educational chances of Roma pupils at basic schools located near by roma excluded localities] [On line] Praha : MŠMT, duben 2011. Available on . Goffman. E. (1963). Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity. New Jersey, U. S .A.: Prentice Hall Inc. Strauss, C. - Quinn, N. (2003). A cognitive theory of cultural meaning. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Štech, S. (1992). Sociálně kulturní pojetí handicapu. [Socio-cultural conception of handicap] Vágnerová, M.; Hadj Mousová, Z.; Štech, S. Psychologie handicapu. [Psychology of handicap] Praha : Univerzita Karlova, s. 18-32.

Author Information

David Doubek (presenting / submitting)
Faculty of Education, Charles University, Prague, Czech republic
Deparment of Psychology
Prague
Marketa Levinska (presenting)
Faculty of Education
Pedagogy and Psychology
Hradec Kralove
Faculty of Education, Charles University, Prague, Czech republic, Czech Republic

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.